• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Official Ranked Xmas Mafia 2024 - Where Worlds Collide

Okay, I don’t get much out of Sparks‘ ISO except that she‘s not scum with Prif, Fuji, Magic, Lethal, Ratchet and Alco.

So if she‘s scum I‘m comfortable locking Ratchet as Town/non Mafia (don’t see him being Indie tho, so likely just Town in that case.) The way she approached him and called him Ratchy reminds me of how she buddied him in the Boys. Not how she treats team mates.
What about on her own merits? I have no idea how to read her to be honest, so I'm basing my suspicion purely on how Melkor handled his interactions with her. Which has a risk of being unfair towards her.
 
What about on her own merits? I have no idea how to read her to be honest, so I'm basing my suspicion purely on how Melkor handled his interactions with her. Which has a risk of being unfair towards her.
That’s also what I‘m basing my read on for the most part, but she also avoided voting him, so it was mutual. I do think her vote on me for pressure was fine given how she said in the other thread she reads me, but that is all that I think could be Townie about her.
 
Town leader reporting in, Christmas aligned.
Kinda LAMIST entrance.
Lynch Pqwerty
This post gave me the ick.

Can someone summarize the other 7 pages?
The vote itself for the post in question isn’t bad.
Why arent you banning them then

Anyone else feel like this post does not match up with the other Pqwerty scatterbrain posts? Seems quite defensive.
I can see that.
What about it?

Do you think that is a scummy trait or are you just trying to direct the town leader's attention away from you?
Again LAMIST.
I read a few pages and while Pqwerty was in hot water, it was for completely different reasons and his play style seems vastly different.

He looks to have been targetted for being too self-aware and coming off as forced. That seems quite different from the first few pages in this game.

Pqwerty is playing like trash. Linking a 100 page game and insinuating he was playing similar there (which he was not) is truly bizarre.

Great, so we agree he is playing like trash which deserves attention.


No thanks.


This geniunely feels like a slip to me, @Lappland .
What is even the purpose behind the post? The first paragraph serves no purpose.

This is valuable information and completely contradicts Lapplands posts where he claims this is normal behaviour for Pqwerty.

My feelings on the Pqwerty wagon have been reinforced.

You call this analysis? lmao


:tiredofthis

Why in the world do you like this reads list from guilo? The post offers no value.

This has to be one of the worst posts in the thread.

Thoughts on this?

What evidence contradicts my read?

The reasoning provided against the read so far is: “Oh he is just a bad player that overreacts”.

I’m fine with that as a day 1 wagon. Especially with people coming out of the woodwork to defend him with absurd reasoning.

Truly disturbing that this day scattered away without any claim from Pqwerty.

RIP Poyser, very impressive day 1 reading

I don’t mind a guillo lynch here.
Probably not scum with Guillo.
I am undecided if Melkor defending Pqwerty is an indication of town/scum alignment for Pqwerty, probably more likely to be town. I think Ultra may have been spot on with Melkor good guying a weak, eccentric townie. I still despise Pqwerty's posts and the misinformation they bring but I'll put that to the side for now.


Lappland defending Pqwerty in the same fashion as Melkor and using weak reasoning/evidence (which I have talked about before).


This post has not aged well for Aurelian.


I have a hard time reading what this bolded part at the end is specifically insinuating but it seems important, @EkkoLoJinx


I think Poyser was killed for this post.

I am down for a guillo or Brutus wagon.

Vote Brutus

His posts are truly disturbing as Flower mentions, skating around and providing no actual input.
He voted for Watson (at 8 votes) when Melkor was at 13 votes with 3 hours left.
Doesn’t look like a bus vote if Brutus is scum.
Generally on the fence wrt Jigsaw. But I do kinda buy it that he genuinely believes he‘s onto smth wrt Pqwerty and suspecting Lappland for his defense of Pqwerty makes sense from that angle. I also don’t think he would be bussing Brutus here based on my posts since my standing in the thread isn’t the best rn either, so why try appeasing to me. Makes no sense. Idt he‘s scum with Guillo either.

Could be Town in all honesty even though I find his push on Pqwerty whack.
 
This post has not aged well for Aurelian.
You do realize I eventually circled back and parked my vote on Melkor right? Not that it bothers me much but you haven't been on the ball much here and I do remember Poyser was looking in your direction as another push/flip when he got killed N1. Anyway, gonna re-read a bit more of day 2's earlier posts to sort through.
 
Kinda LAMIST entrance.
The vote itself for the post in question isn’t bad.



I can see that.



Again LAMIST.























Probably not scum with Guillo.



Doesn’t look like a bus vote if Brutus is scum.
Generally on the fence wrt Jigsaw. But I do kinda buy it that he genuinely believes he‘s onto smth wrt Pqwerty and suspecting Lappland for his defense of Pqwerty makes sense from that angle. I also don’t think he would be bussing Brutus here based on my posts since my standing in the thread isn’t the best rn either, so why try appeasing to me. Makes no sense. Idt he‘s scum with Guillo either.

Could be Town in all honesty even though I find his push on Pqwerty whack.
alright. can you name everyone who tried pushing you so far
 
4. Magic - Town/Indie
6. Ekko - null
7. Alexis - null
8. Aurelian - Town lean
9. Watson - Town/Indie (non hostile)
10. Lappland - Town lean
11. Evans - Scum lean
12. Fuji - Town lean
14. Lethal - Town lean
15. Tweet - Town lean
16. Ultra - Town lean
17. Rugrat - Town lean
18. Ratchet - GTH Town
19. Tpein - null
20. Alco - GTH Town
21. GoddessBlade - Town lean
22. Chuck - Town lean
23. Pqwerty - Town lean
24. Guillo - null
25. Seraphoenix - Town lean
26. Sparkles - scum lean
27. Jigsaw - GTH Town
28. Brutus - scum lean
29. Dr Prof - Town lean
30. X - GTH Town
Leaves a PoE of:

Evans/Sparkles/Brutus/Guillo/Pein/Alexis

Can fit Ekko in there if Guillo is Town.

X could be a possible blind spot for me, but else I feel pretty good about my Town reads.

Ratchet is probably just Town. Don‘t see him aligned with my other scum leans.

Alexis is self resolving with his claim tho, so not really a lynch candidate for me.
 
alright. can you name everyone who tried pushing you so far
The one who stood out the most to me is Brutus. Magic is either washed or Indie. Ultra is just Town. Ekko can also be scum, but I can also see him scum reading me as Town for giving him the PR which is understandable Ig.
 
Back
Top