• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Dune Mafia - town victory

Status
Not open for further replies.
Are you…? Dumb?

It is obvious that by claims i mean pr claims!

This fucking guy

If we have 3 people claiming VT, logically pushing people outside of that will result in PR claims. Scum have them. Town have them. Like 75% of players in the game have a PR.

This makes literally no sense.
 
It is in a game with vanillas in play.
Im not gonna go and risk throwing the game helping you lynch the potential town watcher.
Giving scum good looking roles to claim is standard practice on here. The only AI roles really are miller, cop, vig. The way you play is gonna lose you most of the games
 
It is in a game with vanillas in play.
Im not gonna go and risk throwing the game helping you lynch the potential town watcher.

Very weird angle you're taking here

The logical consequences of trying to lynch anyone who hasn't claimed yet is gonna result in PR claims, you seem to have no issue with doing so today.

I have no issue reconciling the fact that you don't really, you know, think very hard about what you're doing. But this happens to be something I feel like scum would say if they can't defend someone on merit
 
Yeah I have no interest in lynching a Watcher claim here. Not going to defend Watson on play but I don't think the angle is all that compelling. Most of all, seeing Ultra jump all over it tells me it's something he is actively looking for, so ya I won't be voting there today.

Would rather lynch Flower and even then I don't think she's the best option. Ultra/Aurelian.
 
This fucking guy

If we have 3 people claiming VT, logically pushing people outside of that will result in PR claims. Scum have them. Town have them. Like 75% of players in the game have a PR.

This makes literally no sense.
Ok then yah you are dumb or playing dumb.

We have not mass claimed and the pr claim we have besides mine, is Watson's. So if either of our claims are true, scum will have no choice but to kill us. You say noone believes my claim, ok fine, let's pretend we go 8nto the night with that belief. If Watson is town, she has a realistic survival rate of two more games.
If she is town watcher, if there is a doctor, they will protect her.
Doctor cant save a player consecutively right?
So scum will nail Watson the following night.
If they dont, then maybe Watson is mafia and we lynch her.
 
Yeah I have no interest in lynching a Watcher claim here. Not going to defend Watson on play but I don't think the angle is all that compelling. Most of all, seeing Ultra jump all over it tells me it's something he is actively looking for, so ya I won't be voting there today.

Would rather lynch Flower and even then I don't think she's the best option. Ultra/Aurelian.

Predictable tbh
 
Ok then yah you are dumb or playing dumb.

We have not mass claimed and the pr claim we have besides mine, is Watson's. So if either of our claims are true, scum will have no choice but to kill us. You say noone believes my claim, ok fine, let's pretend we go 8nto the night with that belief. If Watson is town, she has a realistic survival rate of two more games.
If she is town watcher, if there is a doctor, they will protect her.
Doctor cant save a player consecutively right?
So scum will nail Watson the following night.
If they dont, then maybe Watson is mafia and we lynch her.
Doctor can theoretically target the same player consecutively, yes
 
I’m not joking about ratchet btw

Yesterday he hard sheeped my sparkles read, today he has no interest in weighing up the points I’ve made about her play despite the fact I’m pretty much always right on Watson too
 
I’m not joking about ratchet btw

Yesterday he hard sheeped my sparkles read, today he has no interest in weighing up the points I’ve made about her play despite the fact I’m pretty much always right on Watson too
I don't think you're any more accurate than I am on Watson. And on play I don't have much ti defend her with, but I don't think she's been that bad either. Her recent scun games are a departure from this, think the worst you can accuse her of her is lacking consistency, which, for Watson, isn't really a scum tell.
 
Very weird angle you're taking here

The logical consequences of trying to lynch anyone who hasn't claimed yet is gonna result in PR claims, you seem to have no issue with doing so today.

I have no issue reconciling the fact that you don't really, you know, think very hard about what you're doing. But this happens to be something I feel like scum would say if they can't defend someone on merit
You can gaslight and sus me for this all you want, i will get in the way of killing the claimed Watcher today, all step of the way.
In fact, if you were to wagon me and Watson, make us competing wagons and we are tied, i'd self vote to save her.
 
Yeah she's self resolving bro. Damn we better lynch her at lylo bro.

It's not strictly speaking wrong but you've used this defense historically for your partners who have claimed invests
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top