Game Ranked Dune Mafia - town victory

[.guillo]

Reads, let's go

i posted my reads yesterday.

Day has barely started, so those reads have not changed.

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Discord?

Can we clear guillo off of that post?

 

[One Last Username]

It is not OMGUS it is common sense, i threw the bait out and he bit the bait.

What about your other posts? Because it’s not just one that I’m onto you about.

 

[Poyser]

Lmao he actually unironically said it was bait

 

[Poyser]

I didn't really feel like he's that town

yall just kinda gaslit me

Thought you gaslit me

 

[Ultra]

i posted my reads yesterday.

Day has barely started, so those reads have not changed.

This suggests you have Watson as firm town, but I didn't get that impression from your posts so far. Sounds like you're waffling about her being scum but haven't changed your PoE at all. Not good.

 

[One Last Username]

Right, i would just like… claim im scum even though no scum has flipped, only town and indies, meaning scum is winning and i just giving up just because…, =/

Torn don’t have fake claims, so from my point of view, town is doing well. Scum and big taking out threats to the house of atreides.

 

[.guillo]

There is motivation for doing it as scum tho, however bad you think it may be

I don’t see an explanation for what she’s thinking to do it as town. Bear in mind, literally like an hour earlier she voted flower and I called her out for putting flower close to hammer whilst acknowledging we wanted more from other people. She conceded I was right and unvoted. Then she hammers her on purpose lmao

It’s so obvious

Ok but why do that as scum?

Like if she is scum there… she just threw the towel, the game? Why?

To maje Ratchet, me and whoever else defended her look bad maybe? At the cost of her own life when the people defending her could buy time for her?

If she is scum, i would like to ask her why, cause i dont see the logic to do it as scum, granted, nor i do see it as town, but … like scum is winning now, why do it there after we saved her and got flower in range to lynch her, Watson was safe, there was no need to do it.

 

[Ultra]

Thought you gaslit me

Let's just blame CP and move on

 

[Luka]

okay guys i think i figured out the gimmick of this setup
their are 5 towns. the rest of yall are wolves.

it matches up with how the games going so far imo

 

[.guillo]

This suggests you have Watson as firm town, but I didn't get that impression from your posts so far. Sounds like you're waffling about her being scum but haven't changed your PoE at all. Not good.

Then you are blind cause ive been saying that Watson's wild play yesterday is likely to come from town than scum. Seems like you are gonna have to wait, i think by now you should know i dont do anything i dont wanna do.

 

[One Last Username]

Ok but why do that as scum?

Like if she is scum there… she just threw the towel, the game? Why?

To maje Ratchet, me and whoever else defended her look bad maybe? At the cost of her own life when the people defending her could buy time for her?

If she is scum, i would like to ask her why, cause i dont see the logic to do it as scum, granted, nor i do see it as town, but … like scum is winning now, why do it there after we saved her and got flower in range to lynch her, Watson was safe, there was no need to do it.

A valiant effort for your faction. Respect. I almost believed you.

 

[.guillo]

Torn don’t have fake claims, so from my point of view, town is doing well. Scum and big taking out threats to the house of atreides.

We havent flipped a single scum, i dont feel we are doung well.

 

[Arne Slot]

Let's just blame CP and move on

Ratchet said it too! We were mind melding!

 

[.guillo]

A valiant effort for your faction. Respect. I almost believed you.

Thank you, i'll make sure to let them know you said hi.

 

[One Last Username]

okay guys i think i figured out the gimmick of this setup
their are 5 towns. the rest of yall are wolves.

it matches up with how the games going so far imo

What I worry more about is where is that freakin worm?

 

[Ultra]

Ok but why do that as scum?

Like if she is scum there… she just threw the towel, the game? Why?

To maje Ratchet, me and whoever else defended her look bad maybe? At the cost of her own life when the people defending her could buy time for her?

If she is scum, i would like to ask her why, cause i dont see the logic to do it as scum, granted, nor i do see it as town, but … like scum is winning now, why do it there after we saved her and got flower in range to lynch her, Watson was safe, there was no need to do it.

I find your level of WIFOM here very suspect

I don't think there's anything wrong with your argument per se, but...considering how you've played the rest of the game, you seem like you have the nuance and consideration of a boulder when it comes to scum reading people.

You seem very reactionary in fact. You call basically everything that is sus on a level 1 basis SCUM and don't leave much room for argument

So I don't buy that you're not calling a spade a spade in this particular instance.

 

[Ultra]

Should specify, I don't think there's anything with your argument not knowing much of anything about Watson. Because yes, she could do that, and multiple players have told you as much

 

[.guillo]

Ratchet lol

Can a double voter be motivated?

 

[.guillo]

Should specify, I don't think there's anything with your argument not knowing much of anything about Watson. Because yes, she could do that, and multiple players have told you as much

Ok if she would do that kind of play as scum then she could be in fact scum for it as there is alleged precedent for it.

But dude, why do it? What is the fucking benefit.

If she is scum i'll just clear Ratchet for it.