2023 Year End Awards Nominations

[Magic]

YOU DON'T HAVE TO ANSWER EVERY CATEGORY, ANSWER WHAT YOU KNOW. THANK YOU.

Best Overall Player
Best Town Player
Best Scum Player
Best Host
Best Newcomer
Most Improved
Most Underrated
Most Dedicated
Best Mafia Team Performance
Best Game
Best Post-Game
Best Feud
Best Fake Claim
Best Individual Performance
LOL Moment of the Year
Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance
Worst Mafia Team Performce
Most Overrated
Biggest Meltdown

Please nominate at most 3 people for each category. We'll give at most a week for nominations. No self voting for individual awards. You may vote for your team in team performance awards.

After nominations have been collected a new thread will be made showing the 3/4 most nominated individuals. We will then request everyone to vote for a single nominee in each category via PM.

We understand you didn't play every game, have played limited games, etc. This is just for fun. Please do participate and nominate based on what you know and, as best as you can, avoid being biased in your nominations/voting(which obviously can't be enforced). The more votes the better.

 

[Magic]

Best Overall Player:

ratchet
ultra

Best Town Player

craig
ultra
gram

Best Scum Player

ratchet
gram
rdk

Best Host

gram
ratchet

Best Newcomer

nibel

Most Improved

hime
tweet


Most Underrated

rugrat
rdk
lord melkor


Most Dedicated

flower
watson
ekko

Best Mafia Team Performance

Medival fantasy mafia

Best Game

Monster Hunter World
All of us are dead.

Best Post-Game

will edit

Best Feud

flower v ratchet

Best Fake Claim

Tpein in baki

Best Individual Performance

ultra in one piece wano
tpein in skyrim mafia
rugrat in christmas mafia

LOL Moment of the Year

evans dueling his own teammate in darkest dungeon and them both dying

Worst Mafia Team Performce

darkest dungeon mafia
skyrim mafia
one piece wano arc mafia

Most Overrated

tpein

Biggest Meltdown


joygirl in anon mafia
flower in one piece wano mafia
rugrat in the dead qt of a game i dont even know if he was in while he was drunk.

 

[Magic]

Spoiler

@Grammaton @Emil @Flower @Lethal @Sky @DoflaMihawk @Magic @hime @RDK @Gadministraitor @Ultra @T-Pein™ @Ratchet @Chairman Nibel @Tempest @Aurelian @Dr. Watson @Evans @Caldust @Dr_Professor83 @Big Man @Ral @Hans Tweetenberg @Whicker @Alco @Lord Melkor @Frinckles @Mr. Reloaded

 

[Magic]

Spoiler

@Xadlin @Sigismund @Chuck @Fujishiro @GoddessBlade @Great Potato @Kurumi @Kurosaki Ichigo @Bachi @Doddsy @Psychic @Polar Bear @The Orca @Hayumi @Penguini @The X @Poyser @Rej @PHEN0M @Goth Boy @Aries @Dalton @Oneiros @Cubey @Aersoldorf @Imposter @Naomi

 

[Magic]

Spoiler

@ConquistadoR @MangoSenpai @Odd @Mashiro Blue @Natalija @TSworder @RÆM @Platinum @TAT @Kobe @Juliet @Ruffles @Poison @Chadwick_Winebarger @SoulKiller @Indigo @xenos5 @One Last Username @Nevermind @Rottkins

 

[T-Pein™]

Template
Copy and paste.

[B][I]Best Overall Player:[/I][/B]

[I][B]Best Town Player:[/I][/B]

[I][B]Best Scum Player:[/I][/B]

[I][B]Best Host:[/B][/I]

[B][I]Best Newcomer:[/I][/B]

[I][B]Most Improved:[/B][/I]

[B][I]Most Underrated:[/I][/B]

[I][B]Most Dedicated:[/I][/B]

[I][B]Best Mafia Team Performance:[/B][/I]

[B][I]Best Game:[/I][/B]

[I][B]Best Post-Game:[/I][/B]

[I][B]Best Feud:[/I][/B]

[I][B]Best Fake Claim:[/B][/I]

[B][I]Best Individual Performance:[/I][/B]

[I][B]LOL Moment of the Year:[/I][/B]

[I][B]Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance:[/I][/B]

[I][B]Worst Mafia Team Performance:[/I][/B]

[I][B]Most Overrated:[/B][/I]

[B][I]Biggest Meltdown:[/I][/B]

 

[T-Pein™]

Best Overall Player:
Tempest (Craigpelton)

Best Town Player:
Tempest (CP)
Ultra

Best Scum Player:
Ekkologix
Ratchet Kun
Tweet

Best Host:
Gramma

Best Newcomer:
Psychic
Orca / Polar

Most Improved:
Hime

Most Underrated:
Ekkologix
Aurelian

Most Dedicated:
Flower
Ekko

Best Mafia Team Performance:
Need to check

Best Game:
Darkest Dungeon

Best Post-Game:
Members Mafia

Best Feud:
X vs Poyser

Best Fake Claim:
Tweet fake claims a meme PR and carries him to a W.

Best Individual Performance:
Will edit.

LOL Moment of the Year:
Will edit

Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance:
Lethal - Gets lynched
Rugrat - Was SK and thought he was town vig

Worst Mafia Team Performance:
Imma say the first time mafia lost the streak.

Most Overrated:
Magic
Poyser

Biggest Meltdown:
Flower on members mafia goes down calling the scums cheaters.

Joygirl - Limegate

 

[Emil]

off top of my head. will edit later if more stuff pop up

Best Overall Player:

• Ultra

Best Town Player:

• Ultra
• CP

Best Scum Player:

• Ratchet
• Magic

Best Host:

• Gram
• RDK

Best Newcomer:

• Nibel
• Gad
• Mr. Reloaded

Most Improved:

• Aurelian
• Lethal
• Hime

Most Underrated:

•  Sky
• T-pein
• Psychic
• Tweet

Most Dedicated:

• Flower
• Prof

Best Mafia Team Performance:

• Mideval Fantasy
• Eastenders
• Hades Mafia

Best Game:

• Elden Ring
• Monster Hunter World
• Baki Mafia

Best Post-Game:

• MHW being the first town win had a good banter post game
• Anonymous Mafia drama was the funniest post game

Best Feud:

• Hime vs Cake
• Poyser vs X
• Ultra vs Polar/Orca

Best Fake Claim:

• Watson's Zeus Martyr Bodyguard claim in Hades created by Magic
• Dofla's giga chad claim in Hime's game
• Nibel fake claiming a result in Baki's lylo

Best Individual Performance:

• Ultra as scum in the Traitors Mafia and as indie/town in most post MHW games
• CP as town in MHW and Xmas
• Watson as scum in Radiant Mafia

LOL Moment of the Year:

• Evans duelling his teammate CP and both getting yeeted in Darkest Dungeon
• Evans accidentally outing his whole team in Final Fantasy Mafia
• Ultra jokingly typing execute in thread only to have Gram coincidentally get executed in Wrestling Mafia

Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance:

• Lethal in Elden Ring
• X in Darkest Dungeon
• Magic/Purple in Anonymous Mafia

Worst Mafia Team Performance:

• Darkest Dungeon
• One Piece Wano Mafia

Most Overrated:

• Gram (more rusty than overrated)
• Ace Dalton

Biggest Meltdown:

• Joygirl in Anonymous post game
• Flower in every post game where she solos the mafia team from day 1 but loses. Xmas game for a quick recent sample
• Ratchet in Mideval Fantasy post game

​

 

[Flower]

B]Best Overall Player:[/B]
Magic
Ratchet
Gram

Best Town Player:
Magic
CP
Ultra

Best Scum Player:
Magic
Ratchet

Best Host:
Grammaton

Best Newcomer:
Luka

Most Improved:
Hime
Watson

Most Underrated:
Gad
Hime

Most Dedicated:
Prof
Ekko

Best Mafia Team Performance:
Medieval Team

Best Game:
Elden Ring

Best Post-Game:
Idk, never read those or I‘m too busy having a meltdown to read them in full.

Best Feud:
Ratchet vs Ultra


Best Fake Claim:
Phenom and X Lovers claim

Best Individual Performance:
Ultra in Darkest Dungeon
Ratchet in Members

LOL Moment of the Year:
Evans dueling CP

Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance:
Fang in Radiant

Worst Mafia Team Performance:
The team from Wano

Most Overrated:
-

Biggest Meltdown:
Me every game (I can‘t deny it).

 

[Sky]

haven't filled in all, only played half the year

Best Overall Player - Magic
Best Town Player - Magic
Best Scum Player - Ratchet
Best Host - Gram
Best Newcomer - Gadministraitor
Most Improved
Most Underrated - Gadministraitor
Most Dedicated - Flower
Best Mafia Team Performance
Best Game - All Of Us Are Dead prob
Best Post-Game - Anonymous because of LIMEGATE
Best Feud - Ultra vs. anyone who doesn't give him an award
Best Fake Claim
Best Individual Performance
LOL Moment of the Year - Evans duels his scum mate (Darkest Dungeon); Ral fakes character as town then T-Pein flips with that same character as his safe scum fake (Christmas); Cubey has the worst vig performance ever including shooting his own backup (ITYSL)
Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance - Cubey in ITYSL
Worst Mafia Team Performance - One Piece Wano, it was a team I was in but yeah
Most Overrated - T-Pein because anyone rates him at all
Biggest Meltdown - the Cakey one in literally every game

 

[Ultra]

Best Overall Player:

Ratchet

Best Town Player:

CP

Best Scum Player:

Magic

Best Host:

Gram

Best Newcomer:

Gad
Frinckles

Most Improved:

Tweet

Most Underrated:

Rugrat
RDK
Ekko

Most Dedicated:

Flower
Ekko

Best Mafia Team Performance:

Eastenders Mafia
Medieval Mafia

Best Game:

TRAITORS MAFIA
Monster Hunters World Mafia
Darkest Dungeon Mafia

Best Post-Game:

TBD

Best Feud:

X vs Poyser

Best Fake Claim:

TBD

Best Individual Performance:

TBD

LOL Moment of the Year:

Gad claiming he's Indian with Curry's role
Evans outting his entire team in Fate
Evans Dueling CP, and aftermath (Pic Related)

Spoiler

Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance:

Aurelian killing himself as Serial (Members)

Worst Mafia Team Performance:

Darkest Dungeon

Most Overrated:

CP (Scum)

Biggest Meltdown:

Joygirlgate

 

[hime]

Best Overall Player:

• Ultra

Best Town Player:

• Magic
• Ultra

Best Scum Player:

• Ratchet
• Ultra

Best Host:

• Grammaton

Best Newcomer:

• Whicker
• Nibel

Most Improved:

• Dr. Watson

Most Underrated:

• Ekkologix
• Psychic

Most Dedicated:

• Flower

Best Mafia Team Performance:

• Not sure yet

Best Game:

• Members Mafia

Best Post-Game:

• Members Mafia
• Anonymous Mafia

Best Feud:

• Ultra vs Polar
• Ultra vs Women

Best Fake Claim:

• Not sure yet

Best Individual Performance:

• Ultra in Darkest Dungeon
• RDK in Fairytail
• Ratchet in Members

LOL Moment of the Year:

• Evans dueling CraigPelton (his teammate) and both of them dying the same phase
• Evans posting a list of people to kill (that had everyone but his team) and then claiming it was a screenshot for work
• RDK claiming Aurelian's role and character and Aurelian not being able to convince anyone that it's his role
• Gadministraitor saying he got an Indian character in Members when it was Curry

Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance:

• Not sure yet

Worst Mafia Team Performance:

• One Piece Wano Arc

Most Overrated:

• Rugrat
• Ace Dalton

Biggest Meltdown:

• Joygirl during the Lime incident
• Flower when she left the forum for awhile
• Flower (town) cussing town out (in a game they won) for lynching her after she got a guilty on her

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

Best Overall Player:
Ratchet
CP
Ultra

Best Town Player:
Ultra
CP
RDK

Best Scum Player:
Ratchet
Ultra

Best Host:
Grammaton
Poyser
Ekko

Best Newcomer:
Nibel
Frinckles

Most Improved:
Sky
Retro

Most Underrated:
Lord Melkor
Rugrat
RDK

Most Dedicated:
Flower
Aurelian
Ekko

Best Mafia Team Performance:
EastEnders
OLF Members

Best Game:
Monster Hunter World
Elden Ring
Hades

Best Post-Game:
Christmas Mafia
Fate/Mafia

Best Feud:
Ultra vs Women
Fang vs X
Flower vs Ratchet

Best Fake Claim:
Zeus Seraph Bodyguard (Retro, Hades Mafia)
Vanilla Cop (Ekko, Christmas Mafia)

Best Individual Performance:
Ratchet in OLF Members Mafia
Ultra in One Piece Wano Arc
CP in Hades

LOL Moment of the Year:
Three dead Mafia at the end of D1 (One Piece Wano)
Ultra tells an emotional Flower to get back in the kitchen (MHW postgame)
Evans duels his own teammate and they both get voted out (Darkest Dungeon)

Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance:
Evans in Darkest Dungeon
Ekko in Fallout New Vegas
T-Pein in Monster Hunter World

Worst Mafia Team Performance:
One Piece Wano Arc
Darkest Dungeon

Most Overrated:
The X
Polar Bear
Psychic

Biggest Meltdown:
Flower in MHW postgame
Everyone in Christmas Mafia postgame

 

[Aurelian]

Best Overall Player:

Grammaton
Ultra

Best Town Player:

Grammaton
Ratchet
Poyser
CraigPelton

Best Scum Player:

Ratchet
Ultra
Grammaton
Magic
RDK

Best Host:

Grammaton
Hime
Ekko

Best Newcomer:

Retro (Dr_Watson)

Most Improved:

Retro
Nibel
Lethal

Most Underrated:

Ekko
Tweet
Evans
RDK

Most Dedicated:

Ekko
Ratchet

Best Mafia Team Performance:

Eastenders Mafia
New Vegas Mafia
Members Mafia

Best Game:

New Vegas (Ultra hosted)
All of Us Are Dead (Hime hosted)

Best Post-Game:

MHW?

Best Feud:

X vs Poyser
Ekko vs Ratchet
Flower vs Ratchet
Joygirl vs Everyone (Among Us Mafia)
Evans vs T-Pein

Best Fake Claim:

Tweet (Members Mafia)

Best Individual Performance:

Idk

LOL Moment of the Year:

Evans dueling Joygirl and both scum members getting lynched in Darkest Dungeon
Ekko trying to push IC/town Grammaton to be lynched in New Vegas Mafia
Me killing myself shooting Magic in Members Mafia

Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance:

Not touching this

Worst Mafia Team Performance:

Skyrim
Darkest Dungeon

Most Overrated:

Not touching this

Biggest Meltdown:

Dunno

 

[Aurelian]

@Magic nothing for indies?

 

[Xadlin]

Most Dedicated:
Ekko

Best Mafia Team Performance:
Melkor
Ultra
Tweet
Best Game:
Bleach game

Best Feud:
every old timer mafia players that always love making drama when they play lol
eveything that involves T-pein

Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance:
Me

Most Underrated:
Gram
fellow swedish speakers are hard to find

 

[RDK]

Best Overall Player: magic, gram, ultra

Best Town Player: magic, cp

Best Scum Player: magic

Best Host: gram

Best Newcomer: nibel

Most Improved: retro

Most Underrated: hime

Most Dedicated: retro, flower

Best Mafia Team Performance: Fairytale, Eastenders

Best Game: fairytale

Best Post-Game:

Best Feud:

Best Fake Claim: tweet xmas

Best Individual Performance:

LOL Moment of the Year:

Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance: Cubey in ITYSL, Flower using town tell in Fairytale

Worst Mafia Team Performance:

Most Overrated:

Biggest Meltdown: flower anytime she is sussed

 

[Tempest]

Best Overall Player:

Ratchet
Magic
Ultra

Best Town Player:

Magic
Gram
Ultra

Best Scum Player:

Ratchet
Magic
RDK

Best Host:

Gram
Ultra

Best Newcomer:

Luka
Nibel

Most Underrated:

Luka

Most Dedicated:

Ratchet

Best Game:

Monster Hunter World

Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance:

Evans dueling his teammate without any discussion in Darkest Dungeon

 

[Gaddamnit]

Best Overall Player - Magic
Best Town Player - Boobies
Best Scum Player - Ratchet
Best Host - idk
Best Newcomer - Luka
Most Improved - Nipples
Most Underrated - Fang
Most Dedicated - Flower
Best Mafia Team Performance - idk
Best Game - idk
Best Post-Game -
Best Feud - Fang vs. someone I forgot oops
Best Fake Claim - Retro's claim that one game I believed her but I was the only one so idk...
Best Individual Performance - Boobies
LOL Moment of the Year - Cubey almost shooting us as scum but shooting exclusively town cause he got triggered.
Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance - Cubey as vig, or maybe this is the best performance
Worst Mafia Team Performance - One where Ekko was caught day 1.
Most Overrated - Ehhhhhhhh Magic? He's accurate but manages to not push it properly imo or at least people don't believe him cause he's too good and they assume he's lying.
Biggest Meltdown - Flower when pushed too much that one game

 

[Grammaton]

Best Overall Player:

Ratchet

Best Town Player:

CP
Ultra
Ratchet

Best Scum Player:

Ratchet
Tweet

Best Host:

Can I vote myself here lol

Best Newcomer:

Nibel

Most Improved:

Hime

Most Underrated:

Tpein

Most Dedicated:

Flower

Best Mafia Team Performance:

Medieval

Best Game:

Monster Hunter World

Best Post-Game:

Monster Hunter World

Best Feud:

Magic vs Tpein

Best Fake Claim:

Ekko in Xmas Mafia

Best Individual Performance:

CP in Members Mafia

LOL Moment of the Year:

MHW Postgame

Most Shockingly Bad Individual Performance:

Cubey Vig

Worst Mafia Team Performance:

Darkest Dungeon

Most Overrated:

N/A

Biggest Meltdown:

Flower MHW
Limegate