- It's that time of the year again! Just kidding, we were late.
Click here to see the awards and nominate people for the rest of the categories.
- We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!
- Thread starter EkkoLoJinx
- Start date
- Status
The Orca
Antihero
Why does Aurelian's death matter at all? Explain a scenario where it does?
.guillo
Exceptional
I dont care about your personal accomplishments, here you are just another player like any of us and this game will only be win if town works together, not with ego driven solo players.
I jailed Tweet last night.
I don't really like Ultra's insistence of forcing a dichotomy between Whicker and myself here. His argument that an even night busdriver and a multi shot jailer cannot possibly exist on the same side is pretty reaching, and when I've asked he's failed to actually make an argument of it. An even night busdriver will, realistically, only get 2 uses, and from a numbers perspective unless the action is perfect it doesn't reduce the numbers loss. A jailer straight up stops the kill. So to argue that town's core protection must be one of the two... makes little sense.
I think Whicker can be scum on his own merits, and I think Ultra going for Whicker first over me here looks decent for him. Just feeling a bit paranoid about how this sentiment isn't getting challenged when it has holes in it to me.
I don't really like Ultra's insistence of forcing a dichotomy between Whicker and myself here. His argument that an even night busdriver and a multi shot jailer cannot possibly exist on the same side is pretty reaching, and when I've asked he's failed to actually make an argument of it. An even night busdriver will, realistically, only get 2 uses, and from a numbers perspective unless the action is perfect it doesn't reduce the numbers loss. A jailer straight up stops the kill. So to argue that town's core protection must be one of the two... makes little sense.
I think Whicker can be scum on his own merits, and I think Ultra going for Whicker first over me here looks decent for him. Just feeling a bit paranoid about how this sentiment isn't getting challenged when it has holes in it to me.
The Orca
Antihero
I continue to be baffled by some of your thoughts
.guillo
Exceptional
Cause he is a low poster whom sussed Watson the most.
The Orca
Antihero
So you think mafia had 2 kills N1?
.guillo
Exceptional
I assume Aurelian was the night kill cause the other was washed.
.guillo
Exceptional
I think Watson had motive to kill Aurelian, they are both admins on this site so i assume Aurelian knows Watson very well, enough to want to fear kill them.
I will read Watson and make an analysis though.
Another reservation I have with Ultra is that he apparently signed off on Flower dying when he surely knew that if I didn't stop a kill (which I almost certainly did) then even if town lynch correctly it's still dependent on night actions to bring the game back into being winnable, so it doesn't make any sense to threaten to shoot me when he must have been factoring in my ability to stop kills to some extent at some point in his risk calculus.
The Orca
Antihero
In a 19 person game mafia isn't gonna have 2 kills N1. A SK or vig took out Aurelian
So you're proposing the guy with 7 posts was the scum kill
So you think Melkor was janitored by town? Or SK?
Is this correct?
.guillo
Exceptional
RDK was obvious town, he towntold himself when he emotionally pushed Flower. Im not gonna say that they didnt kill them for their reads, i will look into that but RDK was very obvious lock town and scum gotta kill those.
That's an easy one - if you two are both town you'd probably just be dead.
The only reason you'd be alive here as town is in fact to delay resolving the wolf between you. If whicker's scum he can't kill you without basically outting himself.
.guillo
Exceptional
Could be, but we cant let any stone unturned.
I'm going to say my decision to lynch flower was about 50% on the basis of not strictly mechanical play, so please try to keep that in mind. I signed off on her lynch at like 4 am when I woke up and checked the thread and saw everything was still locked up. By the time I got back she was hammered
Aside from the above, I once again point out that there is exactly 0% chance Ekko includes a post restricted townie in his game which means OLU is lying about having one. It combines two things Ekko abhors the most - a skillless clear in that the role would be intended to do it for him, and post restrictions. Some people don't know Ekko very well as a host so I can understand why this hasn't been widely adopted, but no chance in hell the rest of you think he actually includes this.
what???
- Status