• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Unranked Bloodborne Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Magic said:
Good job m8. Took too long. The bachi assassination was bad too. You hung on too long on a weak point.
Click to expand...
This is silly, I was town reading Ekko about as early as I reasonably could. Before that I had very little to work with.

As far as Bachi goes, I maintain that he was making a nonsense argument that he didn't believe, and instead of conceding this argument he doubled down which brings hollow and ingenuine. I freely admit that I can see him not being scum over it, but I don't agree with you that he must be town - I think you're giving him too much of an out when all he has done is invent something that clearly isn't true and then stick to it.

There is also his reluctance to vote but that could be more personality.

Next?
 
Anyway Magic your claim that I've made no town reads doesn't stand up - you can say I haven't been terribly proactive with it which is true but that isn't scummy, and your qualifier that I didn't town read Ekko early enough is just silly given I read him about as early as he could be read lol.
 
Ratchet said:
Anyway Magic your claim that I've made no town reads doesn't stand up - you can say I haven't been terribly proactive with it which is true but that isn't scummy, and your qualifier that I didn't town read Ekko early enough is just silly given I read him about as early as he could be read lol.
Click to expand...

What is your current read on Magic then?
 
Lord Melkor said:
What is your current read on Magic then?
Click to expand...
I have none - I don't really think as scum he would immediately overextend like this so on the surface of it he could be town, but I'll acknowledge that he's smart enough to play into this WIFOM game. If I *had* to pick, Town, but I will first need to see his responses to my posts and what he proceeds to do. He loses some points from my perspective for being, well, wrong.
 
Lord Melkor said:
Really? I recall playing at least one game when he was active as scum and what I see from his so far is mostly fence-sitting.
Click to expand...
No you don't. He played twice as scum, the recent game and then one with me. His only contributions that game was pushing me, his teammate. Otherwise he struggled.and he overall still wasn't active.
 
Ratchet said:
I think this is forced too - Whicker has admitted that his activity is going to be on the low end regardless. I actually don't mind him so far but activity is not a reliable tell for him.
Click to expand...
Town reads aren't forced, they're easy. Easy for scum too yet the biggest difference I saw in your town and scum game was you weren't freely handing them out. It does not take a lot to see a number of people as town.
 
Magic said:
Town reads aren't forced, they're easy. Easy for scum too yet the biggest difference I saw in your town and scum game was you weren't freely handing them out. It does not take a lot to see a number of people as town.
Click to expand...
Yeah but I'm saying I have been looking to town clear some players - it's simply that I've only come to a solid one on Ekko and not anyone else. I don't fully agree with your Whicker read, I don't agree with Bachi, CP I can see being town but I don't have much to work with from him and Sky I was more or less at town anyway, with reservations. What am I missing from there?
 
Fujishiro said:
from software e3 GIF


Vote Lynch Bachi
Click to expand...
Why
 
Ratchet said:
Yeah but I'm saying I have been looking to town clear some players - it's simply that I've only come to a solid one on Ekko and not anyone else. I don't fully agree with your Whicker read, I don't agree with Bachi, CP I can see being town but I don't have much to work with from him and Sky I was more or less at town anyway, with reservations. What am I missing from there?
Click to expand...
You're missing timing. It's easier than you're making it but you hesitate cause you don't like town clearing people as scum. You do a few because you have to but overall you avoid it. When I say timing I mean I expected more and sooner. Fuck your apparent process, it doesn't take that long.
 
Magic said:
You're missing timing. It's easier than you're making it but you hesitate cause you don't like town clearing people as scum. You do a few because you have to but overall you avoid it. When I say timing I mean I expected more and sooner. Fuck your apparent process, it doesn't take that long.
Click to expand...
Eh, you're arguing squarely under the premise that I must be scum to make your point - you're not giving due consideration that I haven't made lots of town reads because I just haven't felt the need to do so yet. Again freely admit to being lazy - I would still wager I'm less lazy than the majority of the players in the game.

You're not really addressing the lack of opportunity too - if I disagree with Bachi being town what else have I egregiously missed on, from your perspective?
 
BalsamicBear said:
who are you protecting!

look look this one wont fight
who will this one protect at night
all the inactive people must be lost
we must turn them in a ghost
Click to expand...
Hunting for inactives is a cop out to avoid having to make reads on any actual active players. That doesn't mean we need to protect them but you made no posts trying to read anyone playing up until this point so there was nothing separating you from the inactives outside of the fact you could have made an attempt to read people.

You can go in the scum pile too. Would be happy to lynch.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top