All this is true because I want my wagon.Nu uh, you're leading him to an answer here. By explicitly focusing on the early on part, you give him less to defend his side with, because you easily demonstrate that my play wasn't obviously townie from the early parts of the day. You're not giving him room to flesh out his stance - he could be sheeping to generate a read, or he has a gut read that he wants to see followed through. Crucially, if he is scum, your question does nothing to put him to the test - you're giving him the argument he needs to adjust his position as and when he sees fit.