Circus of Humorous & Humiliating Arguments Part 4: Outskirts Ningen Dome - Laughing edition

[Proto234]

Actually at full blast, Caliburn is equivalent to atleast a non-broken sealed Excalibur(Even if it's destroyed in the process) so that can definitely kill everyone but Composite BB.

And there are enough NPs that can still be strong enough to get to BB as Summer BB basically IS BB at her strongest in CCC, that's why we see her original NP in that form rather than the far weaker version as the Welfare.

Even so, I don't think Summer BB has/utilize Potnia Theron, which is one of her broken authority
Also, does BB fulfills requirement for unlocking all 13 seals of Excalibur?

 

[Xhominid The Apex]

Even so, I don't think Summer BB has/utilize Potnia Theron, which is one of her broken authority
Also, does BB fulfills requirement for unlocking all 13 seals of Excalibur?

BB 100% fits all of the requirements to get Excaliblasted at full power.
And again, while Summer BB doesn't have Potnia Theron, everything else she has is basically enough to work as a functional equivalent and she still lost to the weaker Rhongomyniad(Even if it was from the Servantverse).

 

[Paxton]

Dante (Devil May Cry) runs the Berserk gauntlet

Location of the Contest: Dante fights his opponents where they would usually appear. The starting distance between contestants is forty feet. Feats/equipment for Dante: Dante is given composite feats from every licensed appearance and is equipped with his entire arsenal. Knowledge: Dante has no...

forums.spacebattles.com

>Dante has composite feats

 

[Masterblack06]

Dante (Devil May Cry) runs the Berserk gauntlet

Location of the Contest: Dante fights his opponents where they would usually appear. The starting distance between contestants is forty feet. Feats/equipment for Dante: Dante is given composite feats from every licensed appearance and is equipped with his entire arsenal. Knowledge: Dante has no...

forums.spacebattles.com

>Dante has composite feats

Someone's bout to get "one more god rejected"

 

[Paxton]

Kamen Rider Dangerous Zombie lvl 0 vs Ruby Rose (RWBY)

Round 1: ruby STOMP Genm, she far more faster and stronger, the only thing that save genm is his 99 Lives but ruby in character ruby will never kill a person so she might just knock him out of his transformation Round 2: now lv X is a zombie gashat which is a an upgrade item not a normal item...

forums.spacebattles.com

 

[Papa Nier]

Dante (Devil May Cry) runs the Berserk gauntlet

Location of the Contest: Dante fights his opponents where they would usually appear. The starting distance between contestants is forty feet. Feats/equipment for Dante: Dante is given composite feats from every licensed appearance and is equipped with his entire arsenal. Knowledge: Dante has no...

forums.spacebattles.com

>Dante has composite feats

The only version of Guts that stands a chance.

 

[Paxton]

megaversal guts vs megaversal dante

 

[Xhominid The Apex]

The only version of Guts that stands a chance.

I actually forgot to tell people that yeah, Berserk is actually collabing with SMT Dx2 lol.
So yeah, Megaversal Guts and Griffith and anyone else lol.

 

[Proto234]

BB 100% fits all of the requirements to get Excaliblasted at full power.
And again, while Summer BB doesn't have Potnia Theron, everything else she has is basically enough to work as a functional equivalent and she still lost to the weaker Rhongomyniad(Even if it was from the Servantverse).

While I prefer to ignore servantverse since I hate it, where was it stated that MHXX' NP is weaker than Rhongo?

 

[Stocking Anarchy]

Earthworm Jim vs James Ironwood

VS Both in character Random encounter Both are obstacles in their way and determined to win Jim feats from his Games, Cartoon and Comics James feats from the RWBY Series Both stand 100 metres apart Standard gear for both No knowledge, help and prep Victory by any means Battle Location takes...

forums.spacebattles.com

 

[Xhominid The Apex]

While I prefer to ignore servantverse since I hate it, where was it stated that MHXX' NP is weaker than Rhongo?

I meant it the other way around...

 

[Stocking Anarchy]

Sauron (Lord of the Rings) vs Salem (RWBY)

I ran the numbers on that a while ago, and it's kind of ridiculous. ( For reference for anybody else, this takes place at ~17:00 in Episode 6 Volume 8 of RWBY. ) It takes ~5 frames for the liquid to cross the distance between the ground and Atlas, and RWBY is animated at 24fps, so it takes...

forums.spacebattles.com

Another example for how and why SB is absolutely godawful when it comes to calcs...

Ok I'm looking at this now and woooooooooooooooooow where even to begin here?

If you look at Atlas, it's ~12km off the ground or so in most shots:

Based on what? I dunno about you but when I make a calc I try to show the ACTUAL SCALING.

( The Atlesian Airships in this picture are ~1.4km long, and are ~54 pixels long in this image. Atlas itself is flying ~476 pixels off the ground in this image. )

WHAT ARE YOU EVEN SCALING OFF? WHICH SHIPS DO YOU MEAN?

Also Atlas is only about 196 pixels off the ground, I had a look and-

Wait. Wait wait wait wait.

476 pixels off the ground?

Please don't tell me that-

No no no no no no no no no no no no no.

We see the pillar of liquid is about as thick as one of the shield generator towers on the sides of Atlas. Those towers are about 300 meters wide.

Then scale it. You are making a FUCKING CALC.

So you have a 300 meter diameter cylindrical pillar of liquid, travelling at 60km / second. That's a lot of energy. Let's approximate the energy of the liquid pillar as if it were a cylinder of material hitting a target, which is what it basically is.

Let's say that the pillar of liquid has a density of 1/10th water or just 100kg/m^3 - that would be a mass of 42,400,000,000 or 42 million metric tons. Or you know, 18 gigatons of TNT equivalent when moving at 60km/second.


This is just kind of inherent to the scene. We know roughly how large the pillar is (multiple kilometers), and how quickly it crossed that distance (0.2 seconds). The only thing we don't know is density. But even if you assumed it was as light as the lightest aerogels - i.e. a ridiculously low 1 kg/m^3, a solid 20% less dense than air - it would still be roughly 182 megatons of TNT equivalent.

Yeah but there's not a single sonic boom or mach cone and Team RWBY isn't vaporized and the city below is totally unscathed so it's obviously some kind of esoteric effect.

Oh wait that's only the case with TES and Star Wars and Borderlands.

Derpiscore is a disingenous hypocrite. News at 11.

This is kind of consistent with the earthquakes the geyser created - just before Salem fires the beam there's several tremors that extend out for multiple kilometers around the city - which when you consider the level of energy Salem was manipulating, isnt too surprising.

Wait wait wait, so earthquakes are energy for RWBY but not TES. I sure expect that these geysers ought to have exploded at the exact same time as the earthquakes.

Also no fireball going boom boom woosh so feat is invalid.

Now remember that Salem's geyser stopped because it hit Atlas shields, which rather impressively, actually stopped the geyser for a couple of seconds. But those sci-fi shields of ridiculous strength don't exist in New York, and to thousands of tons of liquid moving at dozens of kilometers a second, conventional structures are just going to cease to exist.

And this isn't even getting into the fact that the Grimm liquid seemingly dissolves stuff that touches it - see the end of Volume 8 Episode 5 where a small boulder and tree just immediately decay into black flakes upon touching the liquid.

Maybe that just makes Atlas shields weak or esoteric instead of strong

 

[Stocking Anarchy]

TL;DR, there's shitty maths, but most of it is double standards and disinngenous behaviour. Dare I say if someone* was to actually put in some effort and calc it chances are it would yield something, but that requires, y'know, effort.

*No not me

 

[Proto234]

A Marine Expeditionary Unit (RL) vs The Separatist Droid Army (Star Wars: Disney)

The droids are of course simple to beat. The droidekas will indeed be annoyance, but so will mortars and howitzers to the droid forces. Superior artillery, support weapons, and competence just might make up for the droid's advantage in heavy armor, such as actually having tanks other than just...

forums.spacebattles.com

Good old muh IRL army better than SF movie army.
Seriously, Ukraine crisis alone proves that IRL army isn't hot stuff compared to any SF army

 

[Qinglong]

Reminder SB unironically meme'd on stormtrooper accuracy when their country's actual army is over 10 times worse at hitting targets (probably closer to 50 times worse tbh)

 

[Proto234]

Reminder SB unironically meme'd on stormtrooper accuracy when their country's actual army is over 10 times worse at hitting targets (probably closer to 50 times worse tbh)

Wait, are you implying that USA army's accuracy is worse than Stormtroopers meme? Despite so called "State of the art" tech they have?

 

[Qinglong]

RL army accuracy is downright atrocious

stormtrooper accuracy even at like 6~10% from my memory is far above the military requiring anywhere from 50k to 250k shots per kill

EDIT: Even discounting automatic weapons the lowest reported figures for rifle accuracy for real life militaries was approximately 180 shots per kill. the Rebellion, who are roughly 4-5 times worse than the Stormtroopers, only required around 25

 

[Xhominid The Apex]

Wait, are you implying that USA army's accuracy is worse than Stormtroopers meme? Despite so called "State of the art" tech they have?

Yes, it actually is. RL Military are actually infinitely worse than any Stormtrooper, missing hundreds of bullets per target hit for a SINGLE Soldier on average.
It's not even a meme, it's the truth.

 

[Xhominid The Apex]

TL;DR, there's shitty maths, but most of it is double standards and disinngenous behaviour. Dare I say if someone* was to actually put in some effort and calc it chances are it would yield something, but that requires, y'know, effort.

*No not me

It's exactly what I told you, they are lying their asses off and playing hardcore double standards to get the shit they do and even then, they still are terrible calc'ers because they choose the wrong scenes to pixel scale.
It's a literal freaking mess and it's honestly absurd how they keep sliding into Reddit-VSB territory with this.

 

[ChaosTheory123]

Yes, it actually is. RL Military are actually infinitely worse than any Stormtrooper, missing hundreds of bullets per target hit for a SINGLE Soldier on average.
It's not even a meme, it's the truth.

Part of why the budget is so inflated

Wasted resources

Remember, if its "military grade" that just means "cheaply made"