• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked COVID-19 Mafia Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
1. Flower
2. Tempest
5. Ekko
7. Gad
10. Grammaton
12. Rugrat
16. Saber

feel like original scums + potential convert should be on this list^
flower and tempest def were not original scums imo
 
hime said:
1. Flower
2. Tempest
5. Ekko
7. Gad
10. Grammaton
12. Rugrat
16. Saber

feel like original scums + potential convert should be on this list^
flower and tempest def were not original scums imo
Click to expand...

Grammaton kind of dipped today, not sure he would not at least pretend to give a shit as scum?

Ekko is putting effort but he is is mainly pushing town power roles, think could be power wolfing here?
 
hime said:
1. Flower
2. Tempest
5. Ekko
7. Gad
10. Grammaton
12. Rugrat
16. Saber

feel like original scums + potential convert should be on this list^
flower and tempest def were not original scums imo
Click to expand...
hmm maybe ekko too for the not an original scum
vibed with him a whole lot more dp1 at least
he kinda felt way more all over the place today
 
Lord Melkor said:
Grammaton kind of dipped today, not sure he would not at least pretend to give a shit as scum?

Ekko is putting effort but he is is mainly pushing town power roles, think could be power wolfing here?
Click to expand...
pretty sure gram said last phase that he will be busy going forward so not sure if his lack of activity is really alignment indicative
 
hime said:
miller is not something i would consider a strong role since all it does is scan guilty, i specifically meant strong prs like invests/protects/vig
i dont see any reason to not operate on this basis if im being honest

also idk what "obvious players" r supposed to mean in this case
there arent really any clear choices since there is always a risk the person is unrecruitable
if the not recruitable status didnt already exist in the game, it would make more sense for yoho's role to exist

think abt it this way:
imagine this was not recruits and instead kills
if there were several townies who were bp the first 2 nights, a doctor that functions those 2 nights just makes less sense to have
thats how i thought of it anyway
Click to expand...
i just don't see why invests and protects would HAVE to be immune to conversion to keep the balance of the game, the vigi did, but these other two don't
the obvious choice would be the active, widely town-read players, pretty much like a kill
and, you know, there was another possibility that i didn't mention because i thought it was silly, but now with melkor's claim, i can't get it out of my head:
scum being informed by the host that the vaccine exists, to balance it out
 
Saber said:
i just don't see why invests and protects would HAVE to be immune to conversion to keep the balance of the game
Click to expand...
personally, i dont see it making much sense otherwise
but sure, protects can be excluded ig unless u count yoho as one maybe
 
Day 2 Vote Count

Emil: Yoho > Luka > Hime > Melkor
Flower: Hime > Rugrat
Tweet: Melkor > Yoho > Melkor
Lethal: Flower > Tempest
Luka: Melkor
Soulkiller: Melkor
Tempest: Hime
Melkor: Hime

Melkor - 4
Hime - 2
Rugrat - 1
Tempest - 1

With 15 alive, it's 8 to lynch. You have ~31 hours remaining.​
 
like, the only way his role would do something is if both the cult and the vaccine decided to visit him specifically on one of the first two nights, his role only exists to confirm something that scum should really know for balance purposes, it makes much more sense as scum TMI than as a real role
 
Emil said:
read some of the day overnight and im here rn. ideally wud like to move some of these nulls to town while also being careful about clearing too many ppl and risking them being culted later. this list is purely aiming for the starting 2 scum

1. Flower
2. Tempest
3. Aurelian
4. Tweet
5. Ekko
6. Yoho
7. Gad
9. Lethal
10. Grammaton
11. Luka
12. Rugrat
13. hime
14. Lord Melkor
15. Soulkiller
16. Saber

soul and flower my strongest town reads, saber can see town from early day engagement with flower coming off different from his recent scum game in wg. tweet i think his entrance was solid and he entertained yoho even tho the timing of it is convenient atleast it was something. could be scum having a good game but is something to worry about later and dont think scum will be bussing in day 1 when its only 2 members.

aurelian thought was distraction townie but the sparkle flip makes me reconsider as his main directions yesterday were both town and hes a guranteed pro-scum vote even if hes town. cant be bothered with dealing with this sht in a cult game. cant clear him for low accuracy this game as he would only have 1 teammate day 1 and if he gets culted we wont even know the difference. chalking him up to townie here in order to progress PoE but wont be opposed to get his claim at least. he didnt do town tell either so im being extremely generous with this one

cp and gram failed the litmus test on a player they shud reasonably be able to read well so hopefully they got something for us today. on surface level play they seem fine but nothing much was happening last day and sparkle kinda self destructed so its not hard for them to fake the thoughts they made day 1. even if those 2 started town they will be the most obvious cult choice if the scum team is cowards. gonna be big day for them today in terms of determining their alignment.

hime gad melkor are all just there, they ask questions but i dont see much drawn conclusions from them. possible we got 1 scum playing it safe there and needs to be pressured. lethal was very easy to bend last day, dont know if this is a town indicative thing of him. probably wud think so. atleast shows open mindedness which is not regular for me to see from him, maybe trying to get on my good side here ngl. hes more of a coward as scum so probs wont bother responding to me, could slot him town for sake of PoE and defer to gram/flower as they read him better

luka i think can be scum. danced around the sparkle town read despite identifying things that he think are scummy from her, and kept his vote on me entire day for a joke post about yeeting cp. dont think he was really all that invested in finding scum, could side quest get a claim from him today

if i forgot to mention anyone, start playing more. we need more original thoughts in this thread if we r to win this. we need people to play as townie as they can in order for us to detect change in behavior to find the culted players, its pretty much the only way this is remotely winnable after losing vig day 1

think yall shud give me my yoho yeet if u got nothing better tbdean. nothing is his play is townie, nothing is keeping him alive aside from claim. the sparkle wagon derailed us from him and he was happy to hop on for bunch of nonsense. i shuda stuck with him yesterday. happy to entertain other wagons for claims or mech but im very dead set on this one otherwise. we giving him the axe today.

vote lynch yoho
Click to expand...
I think this is a fair read list
 
hime said:
y not just claim vanilla and let some ppl continue to be wary of yoho then tho?
Click to expand...
because vt claims never save anyone from their lynches, and yoho wasn't getting lynched today anyway, look at the vote count
 
hime said:
1. Flower
2. Tempest
5. Ekko
7. Gad
10. Grammaton
12. Rugrat
16. Saber

feel like original scums + potential convert should be on this list^
flower and tempest def were not original scums imo
Click to expand...
Remove Saber for now.
 
Also can you guys not hammer early today pls? Gram said he‘ll be here tomorrow and I want to hear his thoughts.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top