• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked COVID-19 Mafia Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Hans Tweetenberg said:
Nope, can't say this convinces me. Being consistently wrong for days on end is one thing, but you're telling me he's scum because he was wrong about one player, maybe two which we don't know yet. Townies are wrong all the time, and his case on Sparkles d1 struck me and a number of other players as genuine which is the more important part. You also voted Sparkles out, you were wrong, does that mean you're scum? I can't help but feel you're preflipping hime here as well.

So yeah, can't tell if you're just being really shallow about this or genuinely arguing in bad faith.
Click to expand...
bro its not just 1 or 2 players, from ur PoV he'd be wrong about u too if hes wrong on sparkle and hime, then from my POV he'd be wrong on me as well if im his direction after u, gezuz christ u cant be forreal

wats with this t1 simping going on
 
gonna go do something else as well. this game is becoming too frustrating. i think scum r having an excellent game whoever they r. could point to gram or someone else that's deep wolfing this. i feel like most ppl have reasons to be town read for yet i know for sure 2-3 ppl have to be scum.

think i wanna go back to melkor tbh, or even aurelian to resolve the yoho thing. we're getting derailed too far from what we started from

anyway bbl, probably bk by EoD. dont hammer anything plz. need thoughts from every1
 
Emil said:
bro its not just 1 or 2 players, from ur PoV he'd be wrong about u too if hes wrong on sparkle and hime, then from my POV he'd be wrong on me as well if im his direction after u, gezuz christ u cant be forreal

wats with this t1 simping going on
Click to expand...
He's currently mulling over his options I'm supposed to believe, chances are he'll come around on at least one of us

I don't like the way you seem to be dealing in absolutes a lot, you just look at the outcome and base your opinion on only that and ignore what lead us there
 
Oh you're leaving? Boring

In that case I suppose I can freely admit that overselling my sus of you and voting you was mostly reaction fishing. I think I've decided I'm not a fan of yours this game either way.
 
Can anyone help me with this, it's been a while since I actually argued with Ekko in a game. Is his reasoning for scum reading CP as shallow as I think it is and indicative of something or is that just how he rolls?
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
He's currently mulling over his options I'm supposed to believe, chances are he'll come around on at least one of us

I don't like the way you seem to be dealing in absolutes a lot, you just look at the outcome and base your opinion on only that and ignore what lead us there
Click to expand...
where have i done that tho? only with sparkle because i truly dont know how to read her. i did want to give her a chance to shoot but ultimately wasnt confident on her being town. im by no means claiming to be her best reader so i left her to those who can

but when it comes to myself and hime i can defend us, when it comes to you... well.. idk what r u doing rn if ur town. im telling u whats going on. also ur point saying why cant he be wrong and town, well he can. i didnt start with immediately scum reading him day 2. i thought he can reasonably still be town despite wrongly lynching a town vig. my read of him moved from town in day 1 to null start of day 2. now its moving to scum given how im seeing his progression in this day

idk how, from ur PoV, u r reading him town. i can get hime reading him scum from hers, i dont understand yours. for hime, i dont understand how she's reading luka town. hope this atleast explains my perspective
 
think at this point we just flip hime and either win or lose the game off it

or melkor/aurelian/luka... or even gram/cp

tweets perspective rn is kinda fked. like his confidence in his approach seems townie but hes got all the results wrong. if im going to go all out immune to reason can just yeet him as well despite having him town all game

thats it for me tonight
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
Can anyone help me with this, it's been a while since I actually argued with Ekko in a game. Is his reasoning for scum reading CP as shallow as I think it is and indicative of something or is that just how he rolls?
Click to expand...
Pushing me with nonsense and backing off after I start solving to his satisfaction vibes town ekko. The size of his POE does vibe scum ekko a bit but given this is a cult game is more understandable
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
A lot happened between those posts you quoted, you made a number of points against her that seemed genuine enough. Like Gram said, you gave the impression you'd genuinely struck gold and you nailed her to the wall the game before this one so sheeping you felt like a good course of action

You'll notice I'm not throwing shade your way at all for being wrong about Sparkles. Matter of fact I feel fine about giving you your hime lynch today on top.
Click to expand...
A lot happened? Like what? They're all from page 8
 
Emil said:
think at this point we just flip hime and either win or lose the game off it

or melkor/aurelian/luka... or even gram/cp

tweets perspective rn is kinda fked. like his confidence in his approach seems townie but hes got all the results wrong. if im going to go all out immune to reason can just yeet him as well despite having him town all game

thats it for me tonight
Click to expand...
I've reconsidered flipping hime today, would rather have her use the role
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
Seriously though, unless all of you, Flower and Ekko are scum, at least one of you lot is high-fiving themselves for being wrong lmao. People gloating preemptively especially when they're wrong gets under my skin like nothing else, it's a pet peeve of mine.
Click to expand...
Not gloating about anything am I
 
Not terribly opposed to yeeting rugrat. Obvious recruit option since it gives cult an extra vote. My initial thinking was that'd be an unrecruitable role but given we have the vig, yoho, and possibly hime now also claiming unrecruitable idk about that anymore. Does feel swingy but then again so does having a bunch of ways for recruits to fail
 
Emil said:
think at this point we just flip hime and either win or lose the game off it

or melkor/aurelian/luka... or even gram/cp

tweets perspective rn is kinda fked. like his confidence in his approach seems townie but hes got all the results wrong. if im going to go all out immune to reason can just yeet him as well despite having him town all game

thats it for me tonight
Click to expand...
came bk to say wud like to add saber and maybe rugrat/gad here as well. pretty not concise list. flower seems to have something to town read saber tho and id like her to tell us what it is to remove him

also @Grammaton eagerly demanding ur thoughts on hime tweet and cp here. thoughts on everything going on basically

Hans Tweetenberg said:
He's currently mulling over his options I'm supposed to believe, chances are he'll come around on at least one of us

I don't like the way you seem to be dealing in absolutes a lot, you just look at the outcome and base your opinion on only that and ignore what lead us there
Click to expand...
also taking a second look at the bolded - are u trying to get ahead of that as well by showing him that ur willing to lynch me? u that scared of cp? so fken what if thats his PoE. he's not above playing the game like the rest of us, if his PoE is shit we just hang him any time
 
Emil said:
where have i done that tho? only with sparkle because i truly dont know how to read her. i did want to give her a chance to shoot but ultimately wasnt confident on her being town. im by no means claiming to be her best reader so i left her to those who can

but when it comes to myself and hime i can defend us, when it comes to you... well.. idk what r u doing rn if ur town. im telling u whats going on. also ur point saying why cant he be wrong and town, well he can. i didnt start with immediately scum reading him day 2. i thought he can reasonably still be town despite wrongly lynching a town vig. my read of him moved from town in day 1 to null start of day 2. now its moving to scum given how im seeing his progression in this day

idk how, from ur PoV, u r reading him town. i can get hime reading him scum from hers, i dont understand yours. for hime, i dont understand how she's reading luka town. hope this atleast explains my perspective
Click to expand...
Tbh there's nothing speaking against him potentially getting culted n1. I thought he was town d1 despite being wrong on Sparkles though. If he's also wrong on hime - which seems like a sizeable maybe - idk where we're going, but I for one am not gonna listen to a potential third case of his at that point.
 
Emil said:
gonna pencil luka as scum aswell btw, pretty slimy defense there
Click to expand...
Youre getting added back to POE
This is pure OMGUS, the accusation on me is shitty and dismissing all of my posts for me going against an objectively poor read is a play I wouldnt expect from a vilager here
 
Emil said:
think at this point we just flip hime and either win or lose the game off it

or melkor/aurelian/luka... or even gram/cp

tweets perspective rn is kinda fked. like his confidence in his approach seems townie but hes got all the results wrong. if im going to go all out immune to reason can just yeet him as well despite having him town all game

thats it for me tonight
Click to expand...
Pfffffff idk what you're doing either rn man. You're supposedly reading CP scummier by the minute but in your own terms are willing to stake the game on lynching someone who's his main case for today. I have no idea how those two fit together.
 
Tempest said:
It's not even true lmao I drove the main wagon today and got a claim and have been grilling her since

People are being so lazy it's shocking
Click to expand...
It is true that you feel slightly lower energy than yesterday, but this is also a fact that you haven't like, dropped off of the face of the earth
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top