Archived Dethy Game

[One Last News]

In Case A if i were gulliable

Both Pongy and Poison shows Insane cops . Also Alwaysmind got result on poison he can only be paranoid from this scenario.

Clear one of them is mafia from this scenario .

Another one If i were Sane and you were guilty
- My result on pony shows innocent so she is confirmed town on two scenarios .
- Poison's result looks pretty inconsistent here .

This post doesn't make any sense. It looks you didn't understand my post.

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

So Another case if Poison turned out to be innocent in this scenario :
Case A: If i were insane
Nessos: Paranoid
OLU: Paranoid
Pongy : Sane /Naive

Nessos and OLU would show inconsistent here .

Case B : If i were Sane
Nessos : Insane/Paranoid
OLU: Paranoid/Insane
Pongy : Naive

Then scum is between nessos and OLU.

Case C: If i were naive
Nessos : Insane/paranoid
OLU : Paranoid/Insane
pongy : Sane cop
Then OLU is likely scum for this scenario . Gibven pongy's result would be consistent with his nessos's result.

 

[One Last News]

Poison is likely scum if you look at scenario of me as naive cop and nessos is scum .

A scenario were you are naive and I am scum doesn't exist. (2 Mafia also not possible)
If I were scum you would have to be sane.


You being naive would only be possible If pongy or poison are Mafia (scenario D or scenario E)

 

[One Last News]

Lets go through potential scenarios

Spoiler: A OLN Mafia

OLU: Paranoid
Kingslayer: Sane
Poison: Insane, guilible
pongy: insane, gulible

Spoiler: B OLU Mafia

OLN: insane, paranoid
Kingslayer: sane, gulible
Poison: sane, guilible
pongy: sane, gulible

Spoiler: C Kingslayer Mafia

OLN: paranoid
OLU: Insane
Poison: sane, guilible
pongy: sane, gulible

Spoiler: D poison Mafia

OLN: insane
OLU: paranoid
Kingslayer: sane, guilible
pongy: sane, guilible

Spoiler: E pongy mafia

OLN: insane, paranoid
OLU: insane, paranoid
Kingslayer: gulible
poison: sane

Through B we know @One Last Username is confirmed Town.

There doesn't exist more possibilities then these!

 

[One Last News]

Am I the only one who gets the Feeling that @Kingslayer is trying to confuse everyone?!?

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

A scenario were you are naive and I am scum doesn't exist. (2 Mafia also not possible)
If I were scum you would have to be sane.


You being naive would only be possible If pongy or poison are Mafia (scenario D or scenario E)

Ya this means both show insane cop results in hypothetical scenario . So between pony and poison someone made up your innocent result .

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

Am I the only one who gets the Feeling that @Kingslayer is trying to confuse everyone?!?

We are talking about if i were Naive cop .

 

[One Last News]

Ya this means both show insane cop results in hypothetical scenario . So between pony and poison someone made up your innocent result .

No thats not true.

In scenario A and scenario C both are Town.

Lets go through potential scenarios

Spoiler: A OLN Mafia

OLU: Paranoid
Kingslayer: Sane
Poison: Insane, guilible
pongy: insane, gulible

Spoiler: B OLU Mafia

OLN: insane, paranoid
Kingslayer: sane, gulible
Poison: sane, guilible
pongy: sane, gulible

Spoiler: C Kingslayer Mafia

OLN: paranoid
OLU: Insane
Poison: sane, guilible
pongy: sane, gulible

Spoiler: D poison Mafia

OLN: insane
OLU: paranoid
Kingslayer: sane, guilible
pongy: sane, guilible

Spoiler: E pongy mafia

OLN: insane, paranoid
OLU: insane, paranoid
Kingslayer: gulible
poison: sane

Through B we know @One Last Username is confirmed Town.

 

[One Last News]

We are talking about if i were Naive cop .

Thats a super stupid pov.

 

[One Last News]

We are hunting Mafia not the naive cop.
Thats why this ist the way to solve the Game.

Lets go through potential scenarios

Spoiler: A OLN Mafia

OLU: Paranoid
Kingslayer: Sane
Poison: Insane, guilible
pongy: insane, gulible

Spoiler: B OLU Mafia

OLN: insane, paranoid
Kingslayer: sane, gulible
Poison: sane, guilible
pongy: sane, gulible

Spoiler: C Kingslayer Mafia

OLN: paranoid
OLU: Insane
Poison: sane, guilible
pongy: sane, gulible

Spoiler: D poison Mafia

OLN: insane
OLU: paranoid
Kingslayer: sane, guilible
pongy: sane, guilible

Spoiler: E pongy mafia

OLN: insane, paranoid
OLU: insane, paranoid
Kingslayer: gulible
poison: sane

Through B we know @One Last Username is confirmed Town.

 

[One Last News]

This way you can proof if player can be Mafia

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

This way you can proof if player can be Mafia

In Scenario A i could be gulliable/sane thats what i am pointing out .

How did you figure i can only sane cop .

 

[One Last News]

In Scenario A i could be gulliable/sane thats what i am pointing out .

How did you figure i can only sane cop .

Math each role only exist once.
You can only be naive If one of poison or pongy are scum.

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

Math each role only exist once.
You can only be naive If one of poison or pongy are scum.

Okay i checked

If i were Sane cop from Hypothetical scenario
Pongy is Insane / Naive in this case and they received inno result
Poison is either Naive/Insane as well and they received inno result

You used process of elimination makes sense now . Alright i didnt check your thread properly.

 

[Jesse Pinkman]

@Poison you need to say something . Are you outted thats why you no longer reply ?

 

[One Last News]

The way to solve it is quite easy.

You go through every player and check, if they can be Mafia.
If one is Mafia, the rest is Town and Rolf the truth. Then you go through the results and point out every possible cop distribution.

If there is a no way to solve, like in B you have a confirmed Town.

Its actually quite good that we have already a confirmed Town with D1 results. Thus it should be easy to win this.

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Vote Tally

news - poison
username - username
poison - poison
pongy - poison
kingslayer - poison

poison - 4
username - 1

 

[One Last Username]

Vote lynch poison

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

Vote Tally

news - poison
username - poison
poison - poison
pongy - poison
kingslayer - poison

poison - 5

Poison was lynched. She was a cop.

Night 1 begins!

 

[Dragon D. Luffy]

@Kingslayer
@Officer MeowMeow Poontang
@One Last News
@One Last Username

Please send your investigations/kill for the night.