• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Dune Mafia - town victory

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
You're assuming everything he does is strictly very calculated as scum, and it's just not true lol and we both know it. He knows his town meta well enough to know that his positions need to be chaotic, you've been scum with him recently on Worstgen where I misread him for him basically doing this (counter claiming Polar when Polar was already dead basically). So this doesn't really hold up to scrutiny imo. I can accept that your read surpasses that suspicion, and hell, I can even accept that you did go through this process and just didn't show it, but acting like I should have just known he would act in a particular way is bunk.
 

I did notice in this post that Alco had said he mindmelded with Ekko on Sparkles but I actually don't see Ekko talking that much about her at this point

He then says I'm null but doesn't give me anything for Sparkles either. Kinda weird
 
Like I was wrong on Ekko and I need to step back and consider that, but your arguments here are clearly working backwards from your premise. None of this actually passes scrutiny.
 
Poyser said:
You don’t see yourself as a bigger scalp than sparkles lol?
Click to expand...

I don't think the order matters so much that he would pull a 180 and switch tact. If he is scum there then obviously his gameplan would be taking my side for a mislynch and then letting me catch flak tomorrow. Vice versa if he sides with Sparkles.
 
Ratchet said:
Like I was wrong on Ekko and I need to step back and consider that, but your arguments here are clearly working backwards from your premise. None of this actually passes scrutiny.
Click to expand...

Being wrong on Ekko is one thing, it was the way you went about it that gave me pause. I think Poyser came off more as genuinely suspecting him
 

Fair enough that he doesn't always strictly conform to logical play, but from a general standpoint it didn't really make sense for him to piss me off in the middle of him getting ragged on by almost anyone. Just defies common sense, didn't feel like he was trying to "sell" anything to anyone
 
I'm going to probably catch some flak for this but I want to go on record saying something is WIERD about Flower and she felt a bit gassed out from posting yesterday

Indi confirmed?
 
Ultra said:
I did notice in this post that Alco had said he mindmelded with Ekko on Sparkles but I actually don't see Ekko talking that much about her at this point

He then says I'm null but doesn't give me anything for Sparkles either. Kinda weird
Click to expand...
From memory he kinda plays me and Ekko off each other in the posts after too
 

Ekko does not surprise me but Lethal? What did lethal do to deserve such a honor? Also, what is with this love for role hiding kills from hosts smh.
 
Ultra said:
Being wrong on Ekko is one thing, it was the way you went about it that gave me pause. I think Poyser came off more as genuinely suspecting him
Click to expand...
Well you keep saying this but your premise for it is something that's your fault. I tend to read hi favourably early, especially lately, and the copious amounts of shit, the resistance he had to Fang (who I still think is a good wagon), my town reads pointing out he's posted a lot of shit, led me to thinking he had a good chance of being scum. And I told you as much. Then, hours later, you act like I haven't said anything about scum reading him, which just isn't true. Think I spent quite a lot of time deconstructing his posts.
 
Ultra said:
Of course you did

Next question, why would you voluntarily out yourself as a killing role Day 1? Are you vig?
Click to expand...
Because i can. I will not confirm nor deny.
Why didnt you question me yesterday when i softed it like 4 times.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Menu
Log in
Register