• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Dune Mafia - town victory

Status
Not open for further replies.
I dont either and his push on me felt half assed, it felt like it lacked conviction. What if Ultra is an indie lol.
See, I really really don’t get this

You’re basically saying he looks like a duck
Quacks like a duck
So might be a cat

Why would you posit he might be Indy for playing like shit, rather than just being scum? Makes no sense
 
you had like 2 votes on you at this time and the game had just started. Bit of an overreaction imo!
she over reacts with half a post, r u making a point here?

No I'm not telling you that. Read my posts, it's literally the opposite - I was questioning her about it precisely because that thought entered my mind. Then I thought "actually, she does this all the time as town" and that made me rethink it.
so then why are u voting ultra for basically thinking the same is my question. if it crossed ur mind then it crossed his as well, am i missing something here?

@Ratchet
@Ultra

Are you guys a team this game or not.
We're not in a chat together, so I don't know.
weird way to respond to what might be a lie detect question. feels like a response a detached scum would make if i was reading this in bad faith - i.e u arent in a chat with ultra and dont know if he's ur teammate or not, but u didnt really answer the crux of it about if you yourself are scum or not
 
See, I really really don’t get this

You’re basically saying he looks like a duck
Quacks like a duck
So might be a cat

Why would you posit he might be Indy for playing like shit, rather than just being scum? Makes no sense
Its mostly because hes doing bad pushes in my POV which I would associate with an indie not wanting to get shot night 1. In the Darkest Dungeon he was SK so he could afford going ham on scum because they couldnt kill him at night. Idk Im just thinking out loud lol.
 

Sparkles and then probably one in Fuji/Poyser, after that tack on maybe CP or something, but that's kind of insubstantial at this point. I feel like everyone's on drugs for towning Sparkles so either she's scum or someone with a good degree of TMI is playing around that. I think I would flip her first. All three feel extremely insincere.

Past that don't have really anything substantial. Maybe CP but that's just kind of a swing in the dark.
 
Flower is a bit weird too honestly, not irreconcilable on account of being a spiteful gremlin, but rarely does she try and stick to one spot as town like this
 
Nah doesn’t make sense
If he was Indy he can just hunt normally and his points would be better. Could explain dialled back aggression but that’s about it

Just last game he scum hunted completely normally when he knew there was another team
 
Weak
 
Nah doesn’t make sense
If he was Indy he can just hunt normally and his points would be better.
Then he dies to scum Night 1.
Could explain dialled back aggression but that’s about it

Just last game he scum hunted completely normally when he knew there was another team
He fully expected to die Night 1 in that game lol. We were worried about it.
 
Yeah I know. I don't think I want Ultra lynched Day 1 anyway, hence why I'd like to see him play more. My main issue with him is I don't like any if his directions
What a load of trash. You disagree with his directions, but want him to keep playing? Huh????
 
The question was if I'm a team with him. He didn't ask "are you scum or not".

For the first part - yeah I voted him because I didn't like how much he was pushing something as scummy for Flower when it isn't. Then when he basically said "yeah I was overselling it" it clicked into place better. You already asked me about this so why do I need to repeat myself.
 
Flower is a bit weird too honestly, not irreconcilable on account of being a spiteful gremlin, but rarely does she try and stick to one spot as town like this
Bullshit again. You gave me zero reason for me to reconsider, so why should I.
 
Then he dies to scum Night 1.

He fully expected to die Night 1 in that game lol. We were worried about it.
Why would he die? For one he’d almost certainly have a vest, for 2 deliver a scum D1 and attract protection N1

Someone like ultra can’t sit back and make bad pushes as Indy. It’s too out of his town range and would get him in trouble. Even in the example you brought up, you said he scumhunted normally lol

Kinds worried about your line of thought here ngl. Feels a bit fake
 
Status
Not open for further replies.