Game Ranked I Think You Should Leave - A Mafia Game by Sky

[Dr. Watson]

I feel like a lot of what they're doing is pointing scum, and the explanations for those actions are a little too convenient. But they're also passably believable.

Maybenot go for them this phase and see if something changes, ig

Where I'm at

I'm trying to make sure that both conclusions I'm drawing are given some thinking about rather than going gungho

Especially with slots like Frinckles' (suppose it also applies to Nibel) where they're hard to decipher because some of us don't have enough knowledge to work off of and played less than 3 games with.
I don't have a good reference point to say "This slot has to be town/this slot is scummy" which makes it harder for me to see whether it's genuine and chalk it up to human error, or it's genuine and scum is just too lazy to tryhard or they're trying to avoid walking back from their previous statements because they were caught in a convoluted web.

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Some Polar Bear is going to have the curry shits in about a week

Do you have like no trust in me?

 

[Dr. Watson]

Okay this is kind of weasely and backtrack-y

-1

This type of thing can be convenient because it's based on a shoddy hippocampus

Any "I derped" argument is more likely to be accepted as a legitimate reason, so if I were to be fair, this just looks handwavey
Who do you think you would've confused Polar with?
Your tunneling has been consistent on him, your ability to retain certain details is lacking. Why is Polar or Orca the slot that sticks out most to you?
You voted Orca, after all. Lines up with confusing him and Polar the most.

Those scenarios aren't at all equivalent

Frinckles is not new to this game. Frinckles is linking their slots, it's on him to provide an explanation for this. Perhaps my speculation is wrong, in fact it probably is a bit out there, but let him answer and stop defending him unsolicited thx

Oh cool, this was covered before you forced me to have to cover it

 

[Ultra]

Trying to figure that out tbh. Anyway I said i was going to reread. Replying to half of the thread trying to lynch me isn't going to do me any favors if my worldbuilding was built on a pile of gravel.

Scum.

 

[Dr. Watson]

Do you have like no trust in me?

I think that scum game of yours made you shoot future!you in the foot because many aren't willing to trust your play since like Nibel, you as scum tend to be overlooked until it's too late

 

[Ultra]

Do you have like no trust in me?

An emaciated Indian man vs a Polar Bear...hmmmmmmmmmmmmm

 

[RDK]

Off to bed, see you fine gentlemen and ladies on the morrow!

Bro got my town read and hightailed it

Based as fuck

 

[Frinckles]

Scum.

Why can't I post images with the phone browser?

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Where I'm at

I'm trying to make sure that both conclusions I'm drawing are given some thinking about rather than going gungho

Especially with slots like Frinckles' (suppose it also applies to Nibel) where they're hard to decipher because some of us don't have enough knowledge to work off of and played less than 3 games with.
I don't have a good reference point to say "This slot has to be town/this slot is scummy" which makes it harder for me to see whether it's genuine and chalk it up to human error, or it's genuine and scum is just too lazy to tryhard or they're trying to avoid walking back from their previous statements because they were caught in a convoluted web.

I think I'm going to wait on Freckles post before I make final judgments cause yeah. He was very carefree last game too. Thing is, he was also making points that scared me as scum, so I do read him as someone who doesn't slip too much. and has good insight. Not much of that this game.

Yeah, this is frustrating.

 

[Sharter Holmes]

I think that scum game of yours made you shoot future!you in the foot because many aren't willing to trust your play since like Nibel, you as scum tend to be overlooked until it's too late

Okay, first of all, nipples is anything but overlooked.

 

[Sharter Holmes]

An emaciated Indian man vs a Polar Bear...hmmmmmmmmmmmmm

Homie, just lie and spare my feelings.

 

[Dr. Watson]

Uh Frinck

The post you said you typed on the computer? Where is it, where is your theory you wanted to share?
Since you already put together a theory, which would imply you've kept track of the thread and your reads, why do you need more time to type out your thoughts?

Only point working in your favor (for me) is you've been consistent on your Orca/Polar connection, implies you're tunneling.

Your defensiveness over Ora's suspicion of your slot is overly defensive and it feels like it didn't really build enough reason to react in retaliation, implies you're not in favor of risking your hide being in the spotlight.
I don't know if scum!you would be so blatant and have the need to backtrack and have so many teeny convenient holes that people are hungry to pick apart, someone here who knows your scum game should shed some light on this.

 

[Ultra]

Homie, just lie and spare my feelings.

I love you

 

[Sharter Holmes]

I think that scum game of yours made you shoot future!you in the foot because many aren't willing to trust your play since like Nibel, you as scum tend to be overlooked until it's too late

Also, I meant he had no trust in me not being bear feed

 

[Sharter Holmes]

I love you

...that's all I needed to hear

 

[RDK]

Just realised all three dead players are from WS and now I'm panicking

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Just realised all three dead players are from WS and now I'm panicking

WS?

 

[Dr. Watson]

Okay, first of all, nipples is anything but overlooked.

Overlooked in terms of having a wagon on him because of his inherent scumminess

Overlooked in terms of favoring stronger scum reads over his slot, who everyone seems to be not at all reluctant to read as scum, that will inevitably end in torture and slithering out of a lynch continuously

Overlooked in terms of the people banging pots and pans the loudest (all of us) where he's only really an afterthought

He isn't overlooked in that he's highly townread and people are protective of the slot, he's overlooked because he can blend in without doing much to contribute and kicking back because people are more concerned over other slots

Yes he absolutely, and players who tend to be treated similarly, are overlooked in the grand scheme of things because there's more pressing matters than a slot that can survive endgame and beat us all to the punch

So I guess it isn't really entirely about Nibel, but how he's playing and how it'll be treated

I'm being proven correct

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Overlooked in terms of having a wagon on him because of his inherent scumminess

Overlooked in terms of favoring stronger scum reads over his slot, who everyone seems to be not at all reluctant to read as scum, that will inevitably end in torture and slithering out of a lynch continuously

Overlooked in terms of the people banging pots and pans the loudest (all of us) where he's only really an afterthought

He isn't overlooked in that he's highly townread and people are protective of the slot, he's overlooked because he can blend in without doing much to contribute and kicking back because people are more concerned over other slots

Yes he absolutely, and players who tend to be treated similarly, are overlooked in the grand scheme of things because there's more pressing matters than a slot that can survive endgame and beat us all to the punch

So I guess it isn't really entirely about Nibel, but how he's playing and how it'll be treated

I'm being proven correct

Fair enough. And on that topic, I would absolutely jump on a Nipple vote.

But you're right, personally I'd go for Orca first.

 

[Ultra]

Overlooked in terms of having a wagon on him because of his inherent scumminess

Overlooked in terms of favoring stronger scum reads over his slot, who everyone seems to be not at all reluctant to read as scum, that will inevitably end in torture and slithering out of a lynch continuously

Overlooked in terms of the people banging pots and pans the loudest (all of us) where he's only really an afterthought

He isn't overlooked in that he's highly townread and people are protective of the slot, he's overlooked because he can blend in without doing much to contribute and kicking back because people are more concerned over other slots

Yes he absolutely, and players who tend to be treated similarly, are overlooked in the grand scheme of things because there's more pressing matters than a slot that can survive endgame and beat us all to the punch

So I guess it isn't really entirely about Nibel, but how he's playing and how it'll be treated

I'm being proven correct

Who is "highly town reading" Nipples?

Seems about middle of the pack, personally and reading the room.