Evangelion is not so secretly Anno's very own form of therapy for himself. While End of Evangelion was bleak as hell, Shinji's lowest point (so far anyway. Rebuild had him sort of, kind of, cause another apocalypse and almost cause a third?), the kid ultimately did choose to reject instrumentality even though he briefly gave in completely.My problem with Shinji is not that he reacts like a teenager to being a Mecha protag, my problem is the way the tv show ruined his character development, set him back to square one, and Anno refusing to give him a proper conclusion, ignoring everything else, making the movie more of a clusterfuck as a fuck you to fans because he was going through issues, and only after decades with the Rebuild films did he bother to give him any real ending which despite how much fanboys who think the original ending was "perfect" will bitch and whine about, is better than what he was given years ago.
Rebuild having a more fulfilling ending is mostly Anno being in a mentally healthier place than anything.
Emotion and expressing it is a healthy thing. Anything in excess can be construed as "bad," especially if it ends up just becoming self-pity without looking for recourse to grow (easier to forgive in children, more egregious to see in adults that should have hopefully grown into better, still context dependent), but the sheer magnitude of the issues characters people tend to label as "crybabies" are far beyond what most anyone can realistically claim to ever need to deal with. A real person would fold confronted by the weight of the fiction someone like Shinji encounters at half the age where the brain is expected to reach something even approaching full maturity.I just rewatched First Blood and finally saw Part 2 for the first time and even outside of the ending of First Blood having John Rambo breaking down and crying from PTSD, the 2nd had him almost weeping over a girl he fell in love with dying. That's a grown ass man trained into being the most elite military unit of his time and even when he shows his emotions I have zero problems with. My problem is when the story refuses to have its character grow out of being a crybaby like with Deku who cries at the drop of a hat and the author pretends that's a good thing and not obnoxious and annoying. Losing a loved one, failing to save someone, losing your cool after too much stress accumulates, those make sense to cry about, doing it all the time is when it goes from "emotional" to just whiny.
What examples are you thinking to be excessive based on the context? What's 42% of the pain of having a spear go through your skull translate to where, up to that point in life, you were just an emotionally abused child with abandonment issues? Or taking on a responsibility you have no business being given and being guilted into it by the adults in the room? The ultimatum was fight the Kaiju seeking to kill everyone with no training, or let this injured stranger child you just met do it and die trying, all because no one older is capable of doing the job you shouldn't have and there's no guarantee you can do it despite being the only and last hope? I'm not even talking about the escalation later, just the first episode.