• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Ranked One Piece Thriller Bark Mafia

Reader mode
[Vote lynch Magic]

Looking back he's been tepid around Xadlin's botched claimed here and day 1 he was soft defending him by deflecting away from focus on Xadlin the first place
 
I think the way the votes and pressure shifted on GP was definitely influenced by scum, his wagon feels off imo. I do think my faith in townMagic is dropping with his interactions on the Xadlin subject.
 
Grammaton said:
It’s possible yeah, I just don’t find it a particularly convincing idea
Click to expand...
I'm just kinda afraid I just misread his intentions again. Good thing I find myself trusting you, at least, to have someone to deal with the guy T-T.
 
I want more answers out of Polar, not deflective bullshit

Am okay with this, first and foremost

Vote lynch Great Potato

You can only make detached commentary and voice opinions over the current events for so long

he hasn't really been particularly engaging in the present moments, imo

Have I missed any interactions where he's had a live one on one discussion or discussed things as they're unfolding, or is it just commentary and profiling others and taking a backseat? Like, has he interrogated the people he's suspected? Asked direct questions?

Because I'm gonna need more engagement then "This player and that player (insert reasons they're probably XYZ alignment.)"
 
Dr. Watson said:
If one of you can develop a proper, thorough case on me instead of screaming 1) "low activity she's scum" (erratic activity, NAI) 2) "WELL, she fell for this trap! She's interrogating in a scummy way!" (because, you know, we all can read your minds and what the 'traps' exactly are and why they're there in the first place.)

I'm all ears.

Show me the commonalities of when we were mates in the WG game, and if I can't counter it, I'll happily watch you lynch me and mislead others on a wrong read due to paranoia and predetermined conclusions that were never going to lead to townreading me to begin with.

Do your best.

Impress me.

This is akin to the same shit as GAD being day 1'd - people grasp at straws, he figs his hole further with bizarre and genuine frustrated reactions. Rinse and repeat. But, really, there wasn't a concrete case on him. Most of it was based on vibes, then him pulling even dumber shit. We aren't learning.
Click to expand...

I think we need to have a talk about how PoE works

You find reasons to town or scum read people as the game goes by - the people on the fringes of the game tend to get poe’d out by design because it’s an easy sell that they are ducking, particularly when they look different to past games

Obviously no two games will be identical, but this is a fairly constant rule. You’re at a point now where you’re competing with like 5 or 6 other players for whom I have no reason to read them town either, so the raw probability of just guessing randomly on that pile should be decent - if we can inform that with differences to previous town play, even better

Your defence in your rant, when boiled down is that gad was town and dug himself a hole, so we shouldn’t use vibe at all as it’s unreliable. It’s true that it isn’t 100% reliable else there would be no point playing the game, but the onus is on each player to overcome or at least deter the argument against them - gads mistake was that his defence was calling me a moron, unsurprising that I would fail to be convinced by that.
 
Aurelian said:
I think the way the votes and pressure shifted on GP was definitely influenced by scum, his wagon feels off imo. I do think my faith in townMagic is dropping with his interactions on the Xadlin subject.
Click to expand...
This, yeah, I'm stuck on it too

But GP has been far less impressive imho

It feels like Magic is attempting to play things safely. But his thought process and his approach is tricky to read for me - he's caught in the null pile for me.

My issue is while he's come to similar conclusions that I have and agree with on the surface is that it's, as it's been said, detached from other priorities. That is definitely a red flag - especially his lack of focus on Xadlin.

He didn't seem to have any pull with it. I'm not sure if this is just independent thinking town!Magic or a derailing scum!Magic.

Has he said he scum read Xadlin?
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top