• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Ranked One Piece Thriller Bark Mafia

Reader mode
How am I not aware of the info when I just told you what the stupid fucking info is?

I'm not blaming anybody for these mislynches lmao. Except Gad who obviously fucked up by ducking the thread when asked to claim instead of simply telling us he was the DV. The reads that made us arrive at that point were obviously wrong, but then he fake claimed Cop on his way to the gallows, and that was precisely the point where people referred to him as caught scum. That part of it is entirely Gads fault, it's not even debatable.

Luka and Lethal claimed conflicting info which needed to be solved and we made the wrong decision. If you wanna say that this is down to us reading them incorrectly, I for one had both of them as town on play so make of that what you will.
 

You also were trying to lynch potato and gramma over Xadlin tho.
Kek

I at least said Xadlin was lhf and he literally was.
Had 4 posts of nothing at the time I was pushing potato.
 
Oh also thanks for reminding me of this, Luka also messed up by not realizing sooner that Lethal is claiming something that should be impossible. It's not like peoples' decisions to go Luka over Lethal came out of nowhere.
 
T-Pein™ said:
You also were trying to lynch potato and gramma over Xadlin tho.
Kek

I at least said Xadlin was lhf and he literally was.
Had 4 posts of nothing at the time I was pushing potato.
Click to expand...
I never tried lynching gram day 2, he argued with me all day 2 about my read on potato.

I'm aware you called him lhf and then you kept angling that as a reason not to lynch him.
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
Oh also thanks for reminding me of this, Luka also messed up by not realizing sooner that Lethal is claiming something that should be impossible. It's not like peoples' decisions to go Luka over Lethal came out of nowhere.
Click to expand...
Definitely not. Luka caused a lot of it himself. Even after he finally claimed everything he still wasn't that gung ho for lynching lethal which is nuts imo.
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
Oh also thanks for reminding me of this, Luka also messed up by not realizing sooner that Lethal is claiming something that should be impossible. It's not like peoples' decisions to go Luka over Lethal came out of nowhere.
Click to expand...
How often do scum entrap themselves by claiming something that makes them out to be lying vs town? Like the basic assumption bad play is always scum and that town don't fuck this shit up(which has happened routinely all year) is grating.
 
I don't even think that the thing that he built his case on - something about most or all of GPs reads being based on meta and setup or something along those lines - was accurate at all
 
Magic said:
Lethal obviously.

And occam's razor also dictates we should lynch tpein for only pushing town/traitor that he didn't know was scum lol.
Click to expand...
Which scum who wasn't the Traitor have you pushed this game?

We're not counting players you believe to be scum and haven't flipped yet.
 

1. I never voted Xadlin at all...just did so after he botched his claim.

2. I never said Luka needs to go after lethal al all, luka vs lethal wasnt a thing till the last hour when I was sleeping

You are just making up stuff.
Kinda sad.
 
Hey uh

Did you ever stop to think that the reason Flower doesn't get killed is because you and Fang are reading her scum despite the fact that she's obvtown? Do you think scum may be willing to exploit that down the line perhaps?
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
Right now we got Lethal claiming to have seen somebody visit you on a night where all roles used on you should have failed, and Flower is claiming to have removed a shot of some role off of Watson who claimed VT.
Click to expand...

Flower said watson was vanilla actually.
Cuz if she destroys abilities then she gets refilled and she got none.
Also lethal claims to have seen orca kill nibel.
None talking about that
 
T-Pein™ said:
1. I never voted Xadlin at all...just did so after he botched his claim.

2. I never said Luka needs to go after lethal al all, luka vs lethal wasnt a thing till the last hour when I was sleeping

You are just making up stuff.
Kinda sad.
Click to expand...
So you did vote xaldin. I literally quoted your posts in chronical order. I didn't make up anything.

I just saw posts of you calling Luka a liar and saying he needs to go. Why didn't you have the same energy for lethal who Polar caught out as lying?
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
Hey uh

Did you ever stop to think that the reason Flower doesn't get killed is because you and Fang are reading her scum despite the fact that she's obvtown? Do you think scum may be willing to exploit that down the line perhaps?
Click to expand...

She has climed she was alive because she was BG.
Then when Xadlin flipped BG she dropped that and instead started saying she is alive cuz scum thinks she is an arsonist.
She was "pretending" to be so in the thread.
It all seems fake.
 
Magic said:
So you did vote xaldin. I literally quoted your posts in chronical order. I didn't make up anything.

I just saw posts of you calling Luka a liar and saying he needs to go. Why didn't you have the same energy for lethal who Polar caught out as lying?
Click to expand...

Wrong.
Like I said
I only voted Xadlin after his botched claim.

Are you preflipping lethal now?
When lethal claimed watcher it seemed legit.
Not that deep.
 
Magic said:
How often do scum entrap themselves by claiming something that makes them out to be lying vs town? Like the basic assumption bad play is always scum and that town don't fuck this shit up(which has happened routinely all year) is grating.
Click to expand...
I mean Lethal evidently also fucked up and we still bought it when he told us he misread the result he received from the host

It's not like we never cut people any slack or never consider the player when we think about whether or not their suboptimal play especially around their role is necessarily scummy, it just appears that this game we did it for the wrong people
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register