• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Radiant Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
I’d much rather get my ultra flip so that I can move on one way or the other lol
I think this is a problem we are running into in general with this game. Too many are set on one lynch only for solving which, is certainly fair in its own right, but it makes it hard to compromise with.

Poyser I'd like to give Ultra a day to solve away from defending himself. If he is scum leaning into these emotional appeals by taking away his crutch he really would have nothing left. If he's town getting frustrated genuinely then this should help him step his game up. I don't see myself coming back to voting him today.
 
He’s had a chance to solve and he just sheeped CP on Dalton because it isn’t him. He came up with some crackpot theory about Dalton faking a catch up and didn’t really have any interest in interacting with me about it, just calling my points shit

I’m also obviously not gonna be down for a Dalton lynch when ultra is pushing for jt

why is him being emotional making you read him as town? I’ve seen him as town and he’s not a massive baby
 
That said I'm struggling to reconcile his read on me. From his perspective I go from being against him to backing off and even coming around to the other side of the spectrum (him being town) when by his own admission scum reading him here is very safe and easy to lean into. Ultra, when town, does tend to read deeply into actions to see if he can find a thread to pull on - I was expecting to see him at least try to reconcile why I do this as scum (really, he would have to establish that my thread position would become safe if he gets lynched and flips town, which he hasn't come close to doing so yet). In that respect I can see the argument that his reads are phoned in.

Hence why I want to give him a day.
 
why is him being emotional making you read him as town? I’ve seen him as town and he’s not a massive baby
It's not something I've ever seen him lean into as scum. Not very much, anyway. And for him to be scum here at least some element of his emotional appeal would have to be ingenuine - I have an easier time reconciling it as legitimate frustration which, given the context of it, does imply town. It's my major hangup on this lynch.
 
There’s no reason why he can’t be scum and genuinely frustrated though. Equally he could still be scum who thinks my case is shit which adds to the real frustration
 
If you look at ultra this game he has been pretty happy to go in on any lynch that isn’t him lol

he was all aboard gram/you
He jumped on fuji
Jumped on psychic
Was pretty happy to give joy girl some sus
Jumped on Dalton

there’s no real consistency to his reads at all lol
 
There’s no reason why he can’t be scum and genuinely frustrated though. Equally he could still be scum who thinks my case is shit which adds to the real frustration
In this context there is though, because while his early frustration could have easily been scum annoyed he is getting voted for poor reasons, his later one has gone into complaining about the thread state and how hostile it is towards him, which if scum, he would know isn't really true. There can still be some emotions that are genuine here, certainly, but there is no real skipping around the fact that if he is scum, he would have to be intentionally playing into them at this point, and that's not something I've ever seen him do as scum before.
 
You are preaching to the choir here, on this point.
 

I observed this earlier, I think his catch up seemed a bit too convenient and thread fitting

This post also pinged me, due to its similarity to an early post he had in Elden Ring (He's referring to ratchet above)

https://onelastforum.com/threads/elden-ring-mafia.3168/page-6#post-143308

Like this seems pretty heavily opportunistic to me lol
 
This is where he originally talked about Dalton he says there’s very little to go off then didn’t really talk about him again until CP brought him up lol

all of a sudden it’s his strongest scum read
 
This is where he originally talked about Dalton he says there’s very little to go off then didn’t really talk about him again until CP brought him up lol

all of a sudden it’s his strongest scum read

Flip dalton.
If he flips scum then you can stop tunneling.
 
If Dalton flips town then the tunnel will continue unfortunately. Flip ultra and it ends either way
 
We lynch any of these.

Ultra
Dalton
Fuji

Mafia will kill any of these

Ratchet
Gramma
Poyser

And if they dont they are game throwing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.