Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

[Evans]

Why on earth would I trust you

I feel confident he's town

In your post/ISO/research about CraigPelton

Can you confirm why you went from not trusting him to a full town read on d1 pls?

 

[Lethal]

Cry me a river, it’s a legit enough reason to suspect you. I saw you say you posted nonsense and clutching at straws, but I don’t see how that makes it any better.

The irony of you telling someone else to cry a river. Get a grip of yourself.

 

[Evans]

The irony of you telling someone else to cry a river. Get a grip of yourself.

vote Aurelian then get into a slinging match pls

 

[T-Pein™]

This list feels so random

not random.
Isolate my readback
I think magic is scum and since magic wants to lynch physic and vice versa I put her in town.
Same with the other people in my town.
they are trying to lynch the scums.

 

[The X]

where r u on the scum reads?

also lets cross check notes on town reads i guess. why do you town read tweet?
@Magic pls let me know as well given ur town read on tweet is strong


i interpret it as a town read but u essentially liked his entrance posts / tone / memes but i dont see much difference between it and fairy tail game. also seem to completely brush off my scum read off him multiple times

I think Fang and Craig are wolfy. I think Nat and Odd are on the sidelines a bit as well. Last game, Nat was at least asking questions and trying to clarify things for herself. Odd has popped in the day some aggressive comments and that's it. Also I think Xad throwing a vote on my wagon and then disappearing is a bad look as well.

I gave Tweet some townie points for his assessment on Melkor being town. I thought that Tweet mentioned a few things about the usual town play that I see from Melkor that I thought was a good observation considering Tweet isn't as familiar with Melkor as others.

 

[Evans]

they are trying to lynch the scums.

CP wants to lynch you and you have him as town

 

[Lethal]

vote Aurelian then get into a slinging match pls

Wouldn't even call it a contest.

Vote: Aurelian

I do hope that Ekko can answer why he shifted to CP once you started down that line at some point today

 

[T-Pein™]

CP wants to lynch you and you have him as town

so what?
he doesn't have a list of everyone that is town.
He is allowed to be wrong.

 

[Evans]

so what?
he doesn't have a list of everyone that is town.
He is allowed to be wrong.

So you think his push on you is townie, despite it being apparently what I did last phase as scum?

 

[The X]

I will have a reaction when I see his flip. Why are you so confidant he is town? You obviously got TMI.

How did it felt weird? He had votes on him and I didnt want to read another dayphase of Gram vs Aurelian. You also voted him at the time.
The reads list was in response to Ekko's question. It was intended to be blunt and only offer alternatives to the lynch, not meant to be an actual read list. Why are you panicking? Was your whole scum team on there?

Who are the two omgus? I don't think anyone has sus me besides you. If anything, You and Ream omgus me!

I don't like the way he's been acting at all. Sure, his slot deserves pressure.

[Change vote lynch T-Pein]

I concur.

This is absurd. How is CP stating his reads all of a sudden makes me special??? Why are you so confidant CP is town?

I scumread you from the start. You literally OMGUS me. I think you're mafia and I think you're scared. You're playing very similarly to your scum meta.

1. You flip flop votes,
2. You Omgus me for scumreading you
3. TMI
4. You literally making up shit for people to sus me
5. Townreading basically everyone

[Change vote lynch Magic]

I will say that posts like these, and what Craig has said about Psychic, despite my initial town read on Psychic, makes me think there could be some team equity between the two. If Craig flips wolf, I'd be changing my outlook non Psychic's slot.

 

[T-Pein™]

Wouldn't even call it a contest.

Vote: Aurelian

I do hope that Ekko can answer why he shifted to CP once you started down that line at some point today

why are you voting for Aurelian?
because he told you to do it or do you have a unique reason?

 

[T-Pein™]

So you think his push on you is townie, despite it being apparently what I did last phase as scum?

Like I said.
If Aurelian flips scum my reads are gonna basically switch.
Most of this phase you were the one egging him on to vote me out when he was entertaining voting BPD.

 

[Lethal]

why are you voting for Aurelian?
because he told you to do it or do you have a unique reason?

He's in my wolf list. I mean if you'd read the thread and weren't a cancerous mong, you'd be able to gauge exactly why he's right up on a lot of people's lists.

 

[Evans]

Like I said.
If Aurelian flips scum my reads are gonna basically switch.
Most of this phase you were the one egging him on to vote me out when he was entertaining voting BPD.

Answer the fucking question.

Do you think CPs push on you is townie based on your current reads list?

 

[The X]

X are u going anywhere with this? i feel like if ur strugging this much to have a slam dunk on fang then he's just town tbh

Yeah I think Fang is trying to promote fake confidence here. There's no reason to try and thunderdome me here and it's only come AFTER my wagon started. He jumped in behind Craig and Magic's vote on me, then made a a case on me, then tried to make this a thunderdome. He's doing everything in reverse order and I don't think it's natural at all. My read on Fang has never changed this game, my. Vote has never moved. I don't know what you really expect from me here with his slot. You want me to have a twenty kate back and forth with him? Is that how I'll show 'confidence' and a 'slam dunk' on Fang?

 

[The X]

i dont think hes struggling, i think he is producing content that u dont agree with thats all

who'se struggling is cp, xadlin, nat, odd

I mean, if we look at Fang's posts, how many of them are just arguing with me and Gram? Magic has asked him for reads multiple times and he's unable to produce any. He calls me out for weak reads but he can't even give reads.

I mean, I don't like any of those slots either, but only Craig really fits the criteria of struggling for content. The other three, while concerning, have mostly just been MIA and on the sidelines.

 

[The X]

her change of style is throwing me off, sadly cant say shes town with a big degree of confidence this game

i do belive she wanted to change her playstyle tho and she talked to me about it so that checks out

How come Psychic gets a pass for this, though? I said at the start of last game, and multiple times during this game, I want to change my style of play on this forum. You're defending Psychic because she said she wanted to changed her style but not a peep has been said about how Fang and Craig are trying to use me 'playing differently' despite me saying I'm trying to play differently.

 

[Evans]

Aurelian
CP
T-Pein
Psychic

BOOK IT

 

[TSworder]

vote lynch Grammaton
He is scum

:<

Convincing

Town Voyeur

I have nothing to lose at this point

3 votes in and you went full yolo with a botched claim

Given its an investigative role that can tell me what abilities were used and how they were used, sorta? I'm like a back up investigator.

Sorta and I`m like aaaa...? Just drop what it does from the beginning.

Do you want me to copy paste what the host game me? And therefore get mod-killed because that's exactly what my role is:

- I can target a player and see who they targeted but it won't tell me what action they did
- all their actions will come back town flavored (killer as vig, role cop as cop, etc...)

Ok

Oh okay: "I can investigate a player at night, and get results on who used what on THEM" not who they targeted, I read that like a muppet at first.

you turned 180 grades with this claim

Just put the vote down

Just put the chromosome in the bag

As much as it pains me yes I'm changing my stance with Grammaton, and I stand corrected on the earlier shit. It doesn't change anything that I'm not nor ever indicated I would scum read Craig from earlier and I don't like your movement here to force it to between me or Craig instead of me vs BPD.

If I'm doing myself "no favors" then so be it.

I'm scum reading BPD.
Craig isn't town reading BPD.
You admit you aren't town reading BPD/pushed him as a null by your own ISO and analysis of his posts.

Why wouldn't I go after our shared common denominator instead of a dark horse at Craig?
Why do you think Craig is scummy?

Why do you changed your stance on Grams when he tunneled you for like 30 hours?
@Grammaton are you voting this lad because he contradicts a lot? from what i've played with him it seems like he does this quite often, doesn't matter the alignment,
Anyway, if this phase ends with Aurelian and bpd as main wagons, I will vote Aurelian.

 

[The X]

Sooo where are we going? Is BPD happening, if not why not and what else are we doing?

BPD is not happening because it'd be very ill advised and town regret it so. Game would turn miserable, in my honest opinion.