Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

[EkkoLoJinx]

i still want to think tpein and BPD r town but i know they r capable of giving us much more

 

[Arne Slot]

‘Indie hunting, SCUM !!!!’11!’

nah it just tracks with the fact he's not as much of a hidden coward as he is as scum but also wants to be on the BIG BOYS's safe side and is throwing reads around rather mechanically to that effect

 

[Grammaton]

Sussssssss

 

[Arne Slot]

on page 7
from what I zapped between the pages, milker seems townish. like they put effort into finding out.
magic did do the town reads early so feels good there to

only ones that are lower in posts then me are natlija and close to me is psychic.
ill check up on sworder and odds posts.

also odd wrote some posts about being cleared as town? feels strange since its hard to confirms town on day 1 unless you have familiarity and you can see the commitment

xadlin comes in and has nothing to say about the Aurelianfest that had dominated much of the thread by this point

 

[Arne Slot]

i think evans is town.

dont really like lethals read back. not read all of it thus far, but lacks lethal's typical town bite he has to it. like he's going after aurelian with what odo is giving him but isn't needlessly attacking him and calling him out for dumb shit, or what he thinks is dumb shit, as he tends to do while calling him trash.

i highly doubt anyone is going to have an appetite for a day 1 lethal lynch though so hopefully everyone just takes note of this instead.

ye I agree with this

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

@Lethal cp just called u an indie. im tired of his shit. we shud put him in the dirt together lets go

 

[Arne Slot]

Aurelian seem more like a townie that have given up trying to defend themselves and just let things happen.
no energy to claim they are town for anything to dissuade anyone.

I can kinda get that from getting jumped by wagon so thats why im hesitant to jump on it.

so xadlin says this later on, I guess realizing it's odd that he hadn't said anything about aurelian yet.

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

Because it's producing the same result?

You have this theory inside your head it makes more sense to go for nat first so everyone goes after aurelian day 2. Yet you're still going after nat day 2.

So it's the same thing isn't it.

no lol. if nat flips scum nobody wud lynch aurelian today

yo magic what r these mid tier arguments

 

[EkkoLoJinx]

also notice nobody is going much for nat now

if scum lynched nat and she flipped town, everyone wud be voting aurelian

its rly not debatable. nat > aurelian is infinitely easier

 

[Arne Slot]

@CraigPelton I would put anyralis on the lean town, since they are acting like another person that as town and just gave up since they were wagon.

I called out Xadlin in real time I guess and he pretty much just repeated himself

 

[Arne Slot]

On topic of CP I'm a bit divided. On one hand I liked Ekkos points against him, but then there's also the fact that he went back and set the timeline straight on that Gram/Fang argument. Why would he ever do that as scum when the whole thread is having a field day with a wrong timeline? Also his "case" against Pein is decent and the fact that it gets zero traction is interesting in and of itself.

I'm still not a huge fan of this point from tweet as it's kind of an irrelevant point but he's using it to seem like he's considering me from multiple angles

 

[Magic]

no lol. if nat flips scum nobody wud lynch aurelian today

yo magic what r these mid tier arguments

You're asking why, if nat is town, scum wouldn't hammer. That is what we're discussing.

 

[Arne Slot]

my thoughts:

Town:
Melkor
Gram
Magic
lethal
Hans

Pro town:
Ekko
psychic
Craig
Ekko
Black dragon
Sworder

Indie:
T-pein- hes to good of a heel for me to put in either category.
Evan- his hateboner for t-pein makes him neg in my book

leaning Scum:
natalija- asked for a catchup and posted more then me
odd- odd made some town claims on day 1 so I think thats sus

[vote Lynch odd]
I dont get the whole Aurelian thing that happened for lik 5 -10 pages

Err

How do you suddenly have 10 or so town reads? Feel free to elaborate on as many as you like

@Hans Tweetenberg
Honestly I think most guys seem town to me on day 1. It’s only on day 2 that I can start figuring things better.

But yeah I’ll jump on that wagon since I was iffy on dragon before.
[change lynch vote to black dragon p]

uhhh, no he wasn't? he had BPD as pro town

 

[Grammaton]

also notice nobody is going much for nat now

if scum lynched nat and she flipped town, everyone wud be voting aurelian

its rly not debatable. nat > aurelian is infinitely easier

Hold on playa

Have you checked Nats availability

Unlike anyone else who plays this game, she has a job

 

[Arne Slot]

I'm all right with tweet overall btw even if I didn't like that one post I think he's more likely town than not here

 

[Arne Slot]

For whose benefit? I literally just said of the people playing, there’s some stuff I like and some I don’t. Any of the guys I tagged and asked to play more, I’d be happy to lynch too but not until Aurelian is dead. If fang is scum then CP will move directly to the top of my suspect list unless he can explain why he had a personality transplant which conveniently preserved the life of a scum player

My fundamental line here is lynch Aurelian today

I feel like turning on a dime seemingly inexplicably is well baked into my meta at this point lol

 

[Arne Slot]

dime his name is BPD, I will be vindicated on that one, he's town

 

[Arne Slot]

CP has plenty of posts and thread status to have a read on him of some form. I prefer it to be on the town side. Done it for quite a while too. Similar vein to Doddsy.

I think I quoted this already but seriously WHAT

 

[Psychic]

You don't wanna just lynch magic?

I would prefer a Magic lynch if it can actually gain traction. Of course a Nat scum flip would confirm my suspicions that Magic is trying to save his scummate like he did in MHW.

Ya cause if tpein or psychic are scum they tend to just kill people suspecting them. There is no critical thought beyond that.

What do you think of lethal, cp? Or ODD

So by your thought process, you are saying that scum tpein killed Evans?

could BPD gram lethal tpein fit as a team?

I would say Magic, Nat, maybe Lethal and maybe Gram? Magic also seems to be protecting Gram or pocketing him. Or maybe take out Gram and put in Pein or BPD?

My play was fantastic day 1 considering my 3 of 4 people flipped were my town reads. Odo went off the deep end and didn't want to finish his own wagon so u saw it through because it was better than a cfd on nat at the end of day.

That’s because you townread everyone.

 

[Arne Slot]

ekko is doing that thing where he makes assbackwards conclusions with confidence so I think he's probably town