• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Town reads on Nat are iffy to say the least, super hard sell. I don’t think you could spin fast enough
 
Magic said:
If this is how you read people it's quite frankly shit people. You were off on aurelian and yes that was your read and baffled at me town reading raem. Maybe it isn't best to take shots.

You're playing like ekko where you feel they gotta earn a town read or something and that's silly. You're also putting way more stock into it than it needs. CFDing nat after spending nearly 45 hours on aurelian is counter productive as you were unlikely to budge from there after.
Click to expand...

That has… nothing to do with whether Nat is town or not though does it

Oh, now Aurelian Is MY read I see. Maybe I should have double town read him for working 2 jobs
 
Magic said:
The confidence you make your town reads and staying on them vs me is entirely different.

I.e. you questioned again if maybe odo is scum here cause he's started lacking. I don't just suddenly start doubting my town reads due to contribution dropping.

Aurelian wasn't my main scum read but it felt like the best lynch at the time. I do feel bad about it as aurelian put in a shit ton of.effort but it is what it is.
Click to expand...
i didnt question my reads on melkor or evans in day 1 past the point of making it

questioned rem a bit but was still town for me by time of his death

my day 1 was not the best because i wasnt able to strongly town read aurelian and defend him. we cuda avoided mislynch there

i think locking ppl as town in mafia is stupid honestly. a read can only be so strong, but cant lock it
 
Ekkologix said:
i still want to think tpein and BPD r town but i know they r capable of giving us much more
Click to expand...
Just consider me town here and solve without me in the POE. I'm playing at my own pace this game and I know I haven't contributed a ton, but I really don't think anything I've said or done has been overly wolfy.
 
CraigPelton said:
xadlin comes in and has nothing to say about the Aurelianfest that had dominated much of the thread by this point
Click to expand...
Another thing about Xadlin was that he dropped in and voted for me and said 'I'm okay with a BPD lynch because I found him iffy before' despite having me as a pro-town lean.
 
Magic said:
If this is how you read people it's quite frankly shit people. You were off on aurelian and yes that was your read and baffled at me town reading raem. Maybe it isn't best to take shots.

You're playing like ekko where you feel they gotta earn a town read or something and that's silly. You're also putting way more stock into it than it needs. CFDing nat after spending nearly 45 hours on aurelian is counter productive as you were unlikely to budge from there after.
Click to expand...
ah you said it urself

nat being lynched and flipping town basically gurantees aurelian going today

so why ddint mafia go for it?
 
Magic said:
If this is how you read people it's quite frankly shit people. You were off on aurelian and yes that was your read and baffled at me town reading raem. Maybe it isn't best to take shots.

You're playing like ekko where you feel they gotta earn a town read or something and that's silly. You're also putting way more stock into it than it needs. CFDing nat after spending nearly 45 hours on aurelian is counter productive as you were unlikely to budge from there after.
Click to expand...
are you actually town reading nat? from what I've seen on a reread your main contention is odo's reason for suspecting her isn't valid
 
Xadlin said:
my thoughts:

Town:
Melkor
Gram
Magic
lethal
Hans

Pro town:
Ekko
psychic
Craig
Ekko
Black dragon
Sworder

Indie:
T-pein- hes to good of a heel for me to put in either category.
Evan- his hateboner for t-pein makes him neg in my book

leaning Scum:
natalija- asked for a catchup and posted more then me
odd- odd made some town claims on day 1 so I think thats sus

[vote Lynch odd]
I dont get the whole Aurelian thing that happened for lik 5 -10 pages
Click to expand...

Xadlin said:
@Hans Tweetenberg
Honestly I think most guys seem town to me on day 1. It’s only on day 2 that I can start figuring things better.

But yeah I’ll jump on that wagon since I was iffy on dragon before.
[change lynch vote to black dragon p]
Click to expand...
Nowhere did Xadlin actually say I was iffy before he voted me and he had zero progression on my slot from pro-town to iffy.
 
Black Pegged Dragon said:
Just consider me town here and solve without me in the POE. I'm playing at my own pace this game and I know I haven't contributed a ton, but I really don't think anything I've said or done has been overly wolfy.
Click to expand...
its hard to do that, lack of a definitive town read on u keeps spoiling the PoE we r trying to form, at the very least u can take a stab at the PoE urself as u have better PoV to solve it, unless u think one of the widely town read players r scum. what r ur reads rn?
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top