• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Final Fantasy XIV Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Magic said:
CraigPelton
TSworder
Black Pegged Dragon
Ekkologix
T-Pein™
Psychic
Xadlin
Grammaton
Hans Tweetenberg
Natalija
Odd
Lethal

Obviously least sure on nat/odd but the tracker results look good for odd.

nat still doesn't really vibe scummy to me. i could be wrong but if you guys decide to flip me here i'd prefer that not be the main direction. one of my town reads, at minimum, need to be off.

bpd isn't scum. ever.

i dont think ekko nor grammaton are scum here either at all. if odo is then props for the emotional manipulation. tweet's reaction to my claim, the way he went about his own claim all looked town as well as his early day 1 play. i will say i dont like how he went from aurelian to nat at the end of day 1 for almost no reason outside of cp asking for it but that was my biggest issue with his play.

im willing to trust ekko on psychic at least. also dont see the reason for her to ever move off of aurelian there as scum. she's tunneling me hard but that's not really AI.

the way xaldin claimed and presented his info looked town as well.

all in all, i think lethal/cp have to be scum here and tpein likely with them. tpein made all of his reads off of a bpd scum read and when he was no longer scum he just said he has to think of new reads basically. he was unable to present any new ones. the issue here is lethal and tpein argument doesn't look as s/s.

if im wrong on ekko this is basically all wrong as him being town is pretty foundational to this making any sense. cp did hint at his role but it honestly looked like he was hiding on it and from play itself he doesn't look great. i dont like his progressions, i dont like a lot of his reaosning, i do think he was trying to create a 2 for 1 with nat/aurelian last phase knowing if aurelian wasn't lynch nat would be. his reaction to not getting his lynch this game was opposite to that of mhw where he was much more mad and hungry to get tpein the second day phase whereas the hunger didn't exist at all this phase.

all this said it banks on him not being the cop which is not giving me the best feeling on it at all lol. i do need some level of confirmation ratchet doesn't have godfathers in his game sometimes(at least last game).
Click to expand...
ive played 2 games of his where there was no godfather or cop. its not unusual yes
 
Grammaton said:
Ways to get a town read from magic so far this game:

- Tunnel someone (me)
- Post like a space cadet (Raem)
- refuse to do anything (nat)
- claim in a somewhat goofy way (Xadlin)
Click to expand...
That isn't why I town read you.

Or nat for that matter.

Goofy claiming has typically been a way to find town.

See evans and tweet in your game
 
Grammaton said:
The point I’m making is that generally speaking I can track your reasoning for your reads

Here, your stated reason for town reading evans was, and I’m not joking:

‘Evans is town’
Click to expand...
Did you see how evans was doing his reads? Like it was blatantly town lol. It wasn't meta. He was attempting to develop a proper case.

There are times I think someone Immmis clearly town and that was one of them.
 
Grammaton said:
I’m aware you make town reads, I’ve played with you for years. I think your townreads in this game are horseshit

You think I’m town but you’re acting like I’m acting dishonestly here, it doesn’t compute
Click to expand...
I don't think you're dishonest. This is exhausting.

I'm asking wirh you to play hypothetically so you have somewhere to go post my flip. Instead you just ask me to defend myself when I know you won't conclude I'm town.
 
Magic said:
Did you see how evans was doing his reads? Like it was blatantly town lol. It wasn't meta. He was attempting to develop a proper case.

There are times I think someone Immmis clearly town and that was one of them.
Click to expand...

It’s not impossible to read evans town day 1 - I also did ultimately, what I’m saying is your timing felt generous to me. He’s not the most egregious example and it is plausible for that to be a genuine read, it’s when I take all of them it seems unlikely

Like seriously who’s even left in your POE? Lethal, Tpein, Psychic … CP?
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top