Game Ranked Negima Mafia

[Penguini]

i mean we get Polar today. if they are town, we get whicker and then its night.

 

[Arne Slot]

I don't necessarily agree that they have to be exclusive

 

[Whicker]

i mean we get Polar today. if they are town, we get whicker and then its night.

As I said. Me vs polar today

 

[Arne Slot]

Feels like a false dichotomy tbh, think I'd rather go Retro now

 

[Penguini]

I also think Polar was stalling before claiming as well.

 

[Sky]

I don't necessarily agree that they have to be exclusive

I'd say they probably do? But BG/JK are more likely to have to be exclusive

 

[Polar Bear]

If we're talking roles in themselves Gravedigger seems like the scummiest of the two in more than name.

I've had plenty of corpses to keep me company at night

 

[Penguini]

Feels like a false dichotomy tbh, think I'd rather go Retro now

if Polar flip mafia, we can get Retro.

 

[Arne Slot]

I also think Polar was stalling before claiming as well.

I don't think so, think this was always going to be the role he claims given his immediate sus of whicker's claim

 

[Arne Slot]

I'd say they probably do? But BG/JK are more likely to have to be exclusive

The rolecopy/grave digger can't target any of the same players on the same night

 

[Whicker]

I'd say they probably do? But BG/JK are more likely to have to be exclusive

Polar + Retro easy.
After that it’s probably still Sigi/Orca

 

[Polar Bear]

The rolecopy/grave digger can't target any of the same players on the same night

I can only target already dead players

 

[Arne Slot]

Polar + Retro easy.
After that it’s probably still Sigi/Orca

Orca and Retro won't be scum together

 

[Arne Slot]

I can only target already dead players

and he can only target alive players.

 

[Penguini]

seems very powerful for town to have both roles - maybe one of them is an indie. but zero buys both town

 

[Oneiros]

i mean we get Polar today. if they are town, we get whicker and then its night.

Repeat for Retro/Orca and it's a wrap.

If the game is still going after that and we haven't lost we get Sky and it's the actual, final, decisive, everlasting wrap.

GG WP (famous last words)

 

[Polar Bear]

and he can only target alive players.

Correct. I personally don't think they both would be in the game and whicker just fit his claim

They could technically both be in the game and town but with so many VT....why?

 

[Arne Slot]

Correct. I personally don't think they both would be in the game and whicker just fit his claim

They could technically both be in the game and town but with so many VT....why?

because that reduces the likelihood of them being able to actually get roles? the # of VTs is an argument in favor of them both being town not against.

 

[Arne Slot]

fwiw rolecopy is the more scummy role as it gives mafia information, gravedigger doesn't

 

[Whicker]

Correct. I personally don't think they both would be in the game and whicker just fit his claim

They could technically both be in the game and town but with so many VT....why?

Why would town have two roles that require dead people?
And vts balance my role whereas you just get to know who you copy