• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Unranked Bloodborne Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Ratchet said:
Eh, you're arguing squarely under the premise that I must be scum to make your point - you're not giving due consideration that I haven't made lots of town reads because I just haven't felt the need to do so yet. Again freely admit to being lazy - I would still wager I'm less lazy than the majority of the players in the game.

You're not really addressing the lack of opportunity too - if I disagree with Bachi being town what else have I egregiously missed on, from your perspective?
Click to expand...
I'm arguing youre scum for behaviour of yours that I find scummy rather than towny. I'm not arguing with the premise you have to be scum and I'm dismissing just the "laziness" defense.

You've missed out things you should be able to see that I can't see from my own perspective. Weird that I expect you to see things i otherwise wouldn't eh.
 
Ratchet said:
@Lord Melkor What's your take on all this?
Click to expand...

You look a bit better than Magic in your exchange I think, I do not get how he sees Whicker as obvious town. Though with the amount of inactivity we have right now and I would not lynch a contributing player today.

I agree with @Magic though that Vinegar/Balsamic hunting inactives looks bad. Though Vinegar can play scummy as town, but last game we were town together (DD) I recall more effort from her side.

Sky's early posts seemed kind of shading people to me, like I sometimes play as scum as well. I agree with some of her thoughts though and people familiar with her town play say she should be town, so would not be my immediate POE.

Bachi's case on you was indeed weird, could see him as non-town, I am also not familiar with his town play.

Ekko is all over the place, he could do this as town unfortunately.

Rej could indeed be scum, he posted something barebones and left. Ekko is sure Rej is on his scum meta but flip flopped from him.

My POE right now would be between Balsamic, Bachi, Rej, Orca (I remember one post from him which was no lynch), maybe Whicker, Ekko right now. Not counting people who have not posted.
 
I do this trick every other game or so. Magic is now confirmed town.

Glad I've got one townie in this fluff stage.

UNVOTE
 
I like Magic here honestly, and it's because of something he told me a while ago. To be a good townie, you have to focus on whom you're town reading, rather than whom you're scum reading. Magic is by that logic in good townie mode
 
BalsamicBear said:
I do this trick every other game or so. Magic is now confirmed town.

Glad I've got one townie in this fluff stage.

UNVOTE
Click to expand...
Being deliberately terrible is such a weird play (if it is a play)

Unvote
Vote Ekko

Back to this then?
 
i wanted to give ratchet until day 2 to do something substantial

if bachi remains his strongest push despite admitting he is potentially uninformed/indie its not a good look
 
Sky said:
I like Magic here honestly, and it's because of something he told me a while ago. To be a good townie, you have to focus on whom you're town reading, rather than whom you're scum reading. Magic is by that logic in good townie mode
Click to expand...
he does this as scum too
u just like him cuz he town read u
 
im here rn. going bk to sleep

lean town
bachi
cp

town side of null
magic
maybe fuji?

null
rest

scum side of null
balsamic
maybe sky. cp and magic town read her tho ill take their perspective for now as i dont scum read either

scum lean
melkor
rej
 
I voted for Ekko with no real explanation and Ratchet ignored my vote despite his town read on Ekko. Furthermore, Ekko had no reaction when he posted reads.
FoS on both.

And Magic goes in town reads as well.
The fact that he can do this being a wolf does not mean we should suspect him, it will become obvious in a few days if his intentions are bad

Lord Melkor said:
Do people that strongly read Sky town have prior experience with her town play?
Click to expand...
No, I've never played with anyone named Sky.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top