Game Ranked All of Us Are Dead Mafia

[Dr. Watson]

Close to hammer, if there's a double voter on his wagon it's technically probably already hammered

If not, Craig or Ekko needs to move the vote

@Lethal Idk if you're just doing background work and simply avoiding playing in the thread because of whatever, just vote Dofla

By a miracle he isn't scum, someone can deal with my slot tomorrow
Not sure if scum simply let me invest from one of players Fang gave (one of them being RDK?) as a recommendation so they weren't really interested in blocking me and didn't think I'd just do my own thing because of my time limit
Or it's two shots and since Flower's invest was utterly useless for town, they assumed correctly I'd simply go for a target that wouldn't threaten their team

Only scenarios (for now) I can think of as to why I wasn't blocked or interfered with

 

[Dr. Watson]

Can you explain your tpein read

Same

Also the Aurelian read, could you give me the deets here? Luke, has Craig managed to read Fang as town ever or in the past given a passive Town read on him?
Last game Fang was Town but he was deadset on him being scum regardless.

I think it's an odd read of him this game given past history.
@Aurelian did you notice this?

 

[RDK]

I was hoping today would be cut and dry with lynching Dofla. Gad's read I can sort of get behind and trust with some hesitancy but RDK over Dofla doesn't sit right. There was never a possibility of scum killing Dofla when he was ripe for pushing any easy mislynch on if he was town so it makes the bus drive to Ultra even more shady and Dofla is no newbie to mafia.

Well yeh that's part of it too I'm pretty sure he's advertised as being a pretty competent player which just makes his claimed usage more baffling

 

[RDK]

Same

Also the Aurelian read, could you give me the deets here? Luke, has Craig managed to read Fang as town ever or in the past given a passive Town read on him?
Last game Fang was Town but he was deadset on him being scum regardless.

I think it's an odd read of him this game given past history.
@Aurelian did you notice this?

I think that fang had a weird game last outing ftr

like I think me and cp generally read him well but last game I had a very strong town read on him to start with that flipped 180 by the next phase when he slowed down.

Bottomf line I don't think cp reading fang town here is that weird

 

[Dr. Watson]

Also the logic based on his GAD theory is.. peculiar. Quite lazy for him in terms of observation.

I personally don't see it as a basis to assume he's Town because there's consensus on him (I read him as Town too but for vastly different reasons I don't have time to go over right now.)

Either he's sheeping because he simply doesn't give a fuck about going into the slot in detail or has mech info or he just isn't interested in solving hardcore this time

 

[Dr. Watson]

I think that fang had a weird game last outing ftr

like I think me and cp generally read him well but last game I had a very strong town read on him to start with that flipped 180 by the next phase when he slowed down.

Bottomf line I don't think cp reading fang town here is that weird

Alright that's fair

 

[Dr. Watson]

9am, work at 11 with church people inevitably flooding in (and a double, yaaaay)

Won't be around much, WG game will also start so if we don't hammer I'll be juggling two games in the midst of work and my hands will be tied

So if anyone needs my solving hat on, I don't have alot of time for it which is why I'm dedicating some time rn

 

[Grammaton]

In the event I die tonight, CP should be your priority. However magic blindly following info from a source he shouldn’t immediately trust on a player he previously read town shouldn’t side either - I’d force them both to comment on each other as they’re both good enough to smell the shit on each others breath

 

[Dr. Watson]

Votes:
Gadministraitor -> Ekkologix > Dofla
T-Pein™ -> DoflaMihawk
DoflaMihawk -> Dr. Watson
Craig -> RDK
Gram -> Dofla
Nibel -> Dofla
Aurelian -> Dofla
Dr. Watson -> Dofla

Count:
Ekkologix = 1 (Gadministraitor)
DoflaMihawk = 6 (T-Pein™, GAD, Gram, Nibel, Aurelian, Dr. Watson)
Dr. Watson = 1 (DoflaMihawk)
RDK = 1 (Craig)

Can correct if needed/things were missed

@RDK

Thoughts on the stray votes?

 

[Grammaton]

Don’t ever lynch Nibel, Watson or Aurelian, and probably not gad either

 

[Dr. Watson]

In the event I die tonight, CP should be your priority. However magic blindly following info from a source he shouldn’t immediately trust on a player he previously read town shouldn’t side either - I’d force them both to comment on each other as they’re both good enough to smell the shit on each others breath

Rough because my instinct this game tells me he's town, but will put this in due consideration he's deepwolfing and has the advantage of being able to play this round, too

 

[Dr. Watson]

Scenario 2: Wondering if Dofla is the triple voter or the stray voters could be to avoid a hammer

Scenario 3: Voter already on wagon and it's hammered but Hime just isn't on

Scenario 4: There is no vote count and we're all in a psych ward imagining this

 

[Dr. Watson]

In the event I die tonight,

By the way expanding on this

If you *don't* (considering I wasn't blocked), who do you think could be the next kill if not you? Who would be on the priority list?

 

[Dr. Watson]

Oh yeah, Whicker was a slot Flower ISO'd

Hold up

 

[Grammaton]

By the way expanding on this

If you *don't* (considering I wasn't blocked), who do you think could be the next kill if not you? Who would be on the priority list?

Be you wouldn’t it

 

[Grammaton]

Rough because my instinct this game tells me he's town, but will put this in due consideration he's deepwolfing and has the advantage of being able to play this round, too

He’s not particularly deep though is he, he repped in for whicker

 

[Dr. Watson]

A greeting.

Just skimmed, apparently.

Pretty safe reads.

Activity excuse No 1.



If you‘re sheeping Ultra, why the sus on me anyway.

Eh.

Pretty weak. Also I don‘t think you even have enough Town game samples from me to judge what‘s within my Town range or not. The only Town game we both were Town together here was Darkest Dungeon and you were N1‘d.














So far, all this guy is doing is give activity excuses and dip right after. Also It’s weird he only decides to sheep Ultra on his Dofla vote and not elsewhere. If Dofla is scum, this fits the profile of a Bus vote.

That is if Dofla is scum. Else the guy barely has anything in his ISO which can help with reading him.

Watson claimed a guilty result on me just fyi.

As for why I voted RDK, it was these posts from Ultra which prompted it:






That was Ultra‘s only interaction with RDK and killing him is something I can see scum RDK do to avoid getting destroyed like in Darkest Dungeon.

Hmmmm seems pretty clear then. I feel like bastard cops aren’t really a thing here. What’s the defense?

At this point with what I know I’d vote for you

I really would prefer to do what is best for town and typically that involves not quickly voting for a guilty invest

What‘s your take?

My take is you are almost certainly scum given a guilty invest, VT claim, and a ranked game (meaning unlikely to be bastard results). Otherwise I’m at work and have already had a couple people to tell me to put the phone down so I’ll catch up later. Which means voting doesn’t do much right now.

I don‘t think Fang and Ekko are going to be scum. Too much going against the grain here. Disregarding mech is also well within their Town plays, especially since that‘s how they won MHW.
Magic is almost certainly scum if Dofla is. He‘s protecting him way too much today when the logical course of action is to get rid of the Bus Driver as they can just never be killed at night. I can always be vigged. Dofla can‘t and will just waste another day which is good for scum if he‘s their team mate or not.
Watson should never get lynched. Not even Vigged.

Final Legacy:

Ekko: Town. Had the mindmeld with him and the way he‘s approaching this day with complete disregard for mech is well within his Town range. Why go against the grain so much and defend me? Could just vote me up and call it a day if he‘s scum.
Fang: Same boat as Ekko.
Watson: Town, do Not Touch.


Whicker: Null, his hesitation reflects kinda well on him, though. As scum he could just vote and call it a day.
Pein: Null. Honestly just Vig that slot. Unlike Whicker or Lethal who just aren‘t around he actually is here and does NOTHING.
Lethal: Literal who. Looked lost af, though. Might be inactive Town.

Gram: Possible SK. Too Passive for either Town or Mafia I feel.


Magic: Part of me thinks he‘s just Town and pulling a Purple again because he‘s doing his best to make himself look horrible today. As scum he knows I‘m not scum, so ya.

Gad: Slimy af today. Only rides Magic‘s coat tails.
Nibel: Sus af entrance and play today.
Dofla: Just sus in general.

Important posts

 

[Aurelian]

I don't think Lethal is whoever Dofla is claiming, it's probably just his last ditch effort to hope the vig shoots him.

 

[Grammaton]

Important posts

Whickers ambience there is of somebody who wants to arrange the furniture so that it looks as though he was a reluctant follower of the info - I don’t remember him town reading flower day 1 and if so, why the quandary?

 

[Dr. Watson]

Be you wouldn’t it

While I tend to bluff about my shots because I don't want to put all my cards on the table usually; not sure I'm primary, more just secondary kill
But yeah there's also a chance of this

It's also much easier to simply try to push me as scum cop, like previously

Who else if not me?