Game Ranked I Think You Should Leave - A Mafia Game by Sky

[Polar Bear]

@Flower

You riding dirty this game?

Still curious of this one

idk abt any of yalls invest results but they should be accurate (unless invest immunity/lawyer) cuz i abstained

Cool, cool

These are the quotes that stuck out to me, so I'm comfortable with these as candidates then:
Xadlin
Charlie
Ultra
hime

Some notes: CP seemed to distrust Ultra strongly with some minor suspicion of Hime so it hints that he wanted to make sure that a potential obstruction to town like a scum!Ultra would be dealt with accordingly and pressured as much as possible, as did Magic
Pressure for reactions on all the above slots, see what direction we'll take after we get (un)satisfactory answers

By why that group?

Polar townread me and then scumread me

This is 100% a lie. I was gonna come in hot after Aurelian bc he probably killed xxxxxxx and I want his blood, but now I know you are scum with Aurelian

Vote Frinckles

 

[Flower]

@Dr. Watson you're Town leader now. Show us the way.

 

[Alco]

Read CP's case on Frinckles just now. Absolutely valid points.

vote Frinckles

 

[Ultra]

Hello



The janitored kill was likely mafia but losing magic to an sk or trigger-happy vig was unfortunate

By the way I got a mission for you

Play the game

 

[hime]

Who suspected Magic consistently, name them

flower, aurelian, haza, frinkles, alco, probs some more ppl sussed him too

 

[Chairman Nibel]

flower, aurelian, haza, frinkles, alco, probs some more ppl sussed him too

I had some suspicions on him too

 

[hime]

The situation looks perfect for you to lead us in a lynch against hime I think

slip? lol

 

[Alco]

the unexplained 180 on Magic outta nowhere is amazing, ngl

 

[Flower]

flower, aurelian, haza, frinkles, alco, probs some more ppl sussed him too

I didn't. He was a solid null and turned Town during the night.

 

[Ultra]

flower, aurelian, haza, frinkles, alco, probs some more ppl sussed him too

Ah yes flower definitely shot Magic

 

[hime]

I didn't. He was a solid null and turned Town during the night.

u voted him at some point, did u not?

 

[Ultra]

I think the only player you named who would remotely consider it is Aurelian, and Magic wouldn't even be on the top of that list

Hime in SHAMBLES

 

[Flower]

Ah yes flower definitely shot Magic

I'm not the Vig. Stop messing around.

 

[hime]

Ah yes flower definitely shot Magic

this wasnt my point and u r fully aware of it

 

[Flower]

u voted him at some point, did u not?

To get him to do something.

 

[Hans Tweetenberg]

Alright so I did read up during night, let's see what I can remember

I think Watson and Gad are obvtown, I think Flower is also likely town. Polar might also be town, he's voting all over the place and doesn't seem to care much what others around him are doing, that's in contrast to the Avatar game where he was scum and cared about looking like a towny who's solving. RDK also seems town, his annoyance seems genuine, and the chances of him being annoyed at drawing scum oughta be fairly slim.

I was with CP many many steps of the way in his solving of Ultra/Hime. There were a handful of posts that really looked like omega awkward distancing but there's a certain point where the pairing just doesn't make too much sense as s/s. Also I liked the way Ultra handled the argument with CP, on top of his points against Hime that her cases seem to be too well constructed for her usual MO.

I got more reads but gotta get back to work, be back in an hour or so

 

[Dr. Watson]

Magic's other 8 posts do nothing for me, tbh. His defense of Polar is an easy one to make as any alignment. Borderline whiteknighting.

Looks like it's immediately countered by Fang too.

ISO on suspicion toward Magic's slot:

Well I'm glad you're on the same hymn sheet I am. The reason I think magic is scum is because I think he's told him that he's obvscum and I think that's why your opinion of fang has changed.

Nuanced but if I'm right I'm goated

Unironically I can see this being an idea Magic entertains lmao

I was about to do this lmao
Vote Magic.

I'm not feeling Magic is town and agree with you and Alco but Ultra's enthusiasm to bring pressure and votes on him feels manufactured and planned out. We both don't trust him so why align on Magic with him?

hmmm well i feel nibel being a indie feels right. they went backa nd forth alot, not taking any real sides really.

magic was scum a earlier game, adn have not posted much so i could put my vote on them.

and then there were polar. which im not sure ive played wiht before. tho im intrigued in seeing how they play, so i might just not vote them due to curiosity

allå allå? emliga armen?
no im never good at reading anyone at day 1.

tbh i would jump on the magic train, since i dont know much of the polar bear.

probably not. i cant even remeber which game it was. couldnt have been the bleach game?
or did he turn out to be town?
anyway, what i remnember was how much engaged magic was adn then either flower or magic turned out to be scum or something.

u asked for another example of scum magic starting out with scum reading ppl rather than jumping to town clears
thats the most recent example i can find

pretty sure alco did this last time he drew scum

Why me specifically

Why do you have Magic as town?

Why don't you lol

Magic wouldn't make this post as mafia - so hard town read

It's not her meta it's the fact her townread of magic was clearly manufactured

As I've said, I've done that before as town so it's not necessarily the worst thing but it's not a good look

Hime's town read of Magic is a bit suspicious cause it was a weak reasoning to use for him but I think it's apparent that Hime and Ultra + Polar aren't aligned.

I have a bit typed up on my computer but I'm going to the store now. Since I that's likely insufficient for you I can offer a TLDR/Sparknotes:

Part 1 was magic sussy then he say go away and I say why you do this then i thonk whether he town meta

part 2 was me drunk and ultra controlling town me scared but probably just drunk

part 3 involved a tale of arctic critters and a funny theory about whether they're aligned

Vote Count

Polar 2 - Aurelian, Chuck
Ultra 1 - Cubey
Magic 2 - Alco, Xadlin
Hime 1 - Penguini
Xadlin 1 - Magic
Aurelian 1 - Polar
Penguini 11 - Ultra, Flower, CP, Frinckles, RDK, Nibel, Hime, Penguini, Gad, Retro
Frinckles 1 - Orca

Spoiler: Vote Progression

Magic: Penguini > Xadlin
Flower: Hime > RDK > Alco > Ultra > Penguini > Nibel > Chuck > Polar > Ultra > Magic > Penguini > RDK > Penguini > Hime > Chuck > Xadlin > Penguini
Hime: Alco > Penguini > Nibel > Ultra > Penguini
Aurelian: CP > Alco > Ultra > Polar
Gad: Ultra > Penguini > Nibel > Polar > Penguini
Ultra: Penguini > Hime > Penguini > Hime > none > Penguini
Nibel: Penguini > none > Nibel > none > Polar > none > Aurelian > none > Penguini > Hime > none > Penguini
Orca: Frinckles > Flower > Frinckles > none > Penguini > Xadlin > Frinckles
Polar: Flower > Aurelian > Frinckles > none > RDK > Aurelian
RDK: Aurelian > Penguini > Hime > Penguini > Hime > Penguini
Alco: Magic
Frinckles: Magic > Gad > Nibel > Polar > Chuck > Penguini
Xadlin: Magic
Retro: Penguini > none > Nibel > Penguini
CP: Ultra > Hime > Frinckles > Hime > Xadlin > Penguini
Cubey: Ultra
Penguini: Orca > Hime > Penguini
Chuck: Polar

Day 1 has ended. Stop posting now. Flip will come in about 10 minutes.

 

[Alco]

I thought Magic's start of the game was shit. Alas, I was wrong.

 

[The Orca]

Vote Frinckles

 

[Ultra]

Xadlin was a very likely vig candidate so obviously that implicates him as well, if Hime flips scum BD I'd hit that up too