Game Ranked I Think You Should Leave - A Mafia Game by Sky

[Alco]

Off to bed, see you fine gentlemen and ladies on the morrow!

 

[RDK]

breh. when you wanna wifom just leave it at the first level with me

Talking shite then

 

[Frinckles]

Talking shite then

That's what I usually do.

 

[Ultra]

Not what I did. I targetted Magic and know it wasn't Hime instead of him. Not saying more.

Oh well thanks for giving away your role

 

[Flower]

(This is not a Vig claim. I did something else to Magic).

 

[Dr. Watson]

@Frinckles

Do you math good

Think you could give some statistical based thoughts on the wagons forming/developing aka the likelihood how many of these slots would be town vs scum bussing because their mate has been caught?

Latter scenario seems highly unlikely but does happen, if you math gud u make happy

 

[Dr. Watson]

(This is not a Vig claim. I did something else to Magic).

Keep it to yourself

Damn, girl!

 

[Dr. Watson]

(Jest)

 

[Chuck]

(This is not a Vig claim. I did something else to Magic).

you,ve said already you're not vig .-.

 

[Frinckles]

(This is not a Vig claim. I did something else to Magic).

Oh well thanks for giving away your role

wine in front of somebody

 

[Dr. Watson]

Flower you should have done a thought experiment and just rolled with the punches to see how many of us would tinfoil on you being vig, that would've been hella funny

But atleast I can analyze people being invested and comfortable trying to find the vig and it rules you out (maybe?) as a potential night target I suppose

 

[Frinckles]

@Frinckles

Do you math good

Think you could give some statistical based thoughts on the wagons forming/developing aka the likelihood how many of these slots would be town vs scum bussing because their mate has been caught?

Latter scenario seems highly unlikely but does happen, if you math gud u make happy

Technically that's my worst subject, my second worst is gym but I'm down for some VCA.

If we're talking EoD, give me a second to pull up the vc. I remember Hime defending Polar and then that wagon dropped off the face of the earth.

 

[Chuck]

Technically that's my worst subject, my second worst is gym but I'm down for some VCA.

If we're talking EoD, give me a second to pull up the vc. I remember Hime defending Polar and then that wagon dropped off the face of the earth.

Vote Count

Polar 2 - Aurelian, Chuck
Ultra 1 - Cubey
Magic 2 - Alco, Xadlin
Hime 1 - Penguini
Xadlin 1 - Magic
Aurelian 1 - Polar
Penguini 11 - Ultra, Flower, CP, Frinckles, RDK, Nibel, Hime, Penguini, Gad, Retro
Frinckles 1 - Orca

Spoiler: Vote Progression

Magic: Penguini > Xadlin
Flower: Hime > RDK > Alco > Ultra > Penguini > Nibel > Chuck > Polar > Ultra > Magic > Penguini > RDK > Penguini > Hime > Chuck > Xadlin > Penguini
Hime: Alco > Penguini > Nibel > Ultra > Penguini
Aurelian: CP > Alco > Ultra > Polar
Gad: Ultra > Penguini > Nibel > Polar > Penguini
Ultra: Penguini > Hime > Penguini > Hime > none > Penguini
Nibel: Penguini > none > Nibel > none > Polar > none > Aurelian > none > Penguini > Hime > none > Penguini
Orca: Frinckles > Flower > Frinckles > none > Penguini > Xadlin > Frinckles
Polar: Flower > Aurelian > Frinckles > none > RDK > Aurelian
RDK: Aurelian > Penguini > Hime > Penguini > Hime > Penguini
Alco: Magic
Frinckles: Magic > Gad > Nibel > Polar > Chuck > Penguini
Xadlin: Magic
Retro: Penguini > none > Nibel > Penguini
CP: Ultra > Hime > Frinckles > Hime > Xadlin > Penguini
Cubey: Ultra
Penguini: Orca > Hime > Penguini
Chuck: Polar

Day 1 has ended. Stop posting now. Flip will come in about 10 minutes.

here

 

[Ultra]

Why did Juice, a randomized lyncher, even need a voyeur or follower for

Weird role

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Read CP's case on Frinckles just now. Absolutely valid points.

vote Frinckles

Elaborate. I don't like that you're just kinda using a dead player's post as a spring board to bring nothing to the table.

flower, aurelian, haza, frinkles, alco, probs some more ppl sussed him too

You got reads on them? I town read at least two of them, and I don't know who Haza is. What are your thoughts on frinkles rn? I feel like you're tunneling Nibel (whose read I agree with you on) and Ultra heavily. I want to see other reads from you.

Alright so I did read up during night, let's see what I can remember

I think Watson and Gad are obvtown, I think Flower is also likely town. Polar might also be town, he's voting all over the place and doesn't seem to care much what others around him are doing, that's in contrast to the Avatar game where he was scum and cared about looking like a towny who's solving. RDK also seems town, his annoyance seems genuine, and the chances of him being annoyed at drawing scum oughta be fairly slim.

I was with CP many many steps of the way in his solving of Ultra/Hime. There were a handful of posts that really looked like omega awkward distancing but there's a certain point where the pairing just doesn't make too much sense as s/s. Also I liked the way Ultra handled the argument with CP, on top of his points against Hime that her cases seem to be too well constructed for her usual MO.

I got more reads but gotta get back to work, be back in an hour or so

This reminded me why Ultra is town read for me. CP basically cleared him. I guess the CP lynch should clear boobies.

Now onto what I don't like about this post. Polar being all over the place is not scummy because it's different from another game? Maybe it's just me but that lack of care seems less town and more scum to me, regardless of how he played in any other game. I'm failing to see why anyone would clear him or his killer dolphin sibling.

Xadlin was a very likely vig candidate so obviously that implicates him as well, if Hime flips scum BD I'd hit that up too

Don't forget Lethal and Cubey

literal slip and everyone is ignoring it
NIBEL TOWN READS ME

How is this a slip?

Well I’m here now. What’s the major discussions?

Go read up on CP's reads at least and get back to us on his reads. C'mon mate, it won't take long, I promise.

Nibel wagon has potential today?

Sexy

He's slippery. I feel like everytime he has some pressure on him, he disappears and then appears when there's a slight push on someone else to jump that wagon, or subtly add to that push. If this were anyone else but Nipples, that's obvscum move.

With nipples, I still read it as scum but idk man. I can't read him.

caught in 4k

Sorry but this is a stretch. You should read other people before you head back to the nipple train, and I'm with you on that train. But I feel like you're ignoring a lot to focus on him.

@Gadministraitor what's your thoughts?

Unsure, developing as I read but aside from Ultra moving to town on my reads, owing to his CP interactions, I'm still not sure. Hime's entering scumzone too

Also, I'm eating and I made this beautiful garlic and turmeric rice. Wanna try?

Had a quick look at Nibel's last two pages of posts and I don't see a hard town read tbh. More like hesitance because they buy into Hime's call to emotion.

Who's buying into Hime's call to emotion? What's your read on Nipples?

Yeah Hime is definitively town there is now way scums let someone play this way

You've been in a scum team and you know we've made plenty of mistakes together. I don't buy your post here. It's not like scum filters every post they make.

Me pushing magic feels safe? What. Everything else you said is fair. Except for the tinfoil part, SeaWorld is real.

I'm assuming you mean the vitiligo panda and his sibling here?

Not half as bad as that

What even is this? What are you trying to communicate here?

Can you like, explain this problem? I could see town being frustrated to be lynched D1. I could see scum being frustrated for the same reason. What's up with this?

Welp, we've kinda started talking about both cp and magic and there's not much else to say about Magic from what i remember.

Fang welp, isn't here, so i can't really tell. Like, he did nothing for me to feel worse about this spot but I'd like if he's more present.

For town i'd list you (mostly because i can see you're being openminded and looking in different directions). Flower since early game, how she handled my inactivity here sounded like concerned town to me. Shift on hime was somewhat crazy but like, if she's scum with hime, she's putting herself in bad position and if she's scum and hime's town, she wouldn't need to defend her earlier. Gad sounds genuine too. Other than that, not much tbh.

Nibel i liked at first but then as i was reading i noticed wierd posts like, at one time he's trying to undermine himself as a noobie but then goes after someone (gad? cp? i don't remember) and basically disses their gameplay. Maybe it's just some strategy or some joke i'm not getting idk, but he also has that pr so that's something.

Hime early i'd say i was confident was town. Now i'm not really sure (didn't like the way she handled claim tbh). She's completely sold on Ultra it seems (and vice versa). Ultra i wasn't a fan of earlier and tbh i still don't really trust him, but it got better. Not sure how much of it is just that he's focusing on other people so that i'm not overly defensive.

For other people I don't have much tbh

Nipple's play hasn't changed at all since the beginning. He's just as confusing now as he was before. What exactly did you like about him at the beginning? Several players even agreed that everything about him was super scummy there. I don't like this point here. It feels like you're trying to add more nuance to your reads than you actually have.

That being said, I'm now kinda unsure about Hime. Part of that is definitely how many people have changed their mind on her, but mostly cause I feel like the tunneling is because she cannot genuinely bring up reads on other people and that's really concerning. So that point, I see it gelling with my thought process.

Also, can you tell me why you think Flower's shift on Hime is that crazy?

vote lynch: alco

Quoting cause it's last post I read. Gonna use you as a bookmark comrade, hope you don't mind.

 

[Frinckles]

Polar 2 - Aurelian, Chuck
Ultra 1 - Cubey
Magic 2 - Alco, Xadlin
Hime 1 - Penguini
Xadlin 1 - Magic
Aurelian 1 - Polar
Penguini 11 - Ultra, Flower, CP, Frinckles, RDK, Nibel, Hime, Penguini, Gad, Retro
Frinckles 1 - Orca

 

[Chuck]

Why did Juice, a randomized lyncher, even need a voyeur or follower for

Weird role

to have something she could claim that could technically be verified?

 

[Frinckles]

Why did Juice, a randomized lyncher, even need a voyeur or follower for

Weird role

huh

 

[Sharter Holmes]

(This is not a Vig claim. I did something else to Magic).

Ngl, part of me wishes it was a vig claim, would have helped us push someone.

 

[Dr. Watson]

Btw I don't think this phase is an appropriate one to mass action claim or whatever you call it, outing the actions this early on is no bueno and guarantees one of you as a target vs whatever scum are deciding to do now so shut your fucking traps unless you REALLY think it's important to share your results

Does anyone feel the need to do this today or are we good to wait for tomorrow?
If so, here's questions we need to ask first:
Does it help resolve a slot being suspected and pave the way for someone else in the scum piles?

Basically I don't want players like RDK to avoid sharinf results this phase as it'd have a higher likelihood of a kill on him and we need him as part of a cohesive town

Keep your cards close to your chest first, then we start ripping out organs
Or you can disagree but I think it gives town more of an advantage to avoid claiming actions outright so in players that have strong town credentials/lead, we buy them an extra night maybe