• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked OLF Members Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've got quite a bit to give a good read of....but Flower's start to this day raises some red flags - hounds Nibel for the shot target, spews a rather interesting explanation for survival, then has a tantrum over being asked to claim. Dislike the whole approach.
What part of that makes her scum though? Just to break this down:

>hounds Nibel
This is well within reason. Nibel had no reason to shoot her off the back of CP's scum flip. Notably, she hasn't tried to argue Nibel is scum.

>spews a rather interesting explanation
Not really. She knows Nibel has an extra shot, as per Aurelian's flip, so from her perspective she is either protected, or Nibel is blocked. I guess you could say she should have assumed she was protected before assuming Nibel was blocked, but that's not a massive logic gap.

>throws a tantrum over being asked to claim
Do you think Town!Flower would not do this, and if so... why?

Kweh!
 
What part of no didn’t you understand?

I didn't like this "mind reader" thing you replied with.
Obviously you can get a sense of where he will shoot by just reading his posts....
I was basically asking you if it was apparent he was gonna shoot flower.
 
What part of that makes her scum though? Just to break this down:

>hounds Nibel
This is well within reason. Nibel had no reason to shoot her off the back of CP's scum flip. Notably, she hasn't tried to argue Nibel is scum.

>spews a rather interesting explanation
Not really. She knows Nibel has an extra shot, as per Aurelian's flip, so from her perspective she is either protected, or Nibel is blocked. I guess you could say she should have assumed she was protected before assuming Nibel was blocked, but that's not a massive logic gap.

>throws a tantrum over being asked to claim
Do you think Town!Flower would not do this, and if so... why?

Kweh!
Whilst I don't recall her play style I've hardly seen a time where she's refused to claim in the way she's showing here.

But I'm vibing you as towny so far on what i've read so I'll put trust in you for this
 
Hello friends and enemies, I'm glad you're all here for my first game back since the summer. I do not plan on reading D1 or D2, but I did see CP was wolf, so what I will do is iso him and use that as my lead. However, that won't be happening until the weekend, so I'll just be lurking and seeing what's up. Also, I haven't even looked at my role yet so you can be sure I'm coming yo with completely unbiased opinions. ;)
 
Hello friends and enemies, I'm glad you're all here for my first game back since the summer. I do not plan on reading D1 or D2, but I did see CP was wolf, so what I will do is iso him and use that as my lead. However, that won't be happening until the weekend, so I'll just be lurking and seeing what's up. Also, I haven't even looked at my role yet so you can be sure I'm coming yo with completely unbiased opinions. ;)

Smart

Scummy, but smart
 
And I answered, no I didn’t know

Ok and then why is flower sus for this?
if the vig had no clear target then you just block it anticipating it might hit your mates for some reason.
you are trying to shade flower here implying that scum blocking the vig is laughable or absurd.
 
I think you are talking bollocks m8

You don’t remember her playstyle but you don’t remember her ever being selfish???
Huh?
My memory is shit. She's been plenty selfish but that's separate from play style, no? Maybe I'm confusing myself with her willingness to claim compared to her actual play.
 
Hello friends and enemies, I'm glad you're all here for my first game back since the summer. I do not plan on reading D1 or D2, but I did see CP was wolf, so what I will do is iso him and use that as my lead. However, that won't be happening until the weekend, so I'll just be lurking and seeing what's up. Also, I haven't even looked at my role yet so you can be sure I'm coming yo with completely unbiased opinions. ;)
what is the lore between u and poyser? y did he ignore list u? 🤔
 
well yes i did think his kill was a daykill
i didnt town read him and i thought that there was no way non-town would have such a role

i didnt really think that much before using it
i gave aurelian a death threat saying to kill cp or i would make sure he dies
i just tried following thru on that
i town read magic and didnt aurelian too so it just felt right too after seeing him try and kill a townie in my eyes

honestly, it felt fine after i submitted it and thought abt it more too bc worst case, he is town and dies and we lynch cp anyway
best case he would be scum/sk and then we kill him thru the duel and eliminate a night kill
or thats what i thought then anyway
You didn't really address the most important part there which was your (lack of) reaction to my post to you yesterday. I profile you as someone who is not prepared to take shit from anyone - I've been on the receiving end of this sentiment and I've seen many others receive it too, it's really hard for me to believe you just take that without any sort of response.

To be fair to you, I do think even without your duel we lynch Aurelian before CP in that scenario but I really wish it was never used. I don't see any real use with your role. I will admit though, I can't really think of any girl/feminist that fits the role half as well as X does.

Kweh!
 
no other power role outed rn.
they would just be using it randomly hoping it does something.
think vig just got blocked for paranoia
 
well yes i did think his kill was a daykill
i didnt town read him and i thought that there was no way non-town would have such a role

i didnt really think that much before using it
i gave aurelian a death threat saying to kill cp or i would make sure he dies
i just tried following thru on that
i town read magic and didnt aurelian too so it just felt right too after seeing him try and kill a townie in my eyes

honestly, it felt fine after i submitted it and thought abt it more too bc worst case, he is town and dies and we lynch cp anyway
best case he would be scum/sk and then we kill him thru the duel and eliminate a night kill
or thats what i thought then anyway
But why would we need the duel to do that when we have a lynch?

You took away the option for those that would have still preferred CP over Aurelian.

As town there's literally no reason to use that role.

So now we have to decide if you were just acting selfishly as town or protecting CP as scum.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top