• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked OLF Christmas Mafia 2023 (Day 9)

Reader mode
Ral said:
Absolutely playing, and I've already contributed by placing my vote. If there's anything specific you'd like me to address or discuss, feel free to let me know. We're all here to make the game interesting and strategic, right? I've also noticed a few patterns in previous games, and while it's early to draw conclusions, I have a gut feeling about potential scum. I've been keeping a close eye on everyone's contributions up until now and seeing how things are unfolding.
Click to expand...

Who
 
Ral said:
Absolutely playing, and I've already contributed by placing my vote. If there's anything specific you'd like me to address or discuss, feel free to let me know. We're all here to make the game interesting and strategic, right? I've also noticed a few patterns in previous games, and while it's early to draw conclusions, I have a gut feeling about potential scum. I've been keeping a close eye on everyone's contributions up until now and seeing how things are unfolding.
Click to expand...
You can follow me my companion. We lizards are a truth worthy sort.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Ral
Evans said:
GTH out of

Luka
Polar
T-Pein
Me
and Poyser

Can you put these in order of most scummy and tell me why?
Click to expand...
You
Luka
=Polar

I'd probably put Poyser below T-Pein. I've actually liked most of Poyser's content outside of the issue I've taken with him.

You - I think your arguments are not based in reality and do not demonstrate any kind of critical analysis that should be present. Pretty clear to me that you came in with an angle that you wanted to push and you've stuck with it, and it's not even at the point where you're just misunderstanding something, your takes are literally not grounded in reality whatsoever.

Polar - Already talked about, plus the fact he fell off the face of the earth too once pressure went away from him.

Luka - Already discussed, also vanished for the most part.
 
Ratchet said:
You obviously haven't been following

Which begs the question as to why this is your position then!
Click to expand...

In the civilised world, we are open to the idea we may be wrong- hence me asking which post Ultra is happy with WRT you. Maybe I’m reading it all wrong!

This is my position because based on the posts of yours that I’m aware of, they’re mostly just full of bluster and faux outrage, which predisposes me against you and makes me think you’re acting in bad faith - it’s a hallmark of your scum play. Can you point to a single post of yours this game where you have checked your own working and assumptions?

Please don’t threaten my points!
 
Poyser said:
Are you serious
Literally the two games I’ve seen him as scum, Elden ring and flowers vanilla game, he stuck around and argued the toss and didn’t slink off and ignore the thread at all lol. Where have you got this from?

In flowers vanilla game I distinctly remember him arguing with CP for the entire day one

You’ve noticed he town read pretty much everyone that was pushing him here? When does he do that as town literally ever?
Click to expand...
Good post :penn:
 
Ral said:
Absolutely playing, and I've already contributed by placing my vote. If there's anything specific you'd like me to address or discuss, feel free to let me know. We're all here to make the game interesting and strategic, right? I've also noticed a few patterns in previous games, and while it's early to draw conclusions, I have a gut feeling about potential scum. I've been keeping a close eye on everyone's contributions up until now and seeing how things are unfolding.
Click to expand...

Could you share some of this please?
 
Ultra said:
I changed my mind think Aurelian is town

Poyser trying to bury him with momentum, we've got time on the clock, also other options and a bunch of chicklefucks who havent done anything.
Click to expand...
You may be overthinking
 
Ratchet said:
You
Luka
=Polar

I'd probably put Poyser below T-Pein. I've actually liked most of Poyser's content outside of the issue I've taken with him.

You - I think your arguments are not based in reality and do not demonstrate any kind of critical analysis that should be present. Pretty clear to me that you came in with an angle that you wanted to push and you've stuck with it, and it's not even at the point where you're just misunderstanding something, your takes are literally not grounded in reality whatsoever.

Polar - Already talked about, plus the fact he fell off the face of the earth too once pressure went away from him.

Luka - Already discussed, also vanished for the most part.
Click to expand...

So why aren’t you pushing for me to be lynched?
 
Ultra said:
Flowers game? The one where he had 30 posts and subbed out?

Reaching the bottom of the barrel here, feel like you've proven my point.
Click to expand...
Oh right, we are going by number of posts? Did you actually read the posts?

Tbh I don’t know what game I’m thinking of where he was arguing the toss but having checked, it wasn’t flowers game. However your point sucks because in literally both of these games he defended accusations against him and wasn’t really ducking the thread

Search results for query: *

onelastforum.com onelastforum.com


Search results for query: *

onelastforum.com onelastforum.com
 
Ratchet said:
I agree with the T-Pein read though? Also they're different players with different styles so why would you equivocate them?

This is awful.

Firstly, "low hanging fruit" doesn't mean they're not scum, and given I went at Poyser too it's not even accurate.

The historical trends point is completely misrepresenting what I said - for Luka I was citing his meta, which is perfectly valid. In regards to CP, I was dismissing the idea that Polar gets pushed and ends up being town, because it has no relevance to this game.

You're clearly just picking things to argue, you go to lean scum.
Click to expand...

Ratchet said:
You are conflating two different terms by "historical trends", you know this because you quoted the posts. What the fuck am I reading - meta is one thing, Polar being pressured in other games isn't meta, it's completely irrelevant.

How can I be distancing from a wagon that doesn't even exist? What are you on about- I was asked by Ekko who I would go for if Luka was taken aside, I said Polar - my vote was on Luka before I just moved it to you. Get out, you obviously just came into this thread to push an angle, which happens to line up with what you were pushing last game when you were scum, I've seen enough.
Click to expand...

Ratchet said:
I've just explained this to CP - Polar's entrance voting on the Indie, and his posts following up on suspicion of him.

I know what meta is, I don't think you do. CP brought up Polar having been pressured before and ended up being town, my response to that was to say that what happened in previous games is irrelevant here, i.e Polar having being pressured in another game has no influence on his alignment here. That's the "historical trends" I'm dismissing. I never dismissed meta, and anyone functionally literate can see I never dismissed meta, so what's your excuse?

I know your gameplan here - you're going to continue to argue because your goal is to frustrate your interlocutor, feel free to appeal to someone else with your arguments, I'm not going to bother. My vote will stay.
Click to expand...

@Grammaton
 
If I’ve completely overtaken your scum reads as public enemy no 1 - why aren’t you at all pushing for my wagon?

But just letting yourself get tied up in my “nonsense”?
 
Probs cos you’re scum and the more you frame my arguments as nonsense, the less shit you’ll take when I flip town if you can manage to lynch me (doubt it)
 
The way the momentum of Aurelian's wagon died instantly when Ultra showed up is very much noted

Will be very interesting to see Aurelian or Luka's flip considering how hard things shifted
 
Poyser said:
Oh right, we are going by number of posts? Did you actually read the posts?

Tbh I don’t know what game I’m thinking of where he was arguing the toss but having checked, it wasn’t flowers game. However your point sucks because in literally both of these games he defended accusations against him and wasn’t really ducking the thread

Search results for query: *

onelastforum.com onelastforum.com


Search results for query: *

onelastforum.com onelastforum.com
Click to expand...

Yeah he reads like a total chicken shit pussy and then subs out of the game in the middle of Day 1.

Again how does this comparison serve your point 🤣

This framing is actually wildly disingenuous, hitting the sub out button is the ultimate "get me the fuck outta here" play and you're trying to say "but he argued with CP"
 
Grammaton said:
In the civilised world, we are open to the idea we may be wrong- hence me asking which post Ultra is happy with WRT you. Maybe I’m reading it all wrong!

This is my position because based on the posts of yours that I’m aware of, they’re mostly just full of bluster and faux outrage, which predisposes me against you and makes me think you’re acting in bad faith - it’s a hallmark of your scum play. Can you point to a single post of yours this game where you have checked your own working and assumptions?

Please don’t threaten my points!
Click to expand...
I think that's more on what you're reading into my posts - I've had a discussion with Poyser earlier where I laid out my considerations in regards to Aurelian and conceded once he presented something I found to be compelling.

My issue with you here is that even a glancing read over the discussion between Evans and me should highlight the issues with what he's asking, you basically haven't done that so what am I supposed to do with your response exactly?
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top