• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Game Ranked Grand Theft Auto Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
GTH I'd say town actually
That's better because it's a least a position. To that end then, who do you think is scum so far, because personally I think most of the thread has been townie. Lethal can be one, but I think Magic's read there warrants some consideration.
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
That's better because it's a least a position. To that end then, who do you think is scum so far, because personally I think most of the thread has been townie. Lethal can be one, but I think Magic's read there warrants some consideration.

My only other scum reads besides Magic/Lethal would be on like RDK or something who seems like he's struggling to fit in, but
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
My only other scum reads besides Magic/Lethal would be on like RDK or something who seems like he's struggling to fit in, but
Fair enough, I don't have a read on RDK yet but I can agree there. However, I don't think Magic/Lethal are likely to be scum together. Arbitrarily defending his teammate is not something he does.
 

Magic

Resplendent
My only other scum reads besides Magic/Lethal would be on like RDK or something who seems like he's struggling to fit in, but
Don't think there's any world where you should have lethal as scum unless you think you can read him better than me as town. I'm not treating his slot like that as s/s so that's pretty weak.
 

Magic

Resplendent
Ultra ill let you try again, expand on your scum read on me and how it makes sense in your world.

You said my pushes were bad and then used the fact many had them as town as a point even though that happened after my initial push not before. The flower stuff you posted was garbage because yes it can be expectation that flower sheeps when her meta involves a lot of sheeping of stronger players.

Do you have any actual substance to stand on this business? Because that lethal pairing was below you.
 

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
I do think there is a disparity with Magic though - what he's arguing with Ultra should be enough to have a scum read there, just last game for example he cited a lack of wider consideration in a tunnel that lasted 3 days. That was the correct read and Magic was town. Here he's identifying parts of the argument that Ultra is making as weak and is qualifying why Ultra's accusation is weak, and it's all fair, except it doesn't have the conclusion there, and I don't find his "you are bad as Scum" to be a very good explanation for why he thinks it's worth overlooking.
 

Magic

Resplendent
I do think there is a disparity with Magic though - what he's arguing with Ultra should be enough to have a scum read there, just last game for example he cited a lack of wider consideration in a tunnel that lasted 3 days. That was the correct read and Magic was town. Here he's identifying parts of the argument that Ultra is making as weak and is qualifying why Ultra's accusation is weak, and it's all fair, except it doesn't have the conclusion there, and I don't find his "you are bad as Scum" to be a very good explanation for why he thinks it's worth overlooking.

That is quite literally why I made my last post.
 

Ultra

THE BEAR
Moderator
Ultra ill let you try again, expand on your scum read on me and how it makes sense in your world.

You said my pushes were bad and then used the fact many had them as town as a point even though that happened after my initial push not before. The flower stuff you posted was garbage because yes it can be expectation that flower sheeps when her meta involves a lot of sheeping of stronger players.

Do you have any actual substance to stand on this business? Because that lethal pairing was below you.

I didn't pair you and Lethal, I said I had you both as suspects.

You will not convince me my read on Flower was garbage. Last game you snap suspected me for not towing Aurelian.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top