• We are currently rolling out incremental alterations to the forum. Don't freak! You aren't going crazy.

Game Ranked Castlevania animated series Mafia - Game Thread

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Ratchet

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
Test
hime said:
like i said multiple times now, my reads wouldnt change if u flip town
i already thought abt the different slots when giving u my answers earlier

if ur argument is that magic would be town if ur town then i suggest u reread my reasons for scum reading him
also i feel like its incredibly lazy to town read magic for saying "Who thinks ratchet/ultra are t/t?"
hes gone absolutely nowhere with it and there isnt enough evidence for me to believe he actually even believes that
Click to expand...
Well I appreciate that there isn't much to read him from. We can only work with what we have though, right? My argument is that if Ultra and I are Town, Magic as scum would be sabotaging an optimal direction for his team, without offering much to the thread. It doesn't really make much sense. My point really is that this is the sort of thing you need to be considering, even if the conclusions of the reads themselves don't change much if at all.
 
hime

hime

Exceptional
Pronouns
She/Her
Ratchet said:
Well I appreciate that there isn't much to read him from. We can only work with what we have though, right? My argument is that if Ultra and I are Town, Magic as scum would be sabotaging an optimal direction for his team, without offering much to the thread. It doesn't really make much sense. My point really is that this is the sort of thing you need to be considering, even if the conclusions of the reads themselves don't change much if at all.
Click to expand...
hes not sabotaging anything bc hes not pushing it nor is he even saying that he believes u both r t/t
he just asked a question if anyone thinks that
 
Ratchet

Ratchet

Moderator
Moderator
Test
hime said:
hes not sabotaging anything bc hes not pushing it nor is he even saying that he believes u both r t/t
he just asked a question if anyone thinks that
Click to expand...
Ah but he is - bringing it up at all runs the risk of people thinking about it, and therefore, if people are thinking about it, it's possible they could conclude it. It would be needlessly damaging to his team, given he apparently isn't doing anything else for them. From my position, I think Ultra is scum but it doesn't really mean all that much to me, but if you think Ultra is town, and you have me flipping town, then scum aren't going to be the ones who are trying to bridge the gap. They're going to be the ones stoking the fire (Ekko kind of did this in response to Magic, which is what is giving me reservations on him).
 
Dr. Watson

Dr. Watson

‣ ↻
Administrator
That read as facetious to me, hime.

But i think it depends on how you read it. Are you saying he's open scumming with Ekko there or do you mean it wasn't intentional, less tongue and cheek?
 
hime

hime

Exceptional
Pronouns
She/Her
Ratchet said:
Ah but he is - bringing it up at all runs the risk of people thinking about it, and therefore, if people are thinking about it, it's possible they could conclude it. It would be needlessly damaging to his team, given he apparently isn't doing anything else for them. From my position, I think Ultra is scum but it doesn't really mean all that much to me, but if you think Ultra is town, and you have me flipping town, then scum aren't going to be the ones who are trying to bridge the gap. They're going to be the ones stoking the fire (Ekko kind of did this in response to Magic, which is what is giving me reservations on him).
Click to expand...
ok im going to ask u who
bc i highly doubt the majority will change their opinion
a couple ppl thinking that isnt really going to do anything
 
Dr. Watson

Dr. Watson

‣ ↻
Administrator
Ratchet said:
"I told you to wait 3 minutes Ekko". It was a bit of fun, the 3 minutes is completely arbitrary.
Click to expand...
It doesn't matter but I'm curious.

How many times have you slipped outside scum chat before/posted something that was meant for PM?
Or am I right to assume you're more meticulous and try to not be careless like that (unless you wanted to get away with it I guess)?
 
hime

hime

Exceptional
Pronouns
She/Her
Ratchet said:
"I told you to wait 3 minutes Ekko". It was a bit of fun, the 3 minutes is completely arbitrary.
Click to expand...
that what i called the slip

could be mad at ekko in scum chat for not waiting for rugrats response and accidentally posted in the thread instead of ur chat
 
hime

hime

Exceptional
Pronouns
She/Her
Dr. Watson said:
That read as facetious to me, hime.

But i think it depends on how you read it. Are you saying he's open scumming with Ekko there or do you mean it wasn't intentional, less tongue and cheek?
Click to expand...
obviously unintentional considering i labeled it as a possible "slip"
 
Dr. Watson

Dr. Watson

‣ ↻
Administrator
Yeah but what I mean is what is the possibility of an intentional slip vs and unintentional one? And why do you think he's more likely to do the former?

We're going to start arguing in circles so for this to be a legitimate point of comparison then receipts need to be dug up from past games as proof he slips on accident

Else you're gonna be stuck in a he said she said scenario like right now - he can easily counter with "but I was just joking brah. Anyway here's wonder wall"

Like how do you prove something like this if it's, from that point of view, crucial to catching him as scum?
 
hime

hime

Exceptional
Pronouns
She/Her
Dr. Watson said:
Or am I right to assume you're more meticulous and try to not be careless like that (unless you wanted to get away with it I guess)?
Click to expand...
do u think some ppl try to be careless? and do u think if someone is careful, they cant make a mistake?
 
hime

hime

Exceptional
Pronouns
She/Her
Dr. Watson said:
Yeah but what I mean is what is the possibility of an intentional slip vs and unintentional one? And why do you think he's more likely to do the former?

We're going to start arguing in circles so for this to be a legitimate point of comparison then receipts need to be dug up from past games as proof he slips on accident

Else you're gonna be stuck in a he said she said scenario like right now - he can easily counter with "but I was just joking brah. Anyway here's wonder wall"

Like how do you prove something like this if it's, from that point of view, crucial to catching him as scum?
Click to expand...
what r u even talking about???

in what world would he "intentionally slip" here
i said that i think its possible he posted a msg meant to be in scum chat in the thread by accident
 
hime

hime

Exceptional
Pronouns
She/Her
this is a very weird focus for u @Dr. Watson
i have been independently scum reading BOTH ratchet and ekko for a while now and i see something that could be taken as a possible slip and i said to keep it in ur back pocket to remember if AFTER one of the flips scum
THEN it might have relevance

i have zero clue y ur essentially attributing my entire position on y i think they r both scum to this
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top