Game Ranked Dune Mafia - town victory

[.guillo]

What other useful roles are out there for scum to steal from

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Think, if OLU is scum, his claim is bullshit and he cleared Ultra because he knows he was town, he would claim not targeting anyone last night, so he avoids clearing more people, specially people in Ultra's PoE, becuase then he would have to kill his own clear, which again is in his PoE.

Scum need the PoEd town for mislynching, not for killing them at night

RDK or OLU have got to be scum and I'm leaning OLU too

 

[RDK]

Its possible but then it doesn't make sense for him to clear Ultra, I have a very hard time reading RDK tbdean

I would always use it to clear people

I try to build a house that isn't going to fall down as the game progresses when I'm scum

 

[.guillo]

Town Vanilla cop is useful, would help scum identify a town PR.

 

[.guillo]

Yes im saying vanilla cop is more useful for scum here

 

[RDK]

RDK preferred ichigo yesterday, he never voted aurelian

And?

 

[RDK]

RDK watching his scummate absolutely faceplant like

You've just argued that I'm an active scum chat participant and now you're trying to insinuate i wouldn't have control over this

 

[RDK]

Its either him or Gad as today's lynch.

I don't for one second believe someone cites Ultra's legacy and knows RDK wasn't scum read by him but chooses instead to die on a hill like this unless he wants to gamble.

I don't understand this point

 

[RDK]

hey look he has the exact same solve as RDK

No he doesn't, I have been firmly ready to lynch him and gad since the phase started because I think that is what the team is

The only thing giving me doubt is you decided to wait until ultra died to tunnel my slot which means you could easily be gad partners that needs an extra mislynch

 

[RDK]

Wait. Did you just claim my intended fake is the one role I managed to verify?

You could verify any of it, it doesn't make you town

 

[RDK]

Yes im saying vanilla cop is more useful for scum here

It could be useful for either, as could most roles

 

[Sharter Holmes]

I am suspicious because you spent most of the game scum reading me but w/e
Ignoring OLU and obviously how dumb a no lynch here is, I'd take either Gad or Siggy today

Nonevolution of reads at this stage.

Nah, this slot gotta go.

 

[Sharter Holmes]

You could verify any of it, it doesn't make you town

Yes. As a scum neighbor, my optimal play was to invite another scum from the chat we shared to a different chat we could share.

And Ichigo.

 

[RDK]

Yes. As a scum neighbor, my optimal play was to invite another scum from the chat we shared to a different chat we could share.

And Ichigo.

Your optimal play as a scum team would be to pocket the refiller so that they don't make useful decisions, yes

 

[Sharter Holmes]

Your optimal play as a scum team would be to pocket the refiller so that they don't make useful decisions, yes

No one knew he was refiller before he was added and this doesn't explain Ratchet so I feel like you're grasping for straws with this angle right up my ass

 

[RDK]

As scum I literally wouldn't use my neighborizer so I dont really care to theorize how anyone else would use it

The main reason I think you're scum is because having a 3 shot refiller and a 2 shot motivator both being town is an intentionally misleading setup

This is basic stuff and has been brought up before

 

[RDK]

It also gives town ridiculous power if used optimally

Have you asked how refiller and motivator would interact?

 

[Arne Slot]

You've just argued that I'm an active scum chat participant and now you're trying to insinuate i wouldn't have control over this

You were clearly gone lol

 

[Sharter Holmes]

As scum I literally wouldn't use my neighborizer so I dont really care to theorize how anyone else would use it

The main reason I think you're scum is because having a 3 shot refiller and a 2 shot motivator both being town is an intentionally misleading setup

This is basic stuff and has been brought up before

You know my motivator isn't exactly a refiller role right?

It just makes my targe reach his target, not accounting for other role shenanigans like BG.

Either way, it is what it is here.

 

[RDK]

You know my motivator isn't exactly a refiller role right?

It just makes my targe reach his target, not accounting for other role shenanigans like BG.

Either way, it is what it is here.

No lol I didn't