• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Unranked Bloodborne Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Ekkologix said:
also fair that its harsh to criticize and pin on certain players when alot of the player base arent making themselves easy to read but just cuz thats possible doesn't mean it's the case and u can easily thrive as scum here like magic mentioned day 1 being lazy isnt really an acceptable excuse
Click to expand...
Of course but blasting first asking questions later strikes me as very suboptimal when you put this into consideration. For example it's hard to lynch actually active players because the risk factor where I'm wrong on them is pretty great given the rampant inactivity, it's actually one of the main reservations I have with Magic's game because yesterday he seemed to be completely oblivious to this when it's something I expect him to have consideration for.

And again you agree with me on Rej at basically every point so I really don't see why his alignment is make or break for me. I think this discussion has probably ran its course now though.
 
Sky said:
It's like Magic says. Fewer kills on the table = more time for town to catch mafia
Click to expand...

And we have no guarantee BB shoots mafia at night. Worst case is 3 town are dead during the night since we have vig, SK and Mafia.

I am almost sure Rej is Mafia here though. He seems to give up today.
 
Also has to be said that Bachi's activity/play has taken a bit of a nosedive in terms of activity - he's taken the town reads and proceeded to do pretty much nothing. Again I ask for someone to explain what's so townie about this?
 
Ratchet said:
I'm not quite sure if you're following. My interaction with Ultra was specifically around her claim in relation to his... that was the crux of the contention I was making, you know, the part you're using to say I was TMI'ing her?

It's not weird at all - in Ultra's game she claimed something risky but benign in the sense that there is no danger of the real vig shooting her st night. That's kind of why Vig doesn't get fake claimed very often - it's way too risky. I did actually acknowledge that it could well be the case too, just that I didn't agree that the roles couldn't coexist at all. I even framed this as such to Ultra - I specifically told him the case (in this context, the case here is referring strictly to his claim and hers( wasn't compelling for me because of that.

To say nothing of course of burning a slot to get the Vig out in the open and not, say, the Cop.

So yeah none of this really stands. Next!
Click to expand...

Yes, I also think that if you were in team with Balsamic you would distance yourself. If you were scum and she were trully SK i also do not see your benefit in defending her. So not feeling Magic's case on you here.
 
Ratchet said:
Also has to be said that Bachi's activity/play has taken a bit of a nosedive in terms of activity - he's taken the town reads and proceeded to do pretty much nothing. Again I ask for someone to explain what's so townie about this?
Click to expand...

Magic said Bachi is definately town.

@Magic if it is mechanical do not confirm.
 
Ekkologix said:
im not going to flip bachi before u baring info as i already have him as non mafia. all i need is to see rej's flip to proceed, if he flips town ur going to be top of my PoE. and sure u can claim etc... u already said u wont be lynched today so better be able to back that up, which is still not going to be 100% clearing with a janitor in play

i think rej is scum but doesnt hurt to solve beyond the flip in case it's wrong
Click to expand...
Lets flip Rej, he looks a bit performative in the last day phase, we trust sk that he wont shoot this night phase
 
Ratchet said:
Also has to be said that Bachi's activity/play has taken a bit of a nosedive in terms of activity - he's taken the town reads and proceeded to do pretty much nothing. Again I ask for someone to explain what's so townie about this?
Click to expand...
Lynch Rej this day phase, sk wont shoot, trust her fr
 
Bachi said:
Lets flip Rej, he looks a bit performative in the last day phase, we trust sk that he wont shoot this night phase
Click to expand...
Can we exclude the possibility of BB saying she is vig as scum? I think she is capable of this.

Also you are quick to believe SK is such a large game has limited shots?
 
Lord Melkor said:
Can we exclude the possibility of BB saying she is vig as scum? I think she is capable of this.

Also you are quick to believe SK is such a large game has limited shots?
Click to expand...
I need to believe something, if I go with the premise that nothing can be trusted, then I should go to sleep and have 0 opinions
 
That having been said, I believe that mafia did 1 kill at night and Balsamic?-most likely sk the second kill
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top