• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Darkest Dungeon Mafia - Game Thread Day 6

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
my conclusion is also alco can be scum not putting his mouth where his money is

flower can be town, no reason to reveal the hater otherwise tho idk how she knew about it. se knows pocketing me is specifically denied from her as id still shoot her if i had a kill
 
Kurumi said:
What does Flower mean by saying that Ekko and Craig are "hated"? Is this some ingame status or something like that?
Click to expand...
Hated is a passive where the user requires one fewer vote than Majority to be lynched. For example, today Majority is at 10 votes - Ekko will be lynched at 9.
 
if flower is the one doing it then using it to capture scum is moot if shes town as scum doesnt know im hated
 
Flower said:
Yeah, I had a 1-shot double hated modifier. So at least means I was not blocked. Scums are scaredy cats lol.
Click to expand...

Because you suspect both of them? Do you really think it was wise to use it right away?
You know that mafia could use this to their advantage. If you hadn´t admitted being responsible for this I´d have assumed that mafia used it on them as Ekko and Craig seems to be players that could easily be mislynched.
 
Dalton said:
You're still not understanding what I'm saying. It wasnt you going after CP that changed my view of you. It was when you went after Psychic too.

My main presumption regarding you being scummy was that your interactions with CP sounded like distancing.
This meant that my scumread on you was predicated on you being teamed with CP (who I also scumread, partially for his interactions with you but also because he seemed more serious than I expect his town game to be so early in the game).

Then you started going hard after Psychic too, and I agreed with you on Psychic being scummy.

It was at this point that I felt the need to reevaluate my earlier stance. Given I thought Psychic was going to flip scum, then if you and CP were to be co-scum, it would mean you had hard-bussed 2 of your teammates in short order.

Since this was unlikely, I reevaluated my stance on you. Given the context of my scumread on Psychic, it made it likely that I had simply misread your and CP's interaction as a bus.



Over and above all of the above, I was feeling like your play was feeling more and more townie, hence me adding that even if Psychic flipped town, I was still now leaning towards you being town on play.
Click to expand...

@Ratchet I've noticed you've put Dalton in your scum pile, can you tell me what you make of this post?

I think what's bothering me here (and yesterday) is that Dalton's tie-in feels completely dependent on CP being scum, but he doesn't go for CP at all.

There's a hole here as well - he doesn't have to assume I'm town off of his assumption that I wouldn't bus 2 mates. He can still conclude CP is the odd townie out after Psychic's flip. This isn't taken into consideration at all.
 
Kurumi said:
Because you suspect both of them? Do you really think it was wise to use it right away?
You know that mafia could use this to their advantage. If you hadn´t admitted being responsible for this I´d have assumed that mafia used it on them as Ekko and Craig seems to be players that could easily be mislynched.
Click to expand...
I don‘t expect to live long, so I was just blowing my load first Night.
 
Ratchet said:
What's weird about it? I haven't disregarded all of your points, I disagree with the conclusion from them. Actually, this is pointless because you're just going tunnel anyway - do your thing I suppose.
Click to expand...
Thanks for treating me in bad faith. I have an issue with Ekko's slot right now, but you're telling me to leave it alone. Ekko hasn't read the game (which you called him out for) and is going after Rugrat (weakly), which is a direction you're apparently fine with. I don't really think it's out of pocket to raise some concerns about how you are playing all of this. The fact you instantly want to shut me down, call me town, and potentially ignore me, doesn't feel great.
 
Ekkologix said:
ur missing the part where those came reactionary to something you did, not off me actively doing it as ur making it sound like but ye
Click to expand...
You called me out for how I handled Psychic's slot.

You then retracted that call out 'based on Psychic's flip'.

You continue to shade me for my effort and alleged over sell.

You have ended up with calling me the serial killer.

This does not feel reactionary. This feels intentional.
 
Ratchet said:
How do you work this magic in your head to get here? No, seriously. You told me I was shutting down Craig and Ekko, and that Vinegar has claimed, so you wanted me to tell you where I'm leading. I told you exactly where, and between this you've somehow forgotten that you were the one asking me for my direction, and are now arguing that I'm trying to overwrite yours without prompt. Absolute nonsense.
Click to expand...
Well I assumed you'd actually have reasons for you susses. Ha. I picked the three names that I was interested in and your reasons for having them on your list was less than adequate.
 
Hans Tweetenberg said:
From rereading Psychics posts, I'm gonna say that Ultra, Kurumi, Ratchet and perhaps Ekko aren't her teammates. She also had a buncha interactions with BPD but those came late-ish and could be bussing, feels to me like she was overselling that whole thing too. Her interactions with Fuji have been positively chummy compared to everything else she's done, not sure if it means anything but it's definitely not enough to offset my town read on the guy.
Click to expand...
Im just that charming of a guy.
 
Ultra said:
@Ratchet I've noticed you've put Dalton in your scum pile, can you tell me what you make of this post?

I think what's bothering me here (and yesterday) is that Dalton's tie-in feels completely dependent on CP being scum, but he doesn't go for CP at all.

There's a hole here as well - he doesn't have to assume I'm town off of his assumption that I wouldn't bus 2 mates. He can still conclude CP is the odd townie out after Psychic's flip. This isn't taken into consideration at all.
Click to expand...
Independently I haven't had any major issue with Dalton's posts, he's there because I haven't seen anything that makes me think he must be town too. I see your point, but the "hole" can be reconciled by him simply having a scum read of CP entirely independent of any association with you (like he said). So yeah I don't really have a problem with the post - if I have a problem with anything it's trying to read into players distancing before grounding his scum reads on either.
 
Black Pegged Dragon said:
Well I assumed you'd actually have reasons for you susses. Ha. I picked the three names that I was interested in and your reasons for having them on your list was less than adequate.
Click to expand...
And by interested in I mean I wanted to see why you thought they were wolves when I haven't been seeing it so far.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top