• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Darkest Dungeon Mafia - Game Thread Day 6

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
The X said:
May I ask where the motivation to reassess Ekko's slot came from? You had him town most of the game and shut me down lots from going after that slot. I agree with everything you're saying now, just curious why the change of heart.
Click to expand...
Honestly his role hunting yesterday that I pointed out, his claim of 2-shot healer that debuffs its target actually feels unreasonably harmful to the town but not a slam dunk, and his arguments towards me today feel like he's making them to invent an angle rather than something he's genuinely curious about.

I also don't think it's a bad thing to re-evaluate reasons for town reading a player - did it just last game with Dalton at around the same point. With my PoE having shrunk to almost 1:1 I think it needs to be recontexualised.
 
Ultra said:
But this implies he would think it less scummy to claim healer standalone against an established claim. Frankly he could be dictating his role mostly as-is.
Click to expand...
Right, but my point is that if he is a role copier, his role wouldn't mention anything about being a healer, which is the main reason to suspect him from a role spec standpoint.
 
one last time - i said i had no more usages, to help sell the fact that the Brazier would have gone through just to gauge reactions.

so i still have x1 usage.
 
Lethal emerging when i name dropped him and Dalton - makes me wary, seems like lurking

VOTE: Dalton

slot is to risky
 
Ratchet said:
Right, but my point is that if he is a role copier, his role wouldn't mention anything about being a healer, which is the main reason to suspect him from a role spec standpoint.
Click to expand...

I'm not proposing he's strictly a role copier and cobbled this together. Frankly, and this is especially true in these thematically laced games and with players who aren't too out of pocket like Alco - my betting odds are that what he claimed is 80-90% true to his role regardless.
 
Ultra said:
I'm half tempted to just take out Dalton via lynch and then have hime shoot someone else in immediate PoE - this is fucking aids
Click to expand...
No, if you consider your rolespec you basically have a dichotomy between Alco and Ekko here - let Gram resolve Dalton, if we're wrong hime can shore up the other. If neither are scum then the rolespec argument can be dismissed and we are left with exactly Vinegar to resolve unless there is a major misclear somewhere.
 
Ratchet said:
I think it's pretty simple - I had no idea I would survive tonight, or if you got blocked again etc, so I opted to abstain and now next night scum are forced to contend with dealing with a watcher.

You can spare me the finger pointing - I would probably always have watched Ultra last night anyway so I wouldn't have found the killer.
Click to expand...
hence i cant find the motive because u can also just say u watched ultra and saw none visit him as scum

its whatever
 
Ratchet said:
No, if you consider your rolespec you basically have a dichotomy between Alco and Ekko here - let Gram resolve Dalton, if we're wrong hime can shore up the other. If neither are scum then the rolespec argument can be dismissed and we are left with exactly Vinegar to resolve unless there is a major misclear somewhere.
Click to expand...
lethal shud be serial dont forget him
 
Ultra said:
I'm not proposing he's strictly a role copier and cobbled this together. Frankly, and this is especially true in these thematically laced games and with players who aren't too out of pocket like Alco - my betting odds are that what he claimed is 80-90% true to his role regardless.
Click to expand...
Yeah that's the point though- if he copies abilities like a counter to Tweet for example, then scum aren't getting the healer claim from anywhere. Fof him to be scum he would have to be a healer by and large, and claimed to copy the role of a player in the PoE, essentially serving as a clear for them, to evidence his actual role. It doesn't really make a lot of sense to me.
 
Ratchet said:
No, if you consider your rolespec you basically have a dichotomy between Alco and Ekko here - let Gram resolve Dalton, if we're wrong hime can shore up the other. If neither are scum then the rolespec argument can be dismissed and we are left with exactly Vinegar to resolve unless there is a major misclear somewhere.
Click to expand...

He isn't, that's kinda the issue
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top