• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Dune Mafia - town victory

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Ultra said:
Gad I need you to make sure you didn't make this shit up

I was reading Ratchet as scum for 95% of the game, there's no reason I could possibly have to shit on you for scum reading him

Me and Poyser were shitting on you for NEIGHBORING him, is that what you're talking about about? That was before you admitted your full claim.
Click to expand...
Let me make this clear cause I think I know what you're getting at. You're asking for proof that you dissuaded me directly from going for Ratchet. You didn't. Just said that the reason I was scum reading him was wrong. I got off his back. Invited him to chat and tried to see what he'd do. Yes, I townread him at this point, I'll admit. Then you basically asked me to go for Ratchet and I didn't jump through hoops to just go back to scum reading him

How it looked to me. I thought Ratchet was scummy. Y'all said I was wrong, sometimes not even to me, just asking Ratchet what my angle could be going after him for something that made no sense to y'all. Got no support, basically told myself I was wrong and tried approaching it as Ratchet=town. You know the rest.
 
Sharter Holmes said:
Let me make this clear cause I think I know what you're getting at. You're asking for proof that you dissuaded me directly from going for Ratchet. You didn't. Just said that the reason I was scum reading him was wrong. I got off his back. Invited him to chat and tried to see what he'd do. Yes, I townread him at this point, I'll admit. Then you basically asked me to go for Ratchet and I didn't jump through hoops to just go back to scum reading him

How it looked to me. I thought Ratchet was scummy. Y'all said I was wrong, sometimes not even to me, just asking Ratchet what my angle could be going after him for something that made no sense to y'all. Got no support, basically told myself I was wrong and tried approaching it as Ratchet=town. You know the rest.
Click to expand...

I'm not even sure I told you that you were wrong for scum reading him though? Dunno about Poyser etc.

Like the narrative your painting here just seems entirely wrong to me. That's why I'm asking you to provide receipts.
 
Ultra said:
My solve is still

1 in Gad/Ichigo
1 in VT claims (Fang, CP, Guillo)

The trouble is that there's a fair degree of overlap here with Ratchet's solve lmao but obviously that's gonna happen to some degree when you're boxed in
Click to expand...

One of them is Sig.

Think about it.

Flower = Redirector
Ratchet = Bus Driver

which one is likely to complete the counter from town, hider or protection JOAT?
 
Ultra said:
I just don't know where to start here You pointed out yourself I have over 1k posts. If you're barely reading the thread, why did you conclude you like Ratchet but not me Why did Watson's flip and who caught her not factor into your solving Your perspective literally makes no sense to me, try and make it make sense if you're town
Click to expand...
I'll try later in the day For now I don't want to clear Aurelian because he was pushed by Ratchet and was the counter wagon yesterday. I opened Ratchet's ISO and there's this post
Ratchet said:
Well that's what I'm saying to you, like that's the issue I had mainly. I agree, it is fake, there's no way she is asking because she doesn't know who to target. But you presented it as something that's scummy for her which it's not. Actually think it's more likely to come from her as town, because she's a selfish player who is not thinking about how to solve, but how to claim her role. Anyway, Unvote Your thoughts make more sense if you're trying to hold her to a standard rather than actually suspecting her for it. Will step back for a bit to see where you go next. Vote: @Aurelian Let's go, time to start playing
Click to expand...
Why is there a ping inside the vote? Is that usual for Ratchet?



I am sure now you are town, Guillo still town (Ratchet pocketing him from my PoV), and I can consider OLU and RDK in town as well.
 
Kurosaki Ichigo said:
I am not reading the game. I probably read 10% of it and I thought he is solving. And I let myself pocketed.
Click to expand...
Okay but you refused to refill the vig (Poyser) and you didn't refill the cop (RDK). So how exactly is the angle your playing supposed to be trustworthy?
 
Ultra said:
I'm not even sure I told you that you were wrong for scum reading him though? Dunno about Poyser etc.

Like the narrative your painting here just seems entirely wrong to me. That's why I'm asking you to provide receipts.
Click to expand...
Why aren't you looking too foo, you do this faster than I do and I hate doing this shit on a phone 😭
 
FWIW a Poyser kill is something I would expect Gad to do given how many times he's gotten buried by him in town. Anyway I'm pretty resigned knowing I'm gonna get lynched today anyways.
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top