• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Dune Mafia - town victory

Status
Not open for further replies.
Why would scum!Ratchet defend scum!Watson only for Watson to Hammer the way she did?

Like ok.

I could believe Ratchet having TMI on watson being town.
I could believe Ratchet being town genuinely allowing scum!Watson the opportunity to self resolve.

But where does hard defending her as both members of scum fit with that EoD play?
1) watson is dead anyways. its killing flower before a possible re-evaluation which mightve happend (e.g. poyser was pushing for watson at that eod). slots dead anyways, take someone out with them

its obviously a fine look for ratchet given it isnt a good idea in general and ratchet is a good player, ubt its not like its lock clearing or even clearing at all tbh lol
 
To be fair Melkor does like to give vote manipulation to scum in some form based on a skim of his set ups

Doesn't mean Ratchet is scum but he loves to give good kits...if they have a vote stealer that might actually be worse :dead:
 
Like if alco is a dead slot as scum his whole team could just bus him right, especially with Poyser pushing that direction
depends on the role right
like, 1x janitor 1x strongarm gf (a role i had on the last scum rand this forum) you just dont bus in that situation lol - no great chances
 
She knew it as a fact because you couldn’t possibly have her as scum when she was scum so you were obviously scum
She was not scum.

She was pretty much a town with a different win con than town's and scum's. She was as uninformed as town.
 
Janitor was already used so why not
still have a strongarm and theirs a chance they just fiend a cop check due to being utr
i see the line of logic here, "why wouldnt wolves try to take the opportunity to just bus and gain town credit", but im not sure its a reasonable assumption to connect towards them being town. also why, if theyre town, wolves dont just push them and direct to a free town kill - poyser has then pushed two town in a row and it lowers their thread position further. you can use similar lines of logic both ways lol
 
still have a strongarm and theirs a chance they just fiend a cop check due to being utr
i see the line of logic here, "why wouldnt wolves try to take the opportunity to just bus and gain town credit", but im not sure its a reasonable assumption to connect towards them being town. also why, if theyre town, wolves dont just push them and direct to a free town kill - poyser has then pushed two town in a row and it lowers their thread position further. you can use similar lines of logic both ways lol
Where's this strongman spec coming from
 
it kinda baffles me how flowers accusation on ultra was "he cant be wrong on me!!" and it turns out she was infact wolves. but she was still confident on ultra even after she flipped???

this is unrelated to the game, just something i find baffling lol
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top