• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Dune Mafia - town victory

Status
Not open for further replies.
I am looking after small things because these are showing a lot sometimes

1. Sigi has a word salady claim, not good IMO. Deflated at SOD today.

2. Ratchet voted Aurelian firstly with the ping and calling him to play - you can say it's nothing but exactly because it's too obvious and showy it can be theatre.
Aurelian was Ratchet's counter wagon yesterday but the wagon is too small. Usually a town cw is bigger and in danger to go first.

I think both Sigi and Aurelian are scum.
So Ratchet who was pushing my lynch all game makes me aligned with him? And how do you even factor Sig into this? He claimed JOAT - Jack of all Trades - which isn't common but not rare in these set-ups. You seem to be grasping at straws and constructing a narrative that you've married the idea that Ratchet was pushing me all game because we're aligned ergo distancing even though there was several points I was even at L-1.

You meanwhile didn't reload the vig or cop, pushed first a theory that the Hider claim was bogus and Ultra claiming to mech cleared was wrong because theoretically you were assuming the possibility that OLU can be scum.

So I really don't get this since both indies/SK/arsonists/duo is dead.
Watson was blatantly contradicted by Sig, by claim of night actions.
Watson claimed to be Watcher.
Watson flipped mafia gravedigger.
Ratchet lied and pushback against the advice of Gad neighboring RDK, the cop.

Ratchet bussing Watson when she was screwed since day 2 wouldn't be improbable given how bad her positioning was and relatively ghosting but how do you get equity from this with me to them?
 
Could be guillo too mind you, I don't think with ichigo though, a bit too on the nose.

I'm Perturbed by his play a lot and concerned ratchet may have told him to lean into it
 
Does melkor have history of vanilla cop role? If so is there any sort of investigation protection i should be worried about?
 
I  think Ratchet may have been the godfather based on flavor which would mean i dont have to worry about it but ye
 
Could be guillo too mind you, I don't think with ichigo though, a bit too on the nose.

I'm Perturbed by his play a lot and concerned ratchet may have told him to lean into it

Guillo makes way more sense as a gopher from a risk management standpoint. I don't think Ratchet would encourage his whole team to lynch me Day 2. Guillo had a town game here when I was SK and he basically got hoodwinked by scum Ratchet in a very similar fashion.

Pretty much all of his directions and input seem frankly terrible I agree. He's leaned into some really lame shit if he's scum too so would piss me off. Sorta wish I had something for comparison here
 
Does melkor have history of vanilla cop role? If so is there any sort of investigation protection i should be worried about?

I would expect they have a framer/lawyer or something if they don't have godfather. I don't think they need to, strictly speaking, but Melkor likes to cover his bases
 
What stands out most is that we haven't had a tracker claim. If Watson cross claimed I don't think Melkor would put in a rolewatcher without a tracker, but could be wrong.

If Lethal was Watcher I think Ratchet may have advised the rolecop/roletracker to not bother claiming the tracker aspect to not get rolespecced.
 
Can everyone give me their top 2 suspects right now
Ichigo and probably Gad

Having a JOAT and a neighbor/motivator/rolecrusher doesn't seem very balanced plus everything I said about Gad, honorary mention I guess Guillo
 
Could be guillo too mind you, I don't think with ichigo though, a bit too on the nose.

I'm Perturbed by his play a lot and concerned ratchet may have told him to lean into it
Then again I can't imagine he had much to do with Watson behavior so there might just not be an avenue of communication
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top