The X
Resplendent
Is she not making any sense or is her logic poor? I realize that that might be a fine line to judge on, but I can at least SEE that point she's trying to make, even if the execution leaves more to be desired.
- It's that time of the year again! Just kidding, we were late.
Click here to see the awards and nominate people for the rest of the categories.
- We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!
- Status
Which ideas are she pushing though? She’s just asking me and ratchet what we think of each other with no payoff or purpose?
TAT
Preeminent
and you realise if someone self metas then that meta is inadmissible as they've shown they're aware of it and therefore can replicate it?
The X
Resplendent
But that's the point, I don't really think she'd do that as scum. She'd drop anything she was trying to ask/push on you and Ratchet is she was scum and felt that there was going to be pressure or attacks on her. I agree that the optics look bad here on her, but I'm not sure if her motivations look bad. By no means am I giving her a solid town read here, and I agree that her play has been poor so far, but it's her poor play that leans her town for me, as contradictory as that might sound.
TAT
Preeminent
Interesting, what do you think a scum Flower does to be 'desperate to be seen as town'?
I mean, I pressured you a bit in my own way and came to a conclusion for now, didn‘t I?
Neither Ratchet nor you have a problem with each other‘s play so far, Ratchet reads you stronger Town than me, but leans us both Town. I think that‘s good info to work with for now.
The X
Resplendent
One example is she'd probably come up with something better than a vanilla claim. I don't really have a list of examples because that's not really how I play the game. But I've seen scum Flower enough to know that if she did roll scum here, I think she's covering it up a bit better in D1 than usual despite her weak thread play so far.
TAT
Preeminent
Okay what are you doing? What do you think good town play is?
TAT
Preeminent
Okay, fair enough, will take your word for it
Dawwwwwww thank you baby
Think Kobe from that last game.
Explain?
I don't think that was crumbling under pressure?
I mean, there was no pressure on her at that point...
I think BPD‘s defense of me rn looks good on him because 1) we were just a team in Weebs, so him feeling like this makes sense from the pov of somebody who just saw me have a fairly decent scum game and 2) I‘m still an easy lynch, so a defense and going against the grain like this is counter productive for scum. Admittedly I have done nothing so strong so far that a defense is easy and him saying that makes me think he‘s Town who really believes what he says rather than scum trying to look good.
TAT
Preeminent
Dawwwwwww thank you baby
Think Kobe from that last game.
Explain?
I don't think that was crumbling under pressure?
I mean, there was no pressure on her at that point...
He had an agenda very early to sus Soul Killer, someone who I thought was playing the game well, Mafia is all about agendas, motives and I thought there was no reason to have that type of sus early on
this is my first post on it -
Game - Ranked - Fallout New Vegas Mafia
You hope you are townie? you either townie or not X. There is no such thing as 'I hope I am townie.' I haven't opened my PM.
onelastforum.com I thought he was misconstruing SK on purpose, I also remember him asking a question about whether he's caught scum before from the amount of time it took to post, I don't think I got an answer
Because I can get behind asking and answering questions about other players and how it pertains to their alignment, what I cba with is the constant bickering that ultimately leads nowhere
TAT
Preeminent
Yeah admittedly that could be it, not like that hasn't happened before
- Status