• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hades Mafia - Game Thread

Reader mode
Ultra said:
how do you expect RDK to be dealt with we don't lynch him today
Click to expand...
I'm coming around to agreeing with voting him out today, but it would really depend on a few factors. Pretty much no one else has given input on what they think he is, hostile or no. If we lynch Mafia today it would give us some more wiggle room, but obviously at the threat of him detonating. I did go over all this in my earlier post, Ultra...
 

RDK will always always always just side with scum if we miss a vote so keeping him around relies on us playing perfectly.

Not interested. We're not swinging for the fence today

If we miss and he's indi Nibel should be confirm and we have to bat 3/3, probably, depending on action usage, but I like those odds with our current PoE
 
Yes but if I detonated I would out myself for what? To just get lynched tomorrow?

I've already told you there's no way I could have primed more than one person. Unless you think I was arsonist from the start as well as a hunter that killed Doffla?
 
Don't do it Ultra. Keep me around because I'm an all round nice guy
 
The Orca said:
Which means RDK is indy...or Xadlin was and can be invested as town that Poyser did on N1
Click to expand...

No, it doesn't confirm him indi. He can be scum posing as indi, and if the indi is hostile they're not going to CC to blow their cover.

Or he could just be indi.

In either case, getting him outta here is probably the right play
 
That's just not the right play imo
 
I also think from an overall game standpoint - him claiming survivor as the prize for town correctly killing Hime as survivor is kinda weird. He's suggesting he's her "replacement", but her role was resolved
 
Ultra said:
I also think from an overall game standpoint - him claiming survivor as the prize for town correctly killing Hime as survivor is kinda weird. He's suggesting he's her "replacement", but her role was resolved
Click to expand...
Incorrect. Me and Hime could only both win if I visited her correctly.

Otherwise I'd keep searching until being killed or she would just survive and win without me.
 
Ultra said:
No, it doesn't confirm him indi. He can be scum posing as indi, and if the indi is hostile they're not going to CC to blow their cover.

Or he could just be indi.

In either case, getting him outta here is probably the right play
Click to expand...
Why not
 
Ultra said:
I also think from an overall game standpoint - him claiming survivor as the prize for town correctly killing Hime as survivor is kinda weird. He's suggesting he's her "replacement", but her role was resolved
Click to expand...
I don't agree that the hime kill was a correct one though. I agree that he's probably full of shit though - the flavour lines up too well plus his play.
 
It also wasn't a prize lmao. I didn't kill hime, Nibel did.

I got punished for that by losing the easier of the two win conditions, as evidenced now.
 
Ultra said:
Well, from my standpoint

From the standpoint of relying on others to put a peg in the correct hole, that's always going to be an issue
Click to expand...
Well I've seen you be plenty frustrated this game at what is left to work with, I can promise you it's not going to get easier. I suppose that's tomorrow's problem though.

Vote: RDK
 
RDK said:
It also wasn't a prize lmao. I didn't kill hime, Nibel did.

I got punished for that by losing the easier of the two win conditions, as evidenced now.
Click to expand...

You're framing it as a punishment for yourself, I'm talking about from a town standpoint, it doesn't jive with me that a branching route for you would inclue being a duplicate of a role that's already resolved. Backup Survivor? Really? Boring, but also kind of redundant.

It makes more sense, actually, if Hime had managed to convert and you replaced her. Not after killing her
 
Reader mode
You must log in or register to reply here.
Menu
Log in
Register