• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked Hero Killer Mafia

Status
This thread has been locked by the thread creator and is currently not open for replies.
but if u believe that they’re both town (and idk if u do, which is why im asking) then one role is obviously more important to save than the other
 
Redoing my Atsumori analysis given the point that I confused their posts with Boquise's before by missing the reaction part

____________

GODDAMN IT WHY DOES THE QUOTE FEATURE QUOTE THE WHOLE TEXT INSTEAD OF THE HIGHLIGHTED PART? OMG THE BUGS HERE

"Provide, please. It's pretty normal here to fluff post during the first pages. I don't know how Miraka is playing usually, but nothing seems really scummy from them right now. I would focus more on people who would take advantage of it."

This being Brad and Lethal mostly. It's natural for me to want to TR this given they defended me, but I think from an unbiased POV it would still be a more townie thing to say.

"Yeah that's it, I told you in scum chat tovdefend yourself and I'm here to defend you."

I don't love this from Atsumori about the random Grammaton vote by Lethal, but I'm less inclined to scumread it because it was in response to what Gram said

"Yeah I didn't understand the point here. How is this even supposed to be sus to ask how people here are naming roles? Boquise's vote looks suspect."

In response to the vote on Stick. I think this line of questioning is more likely to come from town than wolf, especially when the initial FoS was based on a misunderstanding

"@Fujishiro Carry this game right now or you're scum"

And carry Fuji did, although we could have squeezed more spew or anti-spew out of Brad by leaving it until later

"Oh okay, do you know the guy well? If yes, what are their playstyle as a wolf?" - about Boquise sussing Stick I think? A fair question, if Stick were to flip wolf later it could be seen as deflection by Atsumori, but I don't currently sus Stick

"You still didn't explain why" - about Aurelian just saying they were sus of Nibel (Atsumori) and me. The argument is fair (and I believe I made a similar point at some stage as well). Would Atsumori be more emotional when replying to this though as town? I don't know the answer to this, just looking for some meta to work with from people who played with Atsumori a lot more.

"Huh. I've seen better things coming out from you, but okay." - about Aurelian. Starting to townread Atsumori more because they're having somewhat similar thoughts to me, in a way that seems not the easiest to fake as wolf
"@Boquise where did you go?
Come back V L Boq"

feels a bit random

"I don't think Aurelian is scum. I would expect him to pressure me more if he was scum. He still could be indie if he remains too silent."

Disagree, I consider Aurelian the most likely to be the 2nd mafia (given Brad basically outed as the 1st mafia). I mean it's fairly clear to me that Aurelian is not really helping town today and trying to steer in the wrong direction. Plus their defences to my pressure have been just aggressive in a way that feels unnatural.

"I only remember Alexis as when he is town, and right now, I don't think he looks super scummy" - agreed

Overall, Atsumori is a town lean for me
 
but if u believe that they’re both town (and idk if u do, which is why im asking) then one role is obviously more important to save than the other
Stick should you not have that answer from the context of my recent posts already?


Alright, I will repeat it. I am not a renowned brad reader and I did not state a brad read. I stated that I townread fuji for inititating it

So through this my position as I described to you is as follows: I townread fuji, i dont townread brad
 
I legit forgot Atsumori was in the game

Also might be moving you back to null soon, starting to think Brad's a better lynch here
For someone who is very explainy in their posts about how they think, there is a definite lack of demonstrated thinking around the stick read
 
Kinda hurts my read on you that you've hardly interacted with Stick's posts or talked about them that much during this one time. It is easy to fossilize a read based on one off post for both alignments, but imo town are more excited in pummelling the wolf instead of coasting on the read tbh. What do you think of Stick's approach towards me?

This was so long ago that I'm already forgetting the details

But basically Brad was getting progressively more scummy to me over time

While Stick was getting less scummy and I moved them to a null read fairly quickly.

Yes I make early reads based on opening posts but I'm very open to changing my initial perspective in the event of others bringing up strong counterpoints or if others start to become a lot more scummy (as happened with Brad)
 
This was so long ago that I'm already forgetting the details

But basically Brad was getting progressively more scummy to me over time

While Stick was getting less scummy and I moved them to a null read fairly quickly.

Yes I make early reads based on opening posts but I'm very open to changing my initial perspective in the event of others bringing up strong counterpoints or if others start to become a lot more scummy (as happened with Brad)
What makes you feel better about stick here
 
@Miraka sooooo here's the thing.
I backed off of you entirely since you began to play turbos on MU and you got voted out EVERY SINGLE GAME so was showing a bit of mercy there.
Plus I gave that scumread on you and you turned into a whiny bitch after so I pulled back more.

But yeah you decided to return the favor I've given you by trying to OMGUS me by trying to use the "what are you going as for Easter" post.
I would like to think you're not this stupid to not realize that post was a joke acting like Easter was Halloween.

But yeah you decided to out yourself more it seems so...

Vote: Miraka

See ya later, left field, get fucked.
Okay this might be town brad
 
I dont think this analysis is airtight, and my inner cynic feels theres a decent chance that this could be a form of reflected commentary as to what youre doing here, this is to say, youre playing peacemaker and we the audience should interpret that as benign on your behalf

Just a theory
Instantly liking Grammaton
 
I'm actually polarized as fuck, especially since I'm on a newer site. As town I'm obvious as fuck town and as mafia I really don't give a shit and barely show up to the game.

In terms of getting mislynched, funny thing is from like 2021 to 2023 I rarely got mislynched as town.
However a lot of the current reoccurring players on MU now aren't that good so I end up mislynched more than usual.

Also the main thing Stick has said is true regarding partners, since I don't like bussing teammates.
Your scum reads as a wolf are also generally stiff and read as manufactured whereas your scum reads as town are either fueled by confidence or tilt tbh
 
Status
This thread has been locked by the thread creator and is currently not open for replies.
Back
Top