• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Mafia General Discussion: Ultra's Crucifixion

Status
Not open for further replies.
Goth Boy said:
Lmao

Trying to tell adults to act like adults is weird now
Click to expand...

It's weird you feel the need to insert yourself and be weirdly passive aggressive over people discussing mafia in the mafia general

You've used this thread almost exclusively for shitposting, what are you getting your nuts twisted about exactly
 
Ultra said:
Resubbing Dead players is a failure of resource management in a game environment where we're tracking ranked statistics and stuff should be avoided when possible. Just means you should run smaller games to begin with if you're having to resort to that. You also don't wanna become like WG where it starts becoming a meta level expectation and someone like Flower dies and is just like "whatever I'll sub back in anyway". It's obnoxious as fuck.
Click to expand...
Think this is right. Subbing back dead players is something I considered this game but it would be problematic ranking wise. What do you do when a player is town, dies, but then subs in as scum? Imagine scum win in this situation, do you give them points for winning as scum or none because they lost as town? Also annoying with awards in the mix too. What if both your town and scum play were the best of the best (hypothetically). It would just confuse stuff
 
hime said:
Think this is right. Subbing back dead players is something I considered this game but it would be problematic ranking wise. What do you do when a player is town, dies, but then subs in as scum? Imagine scum win in this situation, do you give them points for winning as scum or none because they lost as town? Also annoying with awards in the mix too. What if both your town and scum play were the best of the best (hypothetically). It would just confuse stuff
Click to expand...

Speaking of awards...
 
Ultra said:
It's weird you feel the need to insert yourself and be weirdly passive aggressive over people discussing shit

You've used this thread almost exclusively for shitposting, what are you getting your nuts twisted about exactly
Click to expand...
I just don't think stuff like this drama should be public

Especially if people can go too far when angry

Like imagine if people started calling each others mothers whores because things were allowed to escalate
 
Goth Boy said:
I just don't think stuff like this drama should be public

Especially if people can go too far when angry

Like imagine if people started calling each others mothers whores because things were allowed to escalate
Click to expand...

You're right. One time I lost a mafia game and I showed up to Ral's doorstep with a set of handcuffs and a list of demands.
 
hime said:
Didn't expect to see you back here, Flower

Also I see, heard about that game from her since she said she was upset about being shot Day 1, but didn't know she resorted to rule-breaking right after. Probably wouldn't have let her play if I knew that.

By the looks of it, it happened only 1 week ago too... ._.
Click to expand...
Fuji told me there was drama 🍿. I think I wanna play the next game. Now that I‘m keeping my job things might finally calm down in my life again. Been a rough year all around :life.
 
giphy.webp
 
  • Lizard kek
Reactions: Rej
hime said:
Think this is right. Subbing back dead players is something I considered this game but it would be problematic ranking wise. What do you do when a player is town, dies, but then subs in as scum? Imagine scum win in this situation, do you give them points for winning as scum or none because they lost as town? Also annoying with awards in the mix too. What if both your town and scum play were the best of the best (hypothetically). It would just confuse stuff
Click to expand...
They get win/loss credit for their most recent alignment. That's how it's always worked. It's not like this is a new concept lol
 
hime said:
What I want is for people who were not at all involved nor know the full extent of the situation to stop acting all holier than thou. It's annoying especially coming from my friend who basically avoided my game like the plague.

You've said worse things to people before for less yet it's somehow morally wrong for me and my partner to call someone who purposefully tried to ruin my game (not only for me as the host but for other players who put in their time and energy into it) a bitch?

If you have issues with inactivity in the section or whatever that's fine, just don't want someone criticizing word usage when I'm a pretty inexperienced host who just had my game intentionally ruined
Click to expand...
Because it's a tired subject, she got banned immedietely and has left the forum as far as I can tell. I've also condemned what she did, it sucked, why can't I agree that inactivity is making these games fairly unplayable for large periods?

I didn't avoid your game like the plague at all. I told you that you could rep me in if you wanted and it was up to you but I wouldn't be active because I was going to be busy all weekend. You did the right thing by not repping me in but don't act like I snubbed you or something.

Also I wasn't on the rep list so not really sure why you're having a go at me for this. Take it up with the people that were on the rep list and declined, not me.
 
Poyser said:
I think subbing dead players back in is largely fine. You've just got to be a bit sensitive with it. I personally wouldn't sub back in a dead player that mafia have killed unless they give the ok, or that the sk kill unless they give the ok (if still alive). I'd also maybe not sub somebody in if mafia have extended great effort to get them lynched or somebody that is super pissed off about being lynched. Basically you don't want to negatively effect the game through subs. But if people get vigged/lynched then I think its generally alright
Click to expand...
Yeah it should be situational which is what I meant by under certain circumstances.

Realistically though just make games smaller if you can't fill them or think you'll complain when your game isn't active.
 
RDK said:
They get win/loss credit for their most recent alignment. That's how it's always worked. It's not like this is a new concept lol
Click to expand...
What do you mean "that's how it's always worked"? I've never seen it before on here
 
RDK said:
They get win/loss credit for their most recent alignment. That's how it's always worked. It's not like this is a new concept lol
Click to expand...

It's doable but it's very corny imo. Sub ins are a staple for necessity and same player subs should be a last resort. Might as well just run smaller games instead of replacing canon fodder with the same jerkoffs, makes the stakes better that way
 
Ultra said:
It's doable but it's very corny imo. Sub ins are a staple for necessity and same player subs should be a last resort. Might as well just run smaller games instead of replacing canon fodder with the same jerkoffs, makes the stakes better that way
Click to expand...
Agreed on smaller games
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top