Game Ranked OLF Christmas Mafia 2023 (Day 9)

[Lethal]

This note giving - if only we had an oracle

 

[Lethal]

Thoughts on my list @Ratchet @Flower @Hans Tweetenberg @Caldust

 

[Rugrat]

I mean he could be, I dislike his claim and usage, plus the mech result on him is pretty on the nose. The spanner in the works though is Fuji being targeted with a card/note last night iirc which gives me pause. Trouble is melkor ain't gonna lie about a result in a trade off for getting rid of ratchet

I think he is the card giver and this is intertwined with another role as scum BG.

 

[Flower]

This note giving - if only we had an oracle

Fr.

Also the coal.

 

[Flower]

Thoughts on my list @Ratchet @Flower @Hans Tweetenberg @Caldust

Disagree with the CP read else I'm pretty much with you. Granted if Ratchet is Town, CP needs to be revisited.

 

[Flower]

I like it when you're actually playing, Lethal. You have good insights, but people are too busy mislynching you all the time.

 

[Flower]

Disagree with the CP read else I'm pretty much with you. Granted if Ratchet is Town, CP needs to be revisited.

Oh yeah, and Luka is probably just scum, too.

 

[Lethal]

I very much enjoyed it my fellow Emet and Ysh'tola enjoyer <3

Happy New Year to you too brother.

Well he confirmed he got it. Haven't seen who he passed it to though if the story is to be believed

 

[Flower]

@Caldust where are you at with your reads?

 

[Ratchet]

Thoughts on my list @Ratchet @Flower @Hans Tweetenberg @Caldust

It's okay - I disagree on evans and I think your lack of read on Polar is very complacent, I think you're way off on Fuji and I'd say CP is more likely town than not, but you're not a million miles away from where I'm at.

 

[Flower]

Well he confirmed he got it. Haven't seen who he passed it to though if the story is to be believed

Prof lol.

 

[Lethal]

I like it when you're actually playing, Lethal. You have good insights, but people are too busy mislynching you all the time.

My nonsense and inactivity makes it easy lol

 

[Lethal]

It's okay - I disagree on evans and I think your lack of read on Polar is very complacent, I think you're way off on Fuji and I'd say CP is more likely town than not, but you're not a million miles away from where I'm at.

I can ISO polar if you'd like. I'll need whiskey though

 

[Lethal]

Prof lol.

Ah thanks

@Dr_Professor83 who did you pass the card to? You reptilian bastard you

 

[Ratchet]

I can ISO polar if you'd like. I'll need whiskey though

Probably a few glasses.

Basically my overall contention there is that he's so tepid and mailed in. Usually he's brash, even arrogant, especially when suspected. Instead he's slow rolling his way through and looks like he's just trying to tread water to late game.

 

[Flower]

My nonsense and inactivity makes it easy lol

I made it my mission to prevent the shit Lethal mislynches.

 

[Lord Melkor]

From that vote count I don't really feel the Ratchet direction has legs over Nibel, which is sad because Ratchet is the stronger read on thread play :

Ratchet came as viable option mostly after i came with mech on him, it seems.

 

[Ratchet]

I've noticed as scum he tends to lean into inactivity and apathy to survive as well, I think he's fairly, eh, polarised :^) as a player when it comes down to it.

Also his deference to voting the Indie day 1 was terrible.

 

[Rugrat]

15/6/1/1

1. Sky - Socks, PR Giver
2. heisenblaine Flower
4. Nibel | 花城 - Snow, VT
5. The Orca
6. Dr. Watson - Census
7. Gadministraitor
8. Caldust
10. Polar Bear
11. Tempest
12. Ratchet - Note Giver
13. Lethal - Miller
15. T-Pein™
16. Ekkologix - Vanilla Cop
19. Evans
20. Fujishiro
21. Dr_Professor83 - Survivor
23. The X
24. Ral
25. Kurosaki Ichigo
26. Wang Lord Melkor - Tracker
27. Luka
28. Hans Tweetenberg
30. One Last Username Magic

Blue = town, orange = wolfy, red = wolf. purple = indy. I have no read on my nulls. Orca/Bear just unreadable due to their posting. Ral I have hardly noticed and who is Ichigo?

• Nibel has mech on him and the defence has been atrocious. Yeah it's similar to Fang but fuck, this isn't how he was last game when sussed.
• CP perfectly capable of distancing from Gram and pushing an execute over Poyser. Also clever enough to target less likely players for a janitor shot. Hasn't really pushed anything of note for mine
• Ratchet spends more time arguing with Flower than solving and I find his claim and usage on the nose.
• Pein just treading water and not looking to solve
• Fuji being used as Ratchet's go to and seen nothing impressive
• Magic's read back and limited input has been garbage from my pov.

Sky, Caldust, Retro, Ekko, Melkor and Tweet are locked town core for mine. Others are open for re-evaluation into my POE.

I agree with all of this besides Luka. I’m giving time to Magic in the interest that he was busy/drunk so wait for him to contribute

 

[Lethal]

vote lynch nibel

consider it mech

This was on Day 1 fwiw. Came from nowhere at a time when it was Fang v Luka. The fact he's now doubling down on it is even more on the nose.