Here's something constructive to consider
In theory it's a valid tactic (imho) — it's just that it's misused frequently (...T-P)
In practice, the way you play it is important to avoid throwing and causing further conflict of people's reads of you. It ended up being detrimental to town.
If you want to play this way, I'd say your next approach is just scumhunting & townhunting like you would as an indie. It creates an air of suspicion without just stating arbitrary shit through trolling - I get bait reactions, but it's a negative because it induces further paranoia.
Get into that indie mindset to keep scum on their toes, but don't lean into your indie meta so much you risk getting lynched. Things you don't say out loud.
You may have a higher success rate if you ever do use it as a tactic since you've now proven you can have on the nose reads in hindsight now! Fuck yeah