• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked OLF Christmas Mafia 2023 (Day 9)

Promising to side-eye anyone who randomly unvotes any time soon
Unvote

IMG-1621.jpg

 
Well for the very same reasons I'm more leaning she's scummy but it also isn't super strong basis. I'm not super invested in saving or lynching her either way; I see her slot as one that will need to be resolved just for clarity's sake alone.

And Luka?

To recap-
If you are not attached to the idea of lynching her, why require another case to shift your vote?
For the rest:
Well I also realize this could be a honeytrap and bait. DV itself is NAI in the claim alone. Why do you prefer Luka to Sky?

I think I am finally adjusting my expectations for her posts to be always scummy nonsense and feel like she's ultimately more likely town for one of the reasons you highlighted - she's actually trying to stick her nose into commenting on everything going on instead of just sticking to a game plan or whats in the realm of personal concern.

Not a very strong read though
Ult also gave a case as to why Sky could potentially be town, but you insisted instead that you need to hear the case on why Luka is scum

There's no real validity to stacking a vote then claiming the vote doesn't imply a stance is being taken on the slot
By voting someone, you are taking a stance. You are wanting to rid a slot you feel right about. You're making a call. Pretending or implying otherwise is dishonest

If you were not deadset on a slot and felt it should be resolved later in the game (which also implies it isn't an immediate threat) you don't need to even slap a vote on it
 
"This slot shouldn't weasel on by and I don't think that it'll self-resolve btw so keep an eye. No strong feelings for it so far"

vs

"This slot shouldn't weasel on by but I don't have a strong feeling about this, [vote slot]"
Therein lies the problem
 
To recap-

For the rest:



Ult also gave a case as to why Sky could potentially be town, but you insisted instead that you need to hear the case on why Luka is scum

There's no real validity to stacking a vote then claiming the vote doesn't imply a stance is being taken on the slot
By voting someone, you are taking a stance. You are wanting to rid a slot you feel right about. You're making a call. Pretending or implying otherwise is dishonest

If you were not deadset on a slot and felt it should be resolved later in the game (which also implies it isn't an immediate threat) you don't need to even slap a vote on it
You are literally being dumb here. I scum read Sky for the same reasons Ultra justifies her being so bad he sees her as town. Therefore why would I move my vote off a player I don't identify with town reading to someone I have as a blank (Luka) until I hear Ultra's reasoning besides threatening to help lynch me.

Anyway looking forward to Gram being 0-4 on reading me :banderas
 
You are literally being dumb here. I scum read Sky for the same reasons Ultra justifies her being so bad he sees her as town. Therefore why would I move my vote off a player I don't identify with town reading to someone I have as a blank (Luka) until I hear Ultra's reasoning besides threatening to help lynch me.

Anyway looking forward to Gram being 0-4 on reading me :banderas
Gram isn’t even the one pushing you :jerrykek
 
Can we be real for one moment

If you don't like playing here with this group why did you sign up, like why give yourself the additional stress
I hate seeing you feel like you can't have fun

You clearly ran the risks and rewards through your head and you decided from the getgo there was little reward to doing... well, anything. I don't understand being this belligerent and obstructive

You clearly understand it paints a poorer impression of you and no matter how many times I shout how much I adore you into the void, you'll continue to dig your own hole by passive aggressively taking pot shots throughout the game
It's not pretty to watch

I want Dr_Shitpost83 back
 
i think Aurelian is probably town here, for similar reasons I believed BPD was town - as he (from a brief read has a lot of apathy, that only really is noticeable for forlorn town).

The fact that he believes his role is an absolute reason for not lynching him does reconcile with town play. He simply can’t see any reconciliation that his play could be scum. As mafia, you’re probably gonna be looking for common ground with people you’re trying to persuade to agree with you - so I think it would be easier to get him to concede his play is scummy. If you couple all the play based reasons with a very potent role, which he knows he can’t do any hero BS with - I’d strongly favour keeping him around.

Poyser is the chief driver of the wagon and him saying he thinks the first four players on the wagon are town is useful to know.
 
You are literally being dumb here. I scum read Sky for the same reasons Ultra justifies her being so bad he sees her as town. Therefore why would I move my vote off a player I don't identify with town reading to someone I have as a blank (Luka) until I hear Ultra's reasoning besides threatening to help lynch me.

Anyway looking forward to Gram being 0-4 on reading me :banderas

Good to know you have no concerns I’m trying to mislynch you!
 
Can we be real for one moment

If you don't like playing here with this group why did you sign up, like why give yourself the additional stress
I hate seeing you feel like you can't have fun

You clearly ran the risks and rewards through your head and you decided from the getgo there was little reward to doing... well, anything. I don't understand being this belligerent and obstructive

You clearly understand it paints a poorer impression of you and no matter how many times I shout how much I adore you into the void, you'll continue to dig your own hole by passive aggressively taking pot shots throughout the game
It's not pretty to watch

I want Dr_Shitpost83 back
Dr. Watson, I ensure you this IS me having fun!

(Genuinely I am having a lot of fun right now and this IS shitposting lol. I don’t know what gave you the impression I’m not lol. There was like 5 minutes I wasn’t when I was dealing with Ekko but he’s not even posting and he’s not talking to me anymore!)

(I also completely disagree I’m being belligerent and obstructive. I’ve been cheeky but nothing I’m doing is obstructing anything. Nor am I taking “pot shots”. You clearly just have no way of reading my intentions lol)
 
@Grammaton

You said that you believed that BPD giving up which is often a town tell, wasn’t something to use in his favour because you stated he’d repped into a poor spot.

In light of the fact that Aurelian has not repped into a poor spot, do you think this makes him more likely to be town?
 
Back
Top