• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked OLF Christmas Mafia 2023 (Day 9)

Unless Bachi was the Watcher or they used their Ninja. Why would they kill Ultra who just pushed the Execute? That‘s nonsense. A Serial doesn‘t kill Alco there either.
You're making assumptions that fot what you want the answers to be, you do realise that right. Like the answers are there
 
Fang, Bachi, Poyser, Sigis…with 4 Townies killed a Serial doesn‘t target Alco the Cop. They aim to hit scum. Ultra just pushed the Exe, so he‘s the best target. He‘s also unlikely to be protected. Just like Alco was unlikely to be protected after the protect was modkilled. Perfect time to use a Ninja kill on Alco.
 
Fang, Bachi, Poyser, Sigis…with 4 Townies killed a Serial doesn‘t target Alco the Cop. They aim to hit scum. Ultra just pushed the Exe, so he‘s the best target. He‘s also unlikely to be protected. Just like Alco was unlikely to be protected after the protect was modkilled. Perfect time to use a Ninja kill on Alco.
Again, you're making assumptions favourable to what you want the outcome to be. I also must point out that there are several assumptions at play for the result on me that you've made to make it scum indicative, I dont really think you believe I was any more likely to be Vigged than Luka or that I was the true counter wagon to Poyser when CP himself said it was to claim.
 
Again, you're making assumptions favourable to what you want the outcome to be. I also must point out that there are several assumptions at play for the result on me that you've made to make it scum indicative, I dont really think you believe I was any more likely to be Vigged than Luka or that I was the true counter wagon to Poyser when CP himself said it was to claim.
Yeah, I just managed to exclude a Bus Drive here. Safe to assume it didn‘t happen.
 
Yeah, I just managed to exclude a Bus Drive here. Safe to assume it didn‘t happen.
Also I have to ask, if I'm bodyguard I have that as claimable, so why not claim it yesterday when I would have thought it was safe, Siggy flipped after day 2 after I'd claimed

See, lots of silly assumptions I'm having to put up with designed to make your theory right, nothing I can do with that
 
Like the thought process is that I'd have a doctor fake and choose to go with note passer, of all things.

It can't really be any more plain, at a certain point you either accept reality or you continue making more assumptions to fit what you want to believe, you're at that point now.
 
Also I have to ask, if I'm bodyguard I have that as claimable, so why not claim it yesterday when I would have thought it was safe, Siggy flipped after day 2 after I'd claimed

See, lots of silly assumptions I'm having to put up with designed to make your theory right, nothing I can do with that
I mean, you can be that or even an Inventor/gift giver with a vest as one of your gifts and the card was just one of them.

Fact is, assuming Alco was not the scum kill is just pure nonsense. Ofc he was. You‘re making bad assumptions instead of seeing the obvious which, from a Town you PoV is either Melkor was redirected or he‘s lying.
 
Evans obviously has no interest in whether he's right or wrong because he's engaging in a bad faith tunnel because he thinks that mirrors his town game, he proposed doing exactly that with Flower last game and has history of it as scum, he is overselling the shit out of it, I don't really see any further reason to engage him with this.
 
I mean, you can be that or even an Inventor/gift giver with a vest as one of your gifts and the card was just one of them.

Fact is, assuming Alco was not the scum kill is just pure nonsense. Ofc he was. You‘re making bad assumptions instead of seeing the obvious which, from a Town you PoV is either Melkor was redirected or he‘s lying.
Ah, see now I'm giving gifts beyond d passing a card around that I then target myself with, so now the original premise isn't viable you move onto the next thing you can think of to argue why you're right.

You (this is to the room) can see why I said she's arguing in bad faith, that's pretty much the definition of it.
 
I mean, you can be that or even an Inventor/gift giver with a vest as one of your gifts and the card was just one of them.

Fact is, assuming Alco was not the scum kill is just pure nonsense. Ofc he was. You‘re making bad assumptions instead of seeing the obvious which, from a Town you PoV is either Melkor was redirected or he‘s lying.
Also Melkor could be redirected yes, or there is another explanation. I don't have the answer and I don't think scum Melkor lies about the results because he's nervous as hell as scum. I've just seen him as scum first hand.

You kind of say it there - you're assuming the kill firstly which isn't scientific given it's not as clear cut as you present it. I feel like in general the Mafia kill tends to be displayed first in games too but that's w/e
 
Ah, see now I'm giving gifts beyond d passing a card around that I then target myself with, so now the original premise isn't viable you move onto the next thing you can think of to argue why you're right.

You (this is to the room) can see why I said she's arguing in bad faith, that's pretty much the definition of it.
I mean, I‘m not the one arguing scums killed the guy who fucked up all game and was lynch bait over the outed Cop when the protect just flipped :jerrykek.
 
I‘m done for tonight.

I get accused for making bad assumptions for saying the Cop is the obvious scum kill.

Fucking KEK.
 
I mean, I‘m not the one arguing scums killed the guy who fucked up all game and was lynch bait over the outed Cop when the protect just flipped :jerrykek.
You act like it's outrageous to suggest a player who is probably right on several reads gets killed after they serve their purpose, it's scum 101
 
You act like it's outrageous to suggest a player who is probably right on several reads gets killed after they serve their purpose, it's scum 101
Not when there‘s a fucking outed Cop who would have 2 nights of results.
 
Back
Top