• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked OLF Members Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
RDK said:
Do you think Hime would have agreed to thunderdome them in that scenario?
Click to expand...

It would have to be high level of bussing which would be extremally risky approach for a team that lost 3 members.

Especially that there were other people Hime could duel which are in POE.
 
Luka said:
> Okay, this seems like Ultra is town based on the games I have played with him.
> I am not a PR. No worries! Even though I am LARPing I do not do this, there are certain restrictions even I will not do and that is one of them.
> The above post. Where is your question coming from? That is odd. It was not a thought that came to me. It was a general observation over how she dissects things. It is far too early for cases, she is a lot like me where she slowburns and takes mental notes on players. She could build a case...
> By the way it does not matter though. You just seen to be town hunting based on character spec. I would not he too comfortable playing alongside anyone in that way. I do agree that Ratchet is most likely Town to be clear. You just need to be more proactively guarded as you will be pocketed...
> Yes. The point was read to past the kweh's/PR or whatever and see how he's engaging with others and if you sense there's someone he's emulating. Post restrictions/quirks alone tells us nothing in my opinion. For example, why would a PR be something one would want to make it easier for them...
> You said the CP wagon stunk, yes? 1. Which players on it smell moldy 2. Thought exercise: Which players smell moldy on insisting Ultra is in his scum meta 3. What other wagons (or solo votes) smell like rotten meat 4. I townread you, should I extend olive branches and trust fall with you? 5...

>.<
Not very fancy formatting, but first 5 pages what immediently struck out to me. There is the reasons I mentioned above, but they just feel to genuinly be trying to solve the game. Id also like to compare the coasting last game and borderline conf bias to how investigative are this game. They're asking questions and trying to solve, getting into the nitty gritty which is townie.
Click to expand...

Who are you responding to here?
 
In fact, genuine question for everyone: Where does your PoE go after I flip town? What will change about your view of the game?
 
Sky said:
In fact, genuine question for everyone: Where does your PoE go after I flip town? What will change about your view of the game?
Click to expand...

I do not think my POE would change that much, i would look at people pushing you.

Propably some scum are hiding behind vanilla claims.
 
Magic said:
1) Retro
2) RDK
3) Ekko
4) CraigPelton
5) Nibel
7) The Orca
8) Tweet
11) Hime
13) Aurelian
14) Flower
15) Grammaton
16) Sky
17) T-Pein
18) Xadlin
19) Lethal
20) Evans
21) Rej
22) Psychic
23) Ratchet
24) Luka
25) Lord Melkor

out of the nulls i think rdk/evans look best out of them but rdk because of this phase, some of which can be faked and im somewhat worried he's distancing with cp and evans due to claim alone really.

gram i think has been weaker this phase than last and a lot of his targets i feel were town players, but most of what he's doing and saying resembles his town play. there is some reservations but ill hold those to myself to see if it stacks up. @Grammaton would you agree on the town sky read based on what i said before about her blaming gad for the mislynch opposed to looking to blame living town players.

also i have xaldin as town but i just remembered he's an absolute wild card with his claims in games(in fairy tale i recall he just claimed tracker result on someone with no discussion and for no reason). the fact it's called creep though and the way he gave it kinda looks towny.

luka has looked town to me. dont think he's been angling too hard in any one direction but im not really familiar with his scum play either.

ekko could be town and just be his annoying self but after last game/when he was dying it was pointed out why he was being lynched and how it didn't resemble his town game and he could be trying to play into that. also his play around cp and just avoiding that situation almost entirely while also acting ignorant of the cop/hider/desperado stuff is stupid as well as him just concluding im scum. the gad hammer wasn't the best either.

hime is amazing.
Click to expand...
This was Magics only point against Sky I believe and I don't really think it's a good point.

As scum in the last game on WS, Sky basically said that it was Ekko's fault that he got lynched for playing terribly
 
Lord Melkor said:
I did not read everything in that Hades gams since i subbed after day 1, but Tweet was the deepest scum there i think. Did he play differently there than he plays here? Is he someone concious of his meta?
Click to expand...
A number of people who are familiar with me have commented that I'm completely unlike last game so make of that what you will
 
Actually I think evans said he was scum that game and he was the one that would be to blame so probably can disregard that
 
RDK said:
This was Magics only point against Sky I believe and I don't really think it's a good point.

As scum in the last game on WS, Sky basically said that it was Ekko's fault that he got lynched for playing terribly
Click to expand...
*point in favor of
 
RDK said:
Luka had 4 scum reads in Hades before being lynched so I don't really buy that they just think everyone here is town, especially when there are reasonable reasons to suspect a good chunk of the people here
Click to expand...
Wrong. I only had one scum read, the rest was just Poe.
 
Luka said:
Wrong. I only had one scum read, the rest was just Poe.
Click to expand...
Same thing. You said once you were lynched to lynch through three players to win the game and that the rest was town. That's a solve and displays evidence of paranoia on slots other than those you have town.

You have nowhere near to a solve here and are just town reading everyone except melkor. It's completely different. Not only do you not seem concerned about any of the slots that are yet to be solved, you don't really seem to be trying to solve them.

We still need to find 3 scum at minimum, I just don't buy your everything is fine everyone is townie demeanor while I sit here piling through pages of past games trying to find ways to help me clear people because I keep finding new ways not to trust them.

Maybe it's just a contrast in our approaches, I can't really know that until I see you flip though.
 
I haven't been impressed with anything Luka has said today. He's in a good position to solve and provide something to make him readable and it's almost entirely just apathy. Utter garbage.

Kweh
 
RDK said:
This was Magics only point against Sky I believe and I don't really think it's a good point.

As scum in the last game on WS, Sky basically said that it was Ekko's fault that he got lynched for playing terribly
Click to expand...
Really I feel I was playing my town game that game, Poyser had to remind me that I had to focus more on the task at hand rather than doing something that would "make sense" for me as town

I don't feel that as any alignment I'm in the business of blaming anyone and hindsight heroing when it's just a fact that a townie got themselves mislynched by playing awfully
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top