Game Ranked OLF Members Mafia

[Lord Melkor]

Strictly on an individual basis, this is what I've got:

Scum - Xadlin, Luka, hime
Town - Flower, Melkor, T-Pein

That leaves Tweet, Retro, Lethal.

Of those 3, I think Lethal is most likely to be town.

I'd like everyone to do something similar to the above to establish a consensus - my consideration today is twofold. A scum flip is obviously ideal, but I'm also trying to consider what a playable LyLo would look like, because we should be 7v3 today. At worst, 6v3v1 but I think Sky not being Indie more or less puts that to bed.

Need to try and make the PoE take the lead today to an extent, don't throw any votes around yet please.

Kweh

I have similar POE though I would add Tweet to scum category. He was a bit a bit more active yesterday, propably would be good to ISO him, do not have time right now, busy with work.

From the roles perspective, i think scum should be between duelist, Xadlin as information gathering role and the vanilla claims.

 

[Lethal]

Vote: Tweet

 

[Lord Melkor]

Ultra. Was 1-shot. I fucked up misreading the role. It was pointless.

This role does not seem that strong - you only get a list of targets, not the order? Why is it one shot while cop is 3 shot?

 

[Lord Melkor]

so no one, at fucking all, considered the evans census bullshit scenario?

i was actually getting somewhere with that?
me of all people?

No. I considered it (as it was i did as scum census in other game), i think i was not the only one?

 

[Lord Melkor]

Yes but I asked you
1. If no second indie, do the scum numbers change
2. Why or why not
3. Should a secondary POE be created that diffentitates those numbers
4. What changes if it's not a 6 man scum team

Etc etc

I am leaning towards the number of indies being inflated. 7 persons scum team seems a bit too much? Unless there is traitor type role - but Sky was the biggest candidate there.

 

[Lord Melkor]

hime/tweet never voted wolves but voted town. also hime's usage was selfish and could've been done to remove CP. duelist is NAI

Good point.

I think I would solve Hime sooner or later. I had her slightly town earlier but voting history should be important factor at this stage of the game. Also I think duelist works as scum role in this setup.

vote lynch Hime

 

[hime]

Good point.

I think I would solve Hime sooner or later. I had her slightly town earlier but voting history should be important factor at this stage of the game. Also I think duelist works as scum role in this setup.

vote lynch Hime

It's not a good point
It's literally not even true

 

[Luka]

Strictly on an individual basis, this is what I've got:

Scum - Xadlin, Luka, hime
Town - Flower, Melkor, T-Pein

That leaves Tweet, Retro, Lethal.

Of those 3, I think Lethal is most likely to be town.

I'd like everyone to do something similar to the above to establish a consensus - my consideration today is twofold. A scum flip is obviously ideal, but I'm also trying to consider what a playable LyLo would look like, because we should be 7v3 today. At worst, 6v3v1 but I think Sky not being Indie more or less puts that to bed.

Need to try and make the PoE take the lead today to an extent, don't throw any votes around yet please.

Kweh

Team is Melkor + Lethal +1
Didn’t realize lethal was alive

 

[Luka]

Im fairly confident we vote lethal here.

 

[Luka]

vote lynch lethal

 

[Ratchet]

Im fairly confident we vote lethal here.

Nah.

Kweh

 

[Luka]

Lethal & Melkor have very much been slipping under the radar. I’m fine with either of them flipping.

 

[Luka]

Nah.

Kweh

What townie thing have they done all game. There d3 or w/e was horrible

 

[Ratchet]

What townie thing have they done all game. There d3 or w/e was horrible

Well I am quite confident Melkor is town, Lethal I would also say is probably town too. No buys, not going to happen today

Kweh

 

[Lord Melkor]

It's not a good point
It's literally not even true

Okay, but I would need to check at what point you voted scum. At some point it was obvious CP and Evans are done.

 

[Luka]

Well I am quite confident Melkor is town, Lethal I would also say is probably town too. No buys, not going to happen today

Kweh

But what have they done townie all game you’re not answering me

 

[Flower]

But what have they done townie all game you’re not answering me

Gram has a god read on the guy. Said he liked him.

 

[Ratchet]

But what have they done townie all game you’re not answering me

They've voted scum and co-operated, Melkor especially. I don't know why you think, after basically not playing the game, that you can just insist we lynch someone without any real case behind it and that it will ever go over? Like what games are you used to that that actually flies?

Kweh

 

[Luka]

Gram has a god read on the guy. Said he liked him.

I’ve seen “god reads” be wrong before: IE: tinyhunt on mu.

 

[Luka]

They've voted scum and co-operated, Melkor especially. I don't know why you think, after basically not playing the game, that you can just insist we lynch someone without any real case behind it and that it will ever go over? Like what games are you used to that that actually flies?

Kweh

Okay starting to get a bit fiesty. I’m sorry if you ignored every single one of my posts but I have been playing the game and copperating. Much more than Melkor at the very least. Sod is at 1am for some god forsaken reason but just because I’m not there & I’m not operating to your beck and call doesn’t mean I’m not playing the game. And I did vote scum, vote was on cp d1 and d2.