• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked OLF Members Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
im-not-gonna-be-that-girl-monica-sherer.gif
:hmm
 
I really don't think this mech is reliable. It feels like a trap to me - it only requires Flower to have been targeted by anything to be explained away, basing the lynch around it and throwing out the thread play is just dumb. @RDK This is not how you read Flower - you're not factoring in emotion to her responses where she's wont to lash out at people suspecting her. You're focusing on her logic which is going to be easy to beat. I'm going to ask for some faith in my ability here - I really don't think she's scum.

I'd like to circle back to Evans/Alco. I'm just going to lay out my considerations and the room can decide from there:

Vote Watson
vote Gad

as town leader I think he should be pushed and I think he did a big silly

Both of these are from Day 1. He also jumped onto Retro when he could and beat her down with a few posts, in retrospect it looks bad because not only does he never vote for CP (I'm not even sure he mentions him), it feels to me like he piggy-backed onto my push, and once that faded out, he went onto the next one.

Blast Magic or CP tbh
Coming into Day 2 and he pretty much immediately suspects CP for /reasons/. This is pretty much a carbon copy of what Magic was talking about yesterday - slots that had nothing to say about CP originally and then came into Day 2 with the knives out ready.

How does that confirm you though?

Town leader disapproves.

You being so self aware of this meta and acting like it’s confirmed is absolutely something a scum player would do lol
And this is the kicker for me - he immediately latches onto Flower the moment she gets some pressure. If he thought CP was scum, why is he spending real estate on pushing Flower instead of getting CP shot? To me, it looks like he has been pushing every "bad" direction available and while no townie is infallible, there has to be a cut off somewhere and yesterday's posts are past that point. I am quite certain he'd be voting for her now if he were still playing.

After him, I am coming around to X being scum. I had Psychic at lean town, but I can see the angle, and there was a lack of OMGUS from Psychic. I also think Orca fits the plausible scum mould - he's currently voting for Flower despite his tunnel target Sky proposing it. I had first hand experience of being his tunnel target last game, and he will just go against anything you say regardless of how sensible it is. It doesn't line up at all.

Kweh!
 
I really don't think this mech is reliable. It feels like a trap to me - it only requires Flower to have been targeted by anything to be explained away, basing the lynch around it and throwing out the thread play is just dumb. @RDK This is not how you read Flower - you're not factoring in emotion to her responses where she's wont to lash out at people suspecting her. You're focusing on her logic which is going to be easy to beat. I'm going to ask for some faith in my ability here - I really don't think she's scum.

I'd like to circle back to Evans/Alco. I'm just going to lay out my considerations and the room can decide from there:




Both of these are from Day 1. He also jumped onto Retro when he could and beat her down with a few posts, in retrospect it looks bad because not only does he never vote for CP (I'm not even sure he mentions him), it feels to me like he piggy-backed onto my push, and once that faded out, he went onto the next one.


Coming into Day 2 and he pretty much immediately suspects CP for /reasons/. This is pretty much a carbon copy of what Magic was talking about yesterday - slots that had nothing to say about CP originally and then came into Day 2 with the knives out ready.


And this is the kicker for me - he immediately latches onto Flower the moment she gets some pressure. If he thought CP was scum, why is he spending real estate on pushing Flower instead of getting CP shot? To me, it looks like he has been pushing every "bad" direction available and while no townie is infallible, there has to be a cut off somewhere and yesterday's posts are past that point. I am quite certain he'd be voting for her now if he were still playing.

After him, I am coming around to X being scum. I had Psychic at lean town, but I can see the angle, and there was a lack of OMGUS from Psychic. I also think Orca fits the plausible scum mould - he's currently voting for Flower despite his tunnel target Sky proposing it. I had first hand experience of being his tunnel target last game, and he will just go against anything you say regardless of how sensible it is. It doesn't line up at all.

Kweh!
Yes- but until we know she's been targeted by something else. I'm going to be voting to lynch her.

Right now there is a claimed visitor on her that is our vig, she survived. Either because she's hime, or the godfather.

That's what I'm playing with.

It's not personal, it's just me doing what I think is the right thing to do right now statistically.

You all can do whatever else you want.

If you want another direction from me look at my reads list.
 
Okay as for my claim

Character is Dofla
I'm a seraph knight that's automatically bound to the character of Hime, but also I can (x-shot) check players to see if they are thet character
Orca is not Hime, is all I know

Anyone surviving a vig shot raises alarm bells for me, which is why I felt bad about Aurelian D2
How would you target flower last night automatically based on this claim
 
Yes- but until we know she's been targeted by something else. I'm going to be voting to lynch her.

Right now there is a claimed visitor on her that is our vig, she survived. Either because she's hime, or the godfather.

That's what I'm playing with.

It's not personal, it's just me doing what I think is the right thing to do right now statistically.

You all can do whatever else you want.

If you want another direction from me look at my reads list.
Garbage. You're relying on tenuous mechanical evidence and then refuse to budge using it as a crutch. This is not how one plays as town, unreasonably stubborn.

Kweh!
 
Garbage. You're relying on tenuous mechanical evidence and then refuse to budge using it as a crutch. This is not how one plays as town, unreasonably stubborn.

Kweh!
Yes I've given a full read list yet I'm using someone being shot and surving as a crutch

Your play has been shocking today
 
We should pursue the flower direction then given that nibels shot is confirmed and Xadlin gives some credence to him not having been blocked. I don't think ignoring mech is the right thing to do right now

I think focusing on Flower is a waste of time. She should be town.
 
Yes I've given a full read list yet I'm using someone being shot and surving as a crutch

Your play has been shocking today
LMAO, I'll take that as a compliment. I liked your reads list for the most part, you insisting that you're just going to vote one player and stick to it is horrible.

Kweh!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top