• We're looking for artists. Direct message Dr. Watson for more info!

Game Ranked OLF Members Mafia

Status
Not open for further replies.
Reader mode
Yeah I'm more willing to stake this game on a Xadlin flip personally but I understand if people decide on Luka in the end

I'm not sure what other things are throwing me off on Lu's slot or it's just me having to transition into a scum read after assuming blindly hime wasn't trolling
I get being frustrated with the game and I'm going to assume she mainly did it because it was a fuck you to a wolf Ratchet, but goddamn

But I've also wanted Xad for ages and he's managed to just scrape by without really any dire consequences which I don't like
Anything and everything I had come to a conclusion over with Lu's slot was attached to a scime, gonna also have to re-evaluate that big time
 
Dr. Watson said:
Yeah I'm more willing to stake this game on a Xadlin flip personally but I understand if people decide on Luka in the end
Click to expand...
Music to my ears!

But yeah I mean I think there is a good chance both are scum and I don't think Luka has done much out of urgency today. The whole game feels like it's slow rolling though, probably to avoid hammer so I think the track is correct.

Kweh!
 
Dr. Watson said:
a lightbulb went off but idk why my brain thinks it's relevant

He said he hid behind Mel(k) - was adamant that he left a hint and everything despite people disagreeing

Why give such a weak and odd hint, specifically a pun no one would immediately catch and he himself had to point out?
Why Mel?

Don't ask me why this is sticking out to me, someone else do the rest of the work
Click to expand...

I was one of sussed players day 1 and was engaging with Craig - he was perhaps thinking it would work from the perspective of town hider who he was pretending to be.
 
Dr. Watson said:
Strongest (widely read) town reads out of all these are:
Ratchet, Flower

Weaker town reads:
Lethal, Mel, myself

Scum reads:
Luka, Tweet

Seeing as there's apparently a different voting technique I wasn't aware of this game, I'm not sure how to analyze this and it's pissing me off
Click to expand...

I am not sure what "voting techniques" you speak about here. Common scum tactic is to spread for example, so not all team members are on the same wagon. Here for example Luka was avoiding hammering Hime while Tweet hammered at last moment- both are my main scum reads, i see yours as well.
 
That was just in regards to Luka's votes, he does do it less conventionally
Ergo, I can't really take anything from it when it comes to his slot
 
Dr. Watson said:
You're gonna have to build a better case against Melkor since I'm the only one with my foil hat on regarding his slot (I struggle not TRing him) rn

I don't want to make the same mistake I made previously with Sky by not simply listening to a potential alternative that should've been given more consideration, especially this phase

Today can only go one of two ways, I doubt it'll deviate from you unless Xad does something that makes you look impressive by comparison

So here:
1. Quote the top five posts (or link, if you prefer) that stuck out to you, though I'd prefer you format it
for the sake of readability
2. Show us, don't tell us. Show us why you think Mel is evil. I don't remember any points you made against him that were loud enough to really retain at all.
3. Explain why Mel of all people stick out to you.
Click to expand...
The problem is I have 0 clue why they're town. They have not done a single townie thing all game. There reads feel TMIish with the fact that they're applying some criteira to people and not others(calling Ekko out for low posting but not Psychic), and it just feels really eerie. I do not think they give this much of a shit as town. (IE: HxH Game on WG)
 
Lord Melkor said:
I said it basically in my opening post today.

Your POE yesterday was bad and ISOS were going nowhere - do you have any new thoughts?
Click to expand...
And how were they going nowhere? It made me singlehandidly hesitate on Lethal. The only other one was on you which, from my perspective offered good points. Also, bad POE's aren't evil indicative.
 
Xadlin said:
I creeped on flower last night and he got visited.

who it was, i dont know, but flower got visited by someone.

care to elaborate @Flower
Click to expand...
This is the biggest point t for me with Xadlin. He just *knows* Flower is under pressure this day and asks her to explain something that, as per his own results, isn't remotely damning. It doesn't make any sense. His stated reasoning was he town read Flower I believe, so why does her being targeted with something arouse his suspicion. Forget the lack of modkill which can go either way, this is the key.

Kweh
 
Luka said:
The problem is I have 0 clue why they're town. They have not done a single townie thing all game. There reads feel TMIish with the fact that they're applying some criteira to people and not others(calling Ekko out for low posting but not Psychic), and it just feels really eerie. I do not think they give this much of a shit as town. (IE: HxH Game on WG)
Click to expand...
What? Psychic low posting isn‘t an issue, she does that all the time. Ekko is usually Top poster, so why would him low posting be on the same level as Psychic doing it?
 
Reader mode
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top